News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by spacehome on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:17AM (#10953569)
That's not your fault; most anybody who reads about quantum physics from most sources will be baffled by it because most authors are thoroughly confused themselves.

Look up the Many-Worlds Interpretation. I won't say it's the truth, but it's the most plausible theory available. The math is relatively straightforward, and it gives a deterministic and understandable explanation of what's going on. Denying Many-Worlds necessitates the invention of the philosophical equivalent of epicycles upon epicycles.

I've learned that any article or paper that posits something strange going on without even mentioning Many-Worlds is simply not worth the ink it's written with.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by n4r9 on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:58PM (#10954785)
Many-Worlds has flaws comparable to many other leading interpretations, which is why it's not a large majority view among quantum information and foundations researchers. Explaining why the observable universe is Born-rule typical is a major issue for Many-Worlds.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/9703089.pdf is a good discussion of this issue, which I don't think has yet had a satisfactory rebuttal. A more up to date version is at http://arxiv.org/abs/0905.0624

It's silly to insist that every article about quantum phenomena should refer to any particular interpretation of the mathematics.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by spacehome on Saturday January 23, 2016 @07:58AM (#10958230)
I thought that explaining the Born rule is a problem for every interpretation.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by n4r9 on Monday January 25, 2016 @11:19AM (#10967989)
It is for many, but not all. Generally speaking, it's less of an issue for interpretations that give an epistemic role to the wavefunction.

Perhaps an extreme example, but in the "QBist" interpretation the wavefunction and Born rule are merely a convenient calculus for the prediction of future interactions with the system. It's not the only way to encode this probabilistic information, but it's nice and compact. The issue is then not "why the Born rule?" but "why this particular set of probabilities over potential outcomes?".

Then again, a lot of people find the very idea of epistemic interpretations of quantum theory distasteful, especially in light of the Bell, Kochen-Specker and PBR type inequalities.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by ThomPete on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:35AM (#10953724)
But doesn't many-world interpretation still require a leap of faith though?
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by spacehome on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:48AM (#10953813)
No? At least not any more than any other theory in science. It's a mathematical model that makes predictions. When the predictions stop matching experiment, then we can throw it away.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by guscost on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:20PM (#10954075)
The difference with an interpretation like MWI is that no experiment can disprove it, even in theory. The interpretation requires that the many worlds do not interact, and unless that changes, there is no way to observe anything contradictory to the interpretation that doesn't also contradict QM. Most other famous science theories are falsifiable (I would say it is a necessary condition to qualify as science).
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by Strilanc on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:37PM (#10954636)
> The interpretation requires that the many worlds do not interact

...What? In MWI, interactions between "worlds" is the mechanism for all the quantum effects. If they never interacted, it'd give the wrong predictions.

Also, many proponents of MWI (e.g. Sean Carroll) don't think of the theory in terms of worlds at all. It's just a name that stuck. Really it's just what you get when you infer the Born rule from the unitarity postulate instead of having the Born rule as an extra postulate.

An intuition pump for this idea is: you probably think photons passing the point of no return and escape our Hubble bubble continue to exist. But you'll never ever see them again, even in principle! Wouldn't a model that says they simply get deleted out of reality be strictly simpler in terms of number of entities and therefore be preferred? Assuming a rule that simply deletes parts of the wave function that decohere away from us (i.e. collapse) is pretty analogous to that ( See: http://lesswrong.com/lw/pb/belief_in_the_implied_invisible/ ). Getting rid of the photon-deletion rule is analogous to accepting MWI (though I don't mean to imply it's the only game in town).

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by guscost on Friday January 22, 2016 @05:25PM (#10955970)
I guess what I mean is that coherent outcomes in any of the other worlds cannot be observed from our world, leaving us with nothing but the same observations predicted by QM in general. This could probably be said with a lot more rigor.

Framing the MWI as conceptually simpler than the other popular interpretations is a very interesting approach. I've read a few of Eliezer's essays along those lines, and I think he has a compelling point.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by pjscott on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:30PM (#10954159)
It's a mathematical model that makes observable predictions. It's easily falsifiable: just show that its predictions are false.

Now, you could argue that there's no test to distinguish it from other interpretations of quantum mechanics, but that applies to them as well.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by guscost on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:30PM (#10954167)
Which predictions of the MWI are observable?

> It's a mathematical model that makes observable predictions.

It sounds like you're talking about QM itself, not any interpretation.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by Moshe_Silnorin on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:12PM (#10954474)
QM, itself, predicts macroscopic decoherence. Many worlds is more a prediction of QM than an interpretation.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by guscost on Friday January 22, 2016 @05:34PM (#10956013)
Great way to present it, but we're still talking about a prediction that can't be tested, even in theory.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by ThomPete on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:15PM (#10954495)
It makes mathematical predictions perhaps but thats not enough as far as I understand to claim that you can make predictions in any normal sense of that word. And therefore the Parent I was originally responding to at least from my understanding is claiming something thats not telling the whole story.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by ThomPete on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:14PM (#10954017)
Maybe I am wrong but as far as I understand thats not really the issue here.

As far as I understand there are 3 types of competing interpretations all trying to deal with the local universe vs. the non-local one and trying to explain them in a way that make sense.

1) Logically consistent, allow us to make predictions but which requires a leap of faith (Many World interpretation)

2) Mathematically correct but does not allow us to make predictions (string theory)

3) Allow us to make predictions, doesn't require leap of faith but isn't logically consistent all the way (Copenhagen interpretation)

There is also a couple of outsiders like the electrical universe and plasma universe which completely ignores the idea of quantum weirdness but as far as I understand they also require some leap of faith.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by gizmo686 on Friday January 22, 2016 @02:48PM (#10955110)
Copenhagen requires a leap of faith to accept wavefunction collapse.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by Jach on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:25PM (#10954124)
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by marcosdumay on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:57AM (#10953882)
Only if you believe in it.

It's the easiest to understand interpretation of QM, and completely equivalent to all others. So, why not use it?

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by danharaj on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:11PM (#10953991)
Because it gets rather complicated to formalize when you try to reconcile universe splitting with special relativity.

There is an even simpler interpretation of quantum mechanics: the relational interpretation. It does not speak of any states and therefore no wavefunction collapse. 0 is ontologically better than infinity.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by spacehome on Saturday January 23, 2016 @03:43PM (#10959996)
> it gets rather complicated to formalize when you try to reconcile universe splitting with special relativity

Why? And why is it more of a problem for MWI than other interpretations?

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by danharaj on Sunday January 24, 2016 @08:21PM (#10965016)
When does a universe split? The relativity of simultaneity causes problems: one observer will have to interpret the universe as splitting in one way and then the other, while another will observe the opposite ordering.

My personal favorite interpretation is the relational interpretation [1], where we just stop asking nonsensical questions about the universe. It does away with problematic notions that arise from our biases as human beings.

[1] http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-relational/

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by AgentME on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:16PM (#10954039)
I learned a lot from and really enjoyed the Quantum Physics posts at Less Wrong: http://lesswrong.com/lw/r5/the_quantum_physics_sequence/ . The author starts out focusing on the Many-Worlds interpretation and later defends that point, apparently sharing your criticisms. Early on, the author has a lot to say against other teaching approaches that present Quantum Physics as fundamentally mysterious ("No one really understands it anyway, just use these equations") or leave out the Many-Worlds interpretation:

>I am not going to tell you that quantum mechanics is weird, bizarre, confusing, or alien. QM is counterintuitive, but that is a problem with your intuitions, not a problem with quantum mechanics. [...] It is always best to think of reality as perfectly normal.

>Dragging a modern-day student through all this [initially teaching the subject in the order it was discovered] may be a historically realistic approach to the subject matter, but it also ensures the historically realistic outcome of total bewilderment. Talking to aspiring young physicists about "wave/particle duality" is like starting chemistry students on the Four Elements. [...] The universe is not wavering between using particles and waves, unable to make up its mind. It's only human intuitions about QM that swap back and forth.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by spacehome on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:41PM (#10954268)
Yea, that's a good sequence for its philosophical views, though it's a little light on mathematics and calculations for my taste. It works well as a companion to a more rigorous work. I wish there were a rigorous textbook written from a Many-Worlds perspective.