You've made some good points, but the two are not mutually exclusive.
This article raises points that I've been wondering about myself. The thinner cross-section and lack of non-interactive space in front represent a significant potential gripping issue, at least for those with larger hands or arthritis. These aren't present in iPhone shapes since you can alternatively grip it with your hand wrapped from the left to right. Anecdotally speaking, when playing my Nintendo DS Lite for longer periods, my hands cramp up from clutching the thinner form factor. This makes me wonder how I would be holding an iPad comfortably.
How would you expect to hold yours?
This post was made with a Windows tablet, BTW, as have all my posts for a week. My tc1100 works best lying flat for serious input. I suspect that will also be true for a non-stylus interface.
Are you saying that the bezel around the display responds to touch inputs? If so, do you have a citation?
I guess what I'm saying is that I sit way differently when my laptop's hooked up to, say, an external hard drive and I don't want to accidentally pull out the USB than when I'm curled up on the couch with a blanket and my worry-free not-attached-to-anything phone.
I for one think that the interface looks very intuitive and quite easy to get to grips with. I think it should be more comfortable since you don't need to learn how to interact with the device. Holding and interacting with it should become quite a natural thing.