News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:34PM (#10948573)
Gates is supporting nuclear initiatives, including backing specific ventures, such as the TerraPower "Nuclear Candle" in situ sealed breeder design that "burns up" current spent nuclear fuel (plus a breeder initiator of uranium).

More generally, though nuclear faces considerable obstacles, among the most serious are designing a high-risk, high-complexity system for a very-long-term deployment. How long do you expect nuclear to be human's primary fuel source, and how do you plan to deal with non-technical challenges.

Modern technical society is about 200-250 years old -- most sources date the start of the Industrial Revolution to about 1800. Virtually all our present institutions, companies, science and understand, etc., have emerged or substantially evolved during this time (though of course many trace back further).

Running nuclear power at global scale from here until Doomsday means planning at the level of centuries, if not millennia or even millions of years. That's timescales exceeding the oldest people, companies, governments, schools, religions, languages, even basic systems of morality and ethics.

Provisioning global-scale nuclear power would require on the order of 15,000 plants operating simultaneously. Unavoidable metal embrittlement limits these to a practical life of about 40 years. That means commissioning and decommissioning plants at the rate of one per day, and both processes are themselves 20-40 year endeavours.

That occurring through political and economic crises, wars, natural disasters, political and moral revolutions, and more. Things which are somewhat difficult to engineer around.

Even trace amounts of some nuclear contaminants are exceptionally poisonous, and at the proposed scale of operation, risks of release are decidedly non-negligible. Present human experience is limited to about 400-500 reactor cores, and there have been at least 4 major core integrity breaches, including Chernobyl and Fukushima. Substantial fault in all accident cases devolves to human and management practices, again, exceptionaly difficult to engineer around. With 30 times that many reactors operating from now until Doomsday, what acceptible accident rate are you targeting? We're at about 1:50 reactor years. Are you going to bump that up 10 - 100 fold?

At 1 per 100 reactor-years, we're looking at 150 core meltdowns pere century. At 1:1000, 15. You'd need to exceed 1:10,000 to limit yourself to 1.5 failures per century, and again, that through political strife, economic crisis, mob and mafia involvement, corruption, war, and natural disaster. Forever.

Renewable energy systems based on solar, wind, geothermal, and hydroelectric sources have far more benign failure rates. And I say that despite the fact that the worst power plant disasters are included in that list. China's Banqiao Dam failed in 1975 (itself a story of engineering, design, management, communications, and meterological factors) killing 171,000. Despite that, the region is now home to over 7 million people. The long term effects of such failures is relatively minimal, compared to the nondiscretionary multi-century wildlife refuges now surrounding the former Chernobyl and Fukushima sites, as well as smaller-factor radiation problems at locations such as Hanford, Washington.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banqiao_Dam

More generally, the problem I see is that which was the real core message of the 1972 book Limits to Growth. There are limts to growth, and at exponential scales, those are reached rapidly even with increasing resources or pollution-absorption capacities by powers of 2, or 10, or 100. Those limits need to be embraced.

Nuclear power is just one of numerous cases of pleading for exceptions from the Gods of Complexity. The real challenge (and one Gates also acknowledges, though generally privately) is of accepting the limits of humans' footprint on this little, and rare, and lonely planet of ours.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by wdewind on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:46PM (#10948649)
It's worth noting that, afaik, none of the reactors that have failed have been built using the "newest generation" of reactors, which are supposed to be much safer. This is a double edged sword, of course, because that also means they haven't been tested nearly as long. But I don't think the math to scaling nuclear power is as simple as we've fucked up 4/500 times, just extrapolate the numerator and denominator and you've got it. As we get more experienced with the technology we'll get better. And any conversation about the safety of nuclear needs to contain the relative risk of not using nuclear.

> More generally, the problem I see is that which was the real core message of the 1972 book Limits to Growth. There are limts to growth, and at exponential scales, those are reached rapidly even with increasing resources or pollution-absorption capacities by powers of 2, or 10, or 100. Those limits need to be embraced.

Embracing those limits requires, as far as I can tell, eugenic-style control over breeding. Personally I'd rather the human race burns itself out than go down that path.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:59PM (#10948775)
I'm a fan of empirical over theoretical data and arguments. The 4:500 rate is what we've achieved, and, belabouring the point, all accidents have had massive sociological elements. I very strongly recommend reading Charles Perrow (Normal Accidents, but also other works).

Yes, something's got to control human breeding. Either humans or something other than human. Most likely viral or bacteriological, in my book.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by wdewind on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:38PM (#10949065)
I generally agree, but in the case of the environment we're not going to have clear data on what to do. How are you comparing the risk of building nuclear to the risk of not building nuclear? It's a very difficult thing to do.
Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:08PM (#10949277)
That gets into some pretty profound discussions of just what "risk" is.

The current benchmark (e.g., used in the IPCC's own assessments of carbon-neutral energy options) is of lives per GW generation. I find this naive on numerous counts, e.g., my citation of the Banqiao disaster -- horrible if you were caught up in it (though also note: the bulk of the deaths werev from disease and starvation in the aftermath, the acute toll from the inundation was ~40-50k).

Virtually all deaths due to conventional processes -- physical, heat, trauma, even chemical -- are fairly ameliorable by direct precautions. Even in the case of a massive dam failure -- Banqiao, Johnstown, Vajont -- advance warning of a few minutes would have reduced fatalities tremendously, and with hours or days, all but entirely. Each of these disasters was precipitated by clear warning signs, though they were unheeded, for various reasons. In the Johnstown and Vajont cases, state of the art in engineering and geology was a major component. Perverse incentives to plant operators existed in all cases.

Looking at instances of explosions also suggests that warning, evacuation, and shelter could save virtually all lives, assuming a proper understanding of circumstances. Halifax, Canada, Galveston, TX, West, TX, Martinez, CA, Tianjin, China, and Lac Megantic, Canada all represented substantial loss of life which could have been avoided through both better advanced risk management and notice in advance of the precipitating disasters. Contrast the Pepcon disaster, among the largest non-nuclear blasts ever. Immediate deaths, though, were only two (another 370 or so injured), in large part due to the facility's isolation from any surrounding structures.

By contrast, long-term chronic exposures can be quite debilitating. Minimata, Japan, Love Canal, Hinkley, CA ("Erin Brokovich"), Bhopol, India, Agent Orange throughout Vietnam and SE Asia, and industrial contamination throughout China, will likely be with us for a long, long time. Flint, MI, can be added to that list.

Chemicals can generally be mitigated through binding and sequestration operations, nucleotides are more difficult. Long-term low-level chronic emissions, or perhaps worse: punctuated equilibria, concern me.

The bigger concern I have though is for systemic failure. Nuclear energy provisioning, particularly based on very sparse fuel sources (uranium from seawater, thorium from rare earths mining) creates a long-term dependence on a large and potentially fragile technological stack. By contrast, wind, solar, and hydroelectric power are rather simpler, and even geothermal is fairly straightforward.

"Complexity is the enemy of reliability" is a phrase first occurring in The Economist newspaper, January 18, 1958. It's been repeated, usually as "complexity is the enemy", many times since, though I suspect those citing it don't know the origins (my first encounter was through Eric S. Raymond's writings).

Creating a civilisation-supporting technological stack that isn't complex seems a strong goal. And quantifying systemic global risk part of the problem.

http://books.google.com/books?id=aDsiAQAAMAAJ&q=%22complexit...

https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/24cxgc/program...

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by wdewind on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:46PM (#10954696)
Thanks for a very well thought out reply.

> By contrast, wind, solar, and hydroelectric power are rather simpler, and even geothermal is fairly straightforward.

My understanding is scaling these technologies is where the complexity may lie, and that it would so extremely difficult to support the growing energy needs of the world's population using these technologies that they aren't really even an option. I'd like to be wrong. Am I?

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Friday January 22, 2016 @08:34PM (#10956766)
I don't know.

This gets into a whole mess of considerations, and there's not a lot of agreement.

There's little doubt that there isn't a gross surplus of solar energy incident on Earth's surface. But that surplus is, by orders of magnitude, fairly thin relative to present human energy demands. By the time numerous factors are applied, you end up with infrastructure requirements which are truly prodigious.

I'm increasingly coming to the conclusion that the real lesson of Limits to Growth has largely been missed -- not what limits are, but that they exist, and even highly generous assumptions of abundance (or effluent absorption capabilities) are rapidly overwhelmed with even modest rates of growth. That is, the lesson is humans must embrace limits. There's considerable more math on how far in advance clear warning signs do or don't exist, though fundamentally the principles are simple.

This turns the typical statement of sustainability on its head. The question isn't "how do we provide energy, food, and other resources for the people we see coming", but "how many people can be supported, at what level of affluence, for what duration?" It's not energy supplies that are insufficient, it's humans which are overabundant.

Answers to "how many" vary, though I've seen published values ranging from 50 million to 50 billion -- three orders of magnitude. Someone's off by a lot.

Going by history, the range of 50 million - 2 billion corresponds to human population from early prehistory to about 1920. At the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, the value stood at about 500 million.

Levels at or above present populations would require a large number of complex problems be solved for a very long time.

The answer to your question may well be not that you're wrong, but that you're asking the wrong questions.

Put another way: there's nothing inherent to the Universe (or even this small speck of it) which gives humans any right to existence or level of affluence. Predicating reality on what we'd prefer is the definition of wishful thinking.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by 7952 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:42PM (#10949101)
> none of the reactors that have failed have been built using the "newest generation" of reactors, which are supposed to be much safer.

At some point there has to be a compromise made between cost and safety. You could spend an extra $10 billion making a plant even more safe, but in doing so make the scheme unaffordable, and 20 years late. And even then the station could still have complex failure modes that are very difficult to model. Maybe that is exactly what happened to the nuclear industry since Chernobyl? We ended up with ever more complex and monolithic systems that require thousands of expensive physicists to do basic building and maintenance. Perhaps it would have been better to invest in small modular systems.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:06PM (#10950269)
Self reply. /u/mcnape on Reddit sends some corrections:

1. TerraPower isn't solid state, but dynamically relocates fuel rods to achieve a "travelling wave".

2. Fuel isn't radioactive waste but depleted uranium, a form of uranium in abundant supply, as a byproduct of fuel processing.

Suggested references:

http://terrapower.com/pages/design

https://whatisnuclear.com/reactors/twr.html

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by maxerickson on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:59PM (#10948774)
What population and level of energy consumption is the 15,000 scaled too?

I guess one reactor every 3 days isn't any less daunting, but that 15,000 number seems to be really specific and could use a link or some fleshing out.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:43PM (#10949108)
Derek Abbott, "Is Nuclear Power Globally Scalable"

http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?reload=true&arnum...

Abbott starts with present global electrical consumption and assumes a nominal 1 GW capacity plant.