News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by notacoward on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:41PM (#10948148)
He never seems to identify anything actually wrong with Medium except that it's popular already. People might be disinclined to write anything critical of Medium on Medium itself? Weak sauce. It comes across as a hipster-ish "I was blogging before it was cool" whine, or maybe somebody from Medium stole his girlfriend. What it's not is convincing. I'm actually more likely to use Medium now than I was before.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by jerf on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:52PM (#10948231)
I'd observe that Dave Winer, and I guess me too now, have lived through several instances of this. The question to me isn't how you feel now; it's how will you feel 5 or 10 years from now? Do you still think Medium will have your stuff? Do you think they're going to have your interests in mind?

My weblog ain't nothing special and gets basically no hits (as befits its basically-no-new-posts), but it's 16 years [1] old and still all there (albeit with the first couple of years somewhat scrambled from some importing across systems; just never taken the time to sort it out), and all mine. Has your content lasted 16 years?

The only thing about his piece that surprised me was referring to putting something on wordpress.com as a happy ending, since it seems like the same basic problem.

[1]: Jeepers, my blog can get a learner's permit. When, metaphorically, did that happen?

Re:Anywhere but Medium by notacoward on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:03PM (#10948806)
"Has your content lasted 16 years"

As a matter of fact, yes. I've been blogging exactly that long too. Some of that content has gone through four or five software platforms, and twice that many physical hosts, and it's just as readable as ever. You do bring up a good point, though. The reason I've been able to make all those transitions has been because I retained complete control over the data even at the lowest level throughout. I wouldn't have that with Medium. I'd be at least somewhat at their mercy to keep my posts accessible and/or exportable. That's the argument Dave should have made. Maybe he considered it too obvious to state, but the fact that he didn't make it explicit is what turns a possibly-good rant into an incoherent mess.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by akkartik on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:49PM (#10948668)
Perhaps he means that blogging services would be more likely to have user interests in mind as long as there's multiple of them and they have to compete. By this reasoning using a competing underdog service is a useful act even if it's just as 'closed' or whatever.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by tejaswiy on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:19PM (#10948463)
To continue his analogy with RSS, When Google killed reader, they did provide an option to export all your feeds. Several RSS clients came out, but RSS itself was under attack by Twitter, Facebook and co., and it never regained steam.

Ten years from now, unless you believe weblogs are going to die, I don't think you should be too worried about having Medium disappear and take all your writing with it. What incentive would they possibly have to not have an export option to let users take their content away?

As it stands now, they offer the best writing / reading experience on the web and while I'm all for competition and innovation, I'd be satisfied with their product even if it does not change for the next 10 years.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by pluma on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:03PM (#10948805)
> What incentive would they possibly have to not have an export option to let users take their content away?

Wrong question. What incentive would they possibly have to have an export option? If they're going to disappear, what makes you expect that the most likely scenario involves them helping users transition when the vast majority of startups haven't done this?

You can be happy if you get some advance notice that the service is going to shut down. Getting advance notice AND the option to export your data AND that data being in some remotely useful format is hitting the jackpot.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by Futurebot on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:22PM (#10948959)
Medium already has an export feature. If you're arguing that they may take it away (which I think is vanishingly unlikely), then that's another thing entirely. The feature is there, though, so incentives about building one don't seem relevant to the discussion.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by slyall on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:34PM (#10949804)
But even if you can get all your articles and re-upload them (and they look nice still) the URLs will change so anything that links to your channel or individual articles is going to break.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by chasing on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:11PM (#10948852)
> Has your content lasted 16 years?

My first blog post is from 19 years ago. Before the term "blog" hit the scene, I believe.

Just wanted to brag. :-)

But it's also important just as a reminder that your content might last decades. Those old posts will no doubt still be up on my site 19 years from now. At least, if I'm still around and if something catastrophic hasn't happened to our civilization...

What's the over-under on Medium being around in 19 years?

Re:Anywhere but Medium by skybrian on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:34PM (#10948574)
I'm in a similar situation (old, pretty much dead blog, but still there).

If you're not a historian, I'm not sure that longevity is all that important. It seems like someone who writes a lot and changes platforms every so often without worrying about the past might be better off, even if their old posts might not be around anymore.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by CamperBob2 on Saturday January 23, 2016 @03:52PM (#10960042)
Do you still think Medium will have your stuff?

You step into the river, but the water has moved on / Welcome to the Internet

It's sad, I agree -- but it's naive to expect anything else even from Google, much less some random startup. If you want your content to last, get an FTP account with your ISP, tie it to a domain name you own, upload a static .htm file, and pay the bill every month. Nothing else is guaranteed to work.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by zekevermillion on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:55PM (#10948728)
I would think the same problem exists for all platforms, twitter, wordpress, disqus comments, etc. Why single medium out for criticism? If you want to maintain control over your writing, cross-post. If you don't, render unto Caesar.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by Analemma_ on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:50PM (#10948222)
And another thing: is Medium really that popular? I mean, inside the tech bubble I know it is, but I feel like this might be another case of us having a warped view of the world (like how, outside "tech people" I still have yet to encounter somebody who has heard of Slack). To the general public Medium is just another thing alongside Tumblr and WordPress and Squarespace; I really don't think it's in imminent danger of taking over the web as a monoculture.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by siquick on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:11PM (#10948395)
I don't know anyone apart from myself who has ever heard of it.

They may have visited it but its pretty common these days to visit sites from following a Facebook posted link and never take notice of the actual site name.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by derefr on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:34PM (#10948566)
I would hazard that that's half the point. Medium, to the writer, is a centralized blogging platform, like WordPress or Tumblr—but it's an extremely white-labelled one, where there's not much to indicate to the casual reader that an article is "on Medium" rather than just existing out on a "real" blog somewhere. I think people prefer Medium mostly for that reader experience.

With that in mind, there's a much more Hacker-ly way to get the same reader experience—namely, using one of the many services that provide a "blog-post format gateway" for Github Gists:

• http://www.roughdraft.io/

• http://gist.io/3135754

• http://bl.ocks.org/

Etc.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by lelandbatey on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:47PM (#10948655)
I don't find Medium to be particularly white label, it seems very overt in it's branding. Loading an article off their front page on my phone, this is what I see:

http://i.imgur.com/tJuLn0W.png

What's interesting is that I remember back when I first looked at Medium, it seemed more whitelabel than that screenshot. But I guess that's the point of the original authors post. Medium is a for profit company, and they're going to change the platform over time to try to make money. That may involve changes you don't like, but are unable to act on since Medium has all your content.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by derefr on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:00PM (#10948779)
You're right, that's a more branded experience than I remember as well. In fact, it's worse on desktop as well: they have a bottom-bar now. I definitely had a cached thought that Medium was something I could sign up for if I wanted a fancy white-labelled pastebin, but I guess that's changed.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by shockzzz on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:56PM (#10948268)
He's arguing that Medium owns the distribution rights to your content. Which... if I were to be partial to him, I'd say Medium can monopolize the public's attention as to where we read content. Like Amazon and Books, PornHub and Adult Videos, probably others. It's possible that if Medium goes under, it does everything it possibly could to prevent people from downloading their content.

Not saying that I agree with him. At the end of the day, Medium says the writers own their content. I feel ok with them, though I can empathize with OP, given the amount of shitty things BigCorp companies have done in the past.

https://medium.com/policy/medium-terms-of-service-9db0094a1e...

Re:Anywhere but Medium by pluma on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:06PM (#10948820)
> PornHub and Adult Videos

Did all the other ones die or was PornHub just better at maintaining mainstream media attention? If I recall correctly there were at least three other equally sized sites along the time I first heard of it.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by xlm1717 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:54PM (#10948720)
I can't quite put my finger on it, but I think a big part of why I don't like Medium either is because it's popular. Yes, it's going to sound hipster-ish to say the posts started out interesting, but now whenever I see a link to a post on Medium I expect it to be someone complaining about someone or something, and most of the time that's what it is.
Re:Anywhere but Medium by maus42 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:55PM (#10948731)
I think he has at least one point:

>See there's the other problem with ceding a whole content type to a single company. Since you're counting on them not just to store your writing, but also build flow for it, the inclination is to praise them, to withhold criticism. To try to guess what they like, and parrot it. If Medium becomes much stronger, this will be what SEO becomes. We saw that happen before on Twitter, when they gave huge flow to people they liked, and not to people they don't. Now they're being more open about it. Why not? It didn't appear to cost them anything the last time around.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by CamperBob2 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:54PM (#10948251)
Agreed, I kept waiting for him to come to the point but it never seemed to happen.

A good rant should be like a well-optimized piece of code, and not waste a lot of the reader's mental CPU cycles.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by blakesterz on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:04PM (#10948807)
>> Medium is a startup, a well-funded one for sure, but they could easily pivot and leave all the stories poorly served, or not served at all.

I think his most important point is right there, and that's a pretty good one.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by gballard on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:53PM (#10948699)
You can definitely take issue with his cantankerous and opinionated views on open access to information; but Dave Winer as "hipster-ish"?! That made me spit-take coffee all over my keyboard...
Re:Anywhere but Medium by savanaly on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:59PM (#10948285)
>I'm actually more likely to use Medium now than I was before.

Me too. His explanation of why Medium is thought to be good (before he goes on to explain why he thinks it's actually bad) was very convincing!

>Medium is on its way to becoming the consensus platform for writing on the web. if you're not sure you're going to be blogging regularly, the default place to put your writing is Medium, rather than starting a blog on Tumblr or WordPress.com, for example. I guess the thought is that it's wasteful to start a blog if you're not sure you're going to post that often.

Re:Anywhere but Medium by mrkipling on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:47PM (#10948186)
I was actually going to say much the same, even

> I'm actually more likely to use Medium now than I was before.