News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by saosebastiao on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:25PM (#10948037)
I'm pretty sure we don't need billions of dollars of investments in clean energy, we need billions of dollars of investments in energy storage across a variety of scales ranging from household/vehicle level all the way to geographic regions. There are plenty of existing clean technologies that are as low or lower than the existing cost/kWh of dirty energy technologies. They are just intermittent and unreliable for base power distribution. Unfortunately energy storage is not as glamorous as clean energy production and doesn't get anywhere near the investment levels that it deserves.
Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by Retric on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:28PM (#10948062)
Grid scale energy storage is a 'solved' problem.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_pumped-storage_hydroel...

EX: A single location is storing 4,200 gigawatt-hours per year:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huizhou_Pumped_Storage_Power_S...

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:56PM (#10948258)
Pumped hydro / storage sites are largely built out. To meet full needs, or alternatively, the equivalent dispatchable generation capacity of present fossil-fueled generation, would require something on the order of 2,400 Hoover Dam equivalents.

Siting and water flows for such installations are somewhat lacking.

http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/11/pump-up-the-stor...

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by Retric on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:01PM (#10948308)
Solar and wind never produce zero energy in a single day. So, at most you may want ~30% of one days worth of storage which less than ~1/20th of what he wants. Extra capacity is actually fairly cheap (winds cost are ~2.5¢/kWh now) and something we already do. In extreme events like a heat wave, traditional hydropower can make up the long term difference as it's designed to store power over long periods already.

There math is also wrong on energy density, you get ~30% efficiency with gas > electricity. So one gallon of gas takes less water on balance. ~4 cubic meters of water dropping one mile ~= 1 gallon. A 10 meter drop in water level over 1 km^2 = ~2,500,000 gallons of gas per day and 0.9 billion gallons of gas per year.

Sure, you would need two ~1 km^2 square body's of water within ~3 miles of each other with one ~1 mile higher than another. But, building two 10-20m deep pools is cheap, so now you just need a large flat hill or an unusually deep valley.

PS: People talk about how variable wind is, but if you ignore the peak and compare median power to minimal power it's actually surprisingly steady. Yes, we will waste a few days at peak power, but that's not actually a lot of wasted energy.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:38PM (#10948600)
Solar produces, to a reasonable approximation, zero energy every night.

If you want to see seasonal trends, the Fraunhoffer Institute in Germany has excellent actual production plots for Germany. Solar does well in summer, not so much in winter. Some of the slack is made up for with wind.

There's additional other sources, including wastestream processing, though that itself is just derivative of biofuels. Germany has surprisingly little geothermal potential.

And though Germany is a high-latitude country, it's fairly representative of about 450 million people living in modern high-energy lifestyles, throughout Europe.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by Retric on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:59PM (#10948776)
People use vastly more energy in the day time. Peak solar and usage don't line up 1:1, but they are fairly close. Further, Summer cooling uses a lot of energy and you get more solar energy in the Summer.

Solar hot water heating is much more efficient ~90% and easy to store locally. Payback is ~3-5 years in most of the US even if you only need heat for a few months out of the year. Granted, it does not work in Alaska, but it does work in Mane.

Thus, Wind for base load 24/7/365. Solar for peak power usage. Toss in a 30% buffer + ~20% extra generating capacity get's you to 5 9's.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by saosebastiao on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:08PM (#10949271)
> People use vastly more energy in the day time.

This isn't guaranteed to be true. Before electrical household appliances were common, we used far more energy at night because indoor lighting was the primary use case for energy. And we are likely to revert to this pattern again if we ever have a mass move toward electric cars which will be charging at night.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:11PM (#10949293)
To be fair: EVs (or other high-demand storage-recharge uses) will most likley operate when supply is abundant.

Presently with inflexible base-load power generation (coal and nuclear), that's at night.

Given nondispatchable opportunistic generation, that's likely to be during daylight hours.

Storage is the electrical demand of last resort, along with other very-high-energy uses (e.g., thermal banking, aluminium smelting, etc.).

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by Retric on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:36PM (#10950766)
Electric cars need less energy than you might think.

Using Tesla numbers, 230 miles on 60kwh. Average person drives 13,000 miles per year which averages out to 9.3kwh per day. Split that over 12 hours and your looking at ~780watts.

Further, if it cost less we would charge cars during the day.

PS: Average household uses 31kwh per day. But, offices are really daytime biased.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by saosebastiao on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:44PM (#10948164)
It is only solved if you are lucky enough to have suitable geography and a stable and wealthy enough government to support it, and are willing to irrevocably damage large ecological areas to build it. That solution isn't good enough to convert the entire world.
Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by Retric on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:58PM (#10948275)
This things can actually be fairly compact and self contained. Traditional hydro is designed to store ~1 year of energy generally from seasonal rain, and needs a deep lake to build a useful head of water, which takes a lot of space. Pumped hydro is designed to store ~12 hours of energy and recharged every day. So, you can just have a small lake on top of a hill and another at the base within ~1-2 miles.

As to geography you can also move electricity ~1,000 miles with minimal losses, So there is some dependence on geography but outside of some islands you can use pumped storage just about anywhere in the world as all you really need is a large hill to start with.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by david-given on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:20PM (#10949345)
> A single location is storing 4,200 gigawatt-hours per year

That seems like a lot, but for comparison purposes, China uses 5,400,000 GWh/yr. I don't know how many sites China has available to build storage plants of this capacity; the terrain there looks kinda special --- Wikipedia claims the lower dam is over 400m high...

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:00PM (#10948299)
Both.

The scale of solar and wind build-out required, and of energy storage, are both absolutely staggering.

Largest built infrastructure, possibly short of highway and road systems (which are significantly lower tech, and have far fewer moving parts).

Though highway maintenance costs might give you pause as well. Lifetime for solar and wind plant is roughly 20 years, due to various degredation factors.

Re:Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Cle... by 7952 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:07PM (#10949268)
There is also huge potential for adjusting demand. There are numerous devices that don't need to be powered all the time which could be switched depending on availability.