News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by azinman2 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:35PM (#10946798)
Uhhh what? Blockchain blockchain blockchain! And uber!

How in the world are these connected. He's presenting it like its this obvious thing that needs to be connected when it's not clear at all why any blockchain needs to be involved.

Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by colordrops on Thursday January 21, 2016 @01:05PM (#10947015)
Why is there always a highly up-voted comment in every thread that expresses befuddlement at the utility of the blockchain? I thought HN was all about forward thinking and experimental ideas, instead of throwing up hands in ignorance.

Admittedly, the article is light on technical details, but if you understand how blockchain technology works, you could easily deduce that a likely use case for this would be a service for connecting drivers to passengers without a middleman and without the regulatory burden that often prevents these services from proliferating in certain markets. A more fleshed out general case of a decentralized marketplace is OpenBazaar, which creates a marketplace with no middleman that can't be taken down.

There is no reason a blockchain based app couldn't be implemented. Whether this guy is actually on the right path or not is hard to say based on the article.

Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by yid on Thursday January 21, 2016 @01:15PM (#10947089)
> There is no reason a blockchain based app couldn't be implemented.

I don't think anyone is doubting this bit. It's the overwhelming current trend of forcing everything onto the blockchain, whether it improves the application or not. The interesting questions (frequently not answered) revolve around why one should do this.

Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by hughw on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:01PM (#10947427)
To me, the supposed benefit of using blockchain was so obvious as not to require stating: Removal of any central authority over connecting customers to service providers. And you might not want Uber tracking your travels, for example.

There are good arguments for centralization, too. Not saying the blockchain argument win out. Just saying, the benefits are the same as for every other blockchain application, and well understood.

Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by duskwuff on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:32PM (#10947654)
> And you might not want Uber tracking your travels, for example.

Surely a blockchain would only change that to anybody being able to track your travels, though?

Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by colordrops on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:40PM (#10947709)
The whole system wouldn't have to sit on the blockchain - only the parts that are needed to put out a request. The only part that would need some thought is the initial location. One option would be to put out a general location, within 10 miles, then only give exact location to those who request it and have a proven record of being good drivers. That's another problem as well - how do you create a ratings system on the blockchain that can't be manipulated? Perhaps a page-rank style algorithm could do that.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by hughw on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:31PM (#10949023)
No more or less than anybody can track my bitcoin transactions, right? If I want to be anonymous, I use a new bitcoin address for each transaction.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by yid on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:07PM (#10947486)
The presence of both "so obvious as not to require stating" and "Not saying the blockchain argument win out" suggests that it's probably not as obvious as it seems. :)
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by zekevermillion on Thursday January 21, 2016 @01:29PM (#10947204)
Decentralized uber is a great idea, and I optimistically look forward to a viable implementation...maybe in the next 20 years. I'm not sure that we necessarily need bitcoin or similar software to do this, however. There would need to be some PGP-based identity system and a way to associate driver and passenger reviews with those identities, as well. Ideally identities could be registered in a distributed filesystem -- maybe ethereum works for that, but I also see no reason this couldn't be done in a less costly way. Drivers and passengers could confirm payment and publish reviews based on PGP-signed receipts. Payment could be handled in the usual manner, and I see relatively small benefits to making that verifiable through bitcoin.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by colordrops on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:42PM (#10947721)
We may not need bitcoin or ethereum to create a decentralized system, but do you have suggestions for better alternatives? Until then, we've got the blockchain as our tool for exploring generalized decentralized computing.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by zekevermillion on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:12PM (#10948405)
The key elements of decentralized uber are:

1) open source hailing app or dispatcher 2) rating system with identities

For the hailing or dispatcher, we don't need bitcoin but it may be useful if there is abuse to impose some cost on hails (e.g., uber employees generating fake hails, haha).

For the rating and identity, we can use a GPG web of trust.

Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by colordrops on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:52PM (#10948692)
How do you prevent a local government from shutting down whomever is running this open source hailing system? What happens when this person no longer wants to spend money running a hailing server?
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by zekevermillion on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:00AM (#10953443)
The key is that the taxi drivers are running the hailing system, it is a tool for an already-licensed driver. There is no company coordinating the activities of "independent contractors". If someone tries to own this network, and exploit rent from it as a business opportunity, then they could run into the same regulatory issues as Uber.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by aakilfernandes on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:57PM (#10946961)
Monopoly prevention. Once the api is on the blockchain, no one can build a wall around it and charge an entry fee.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by yid on Thursday January 21, 2016 @01:17PM (#10947108)
What about transaction latency, driver/passenger reputations and ratings, local legal compliance, payment for auxiliary services like maps and point-to-point navigation? All those things sound like they'd be worse off.

The end benefit to the consumer being monopoly prevention isn't likely to outweigh the service guarantees of a centralized service.

Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by dayon on Thursday January 21, 2016 @01:34PM (#10947237)
How does Craigslist handle reputation? And yet, I'm sure you'd rather use Craigslist for certain purchases than eBay.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by yid on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:05PM (#10947468)
Yes, but I'd ideally go to a licensed, brick-and-mortar store for the reputation and reliability over either eBay or Craigslist, if it weren't for the prices and availability of items. My point is that the benefits of centralized, non-blockchain solutions can outweigh what you lose when you go decentralized, and that's something that should be questioned of every new blockchain application.
Re:Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber by HillaryBriss on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:32PM (#10947659)
Yes. Good point. It's an interesting thought experiment.

What if the broad spectrum of Craigslist service providers included car drivers who could (somehow - hand wave) offer rides on Craigslist?

How much confidence would you have in them?

What condition would you expect their cars to be in?

What kind of driving record could be expected from the drivers?

How would you choose a driver from that spectrum?

Would you expect to pay less or the same as for an Uber ride?

Under what circumstances would you just avoid using a Craigslist driver altogether?