News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by jupiter90000 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:47PM (#10941978)
Is anyone aware if there is reliable data prior to say 1880? [1] Is there any possibility that large scale climate trends could be outside of the observed window of time available? For instance, some large scale natural state-shifting appears to occur on the order of hundreds of years (reference is about earthquakes, but maybe relevant?) [2].

Based on everything I've heard/read/etc about this, it seems unlikely that humans are not impacting climate, but I get concerned I'm hearing lots of motivated agendas about it rather than facts.

[1] https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cag/time-series/global/globe/land/... [2] http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/07/20/the-really-big-...

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by scarmig on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:04PM (#10942101)
"Reliable" is obviously a spectrum, and nothing beats a thermometer. However, there are multiple independent reconstructions of temperatures over the past 2000 years using a variety of proxy sources, from rings in trees to coral growth to bores in Antarctic ice [0]. They provide sufficient evidence that the IPCC thinks it's "likely" (a technical term) that temperatures are higher than anytime in the past thousand years.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_large-scale_temperatur...

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by jupiter90000 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:07PM (#10942128)
Thanks, I'll read up on some of the citations listed on that page, looks like a great resource for the information I was looking for.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by sebringj on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:13PM (#10942179)
I actually just posted about this -> http://www.skepticalscience.com/co2-lags-temperature-interme... the co2 lag in the ice core records indicates temperature rise prior to co2 emissions but 90% of the temperature rise then occurs AFTER co2 levels rise so its both natural cycles AND co2 where co2 is the more significant culprit. I was in your camp but got out.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by jupiter90000 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:19PM (#10942200)
Awesome, thanks! I'm going to check this out.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by mikeash on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @07:45PM (#10942592)
There are plenty of motivated agendas on both sides, for sure.

But if you strip that away by going back as close to the original sources as you can, to the scientists who gather the data and do the grunt work and make the best predictions they can, you'll find they overwhelmingly lead to one conclusion: the planet is warming and human activity is the major cause.

If you try to trace back the "skeptic" positions, it just sort of peters out. You'll find some articles and a little bit of data, but there's little rigor or corroboration.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by snowwrestler on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:54PM (#10942377)
This is a good time to remind folks that the theory of anthropogenic warming doesn't rest on historical climate reconstructions. Past climate helps us understand the implications but without those reconstructions we would still have a clear and strongly supported theory.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by rayiner on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:54PM (#10942033)
> but I get concerned I'm hearing lots of motivated agendas about it rather than facts.

What motivation does anyone have to predict disaster?

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by jupiter90000 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:04PM (#10942100)
Here you go [1]. If you don't want to read the whole thing, a relevant part: "News media is tightly entwined with the attention economy. Newspapers try to capture people’s attentions through headlines. TV and radio stations try to entice people to not change the channel. And, indeed, there is a long history of news media leveraging fear to grab attention, often with a reputational cost."

[1] http://www.poynter.org/2012/fear-undermines-an-informed-citi...

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by DasIch on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:41PM (#10942320)
This argument ignores the overwhelming scientific evidence. There is no one who deserves to be taken seriously arguing that climate change doesn't exist or isn't caused by humans.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by mikeash on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @07:54PM (#10942626)
This really should not be downvoted. It's absolutely true. Yes, there are good reasons politicians and news organizations would want to peddle fear. But in this particular case, the origin of the fear is the work of thousands of smart people who have made it their life's work to study this stuff, and they almost all come up with the same answers over and over and over again.

The media wants to scare us? Sure. Politicians? No doubt. But tell me why (and how!) all these climate scientists would want to predict disaster when there isn't any.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by midwest1 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:23PM (#10950342)
I used to evaluate the work of scientists for the US government. You would be surprised at the rampant amount of fraud in science.

To answer your last question, job security. Many other reasons... adulation, professional competition. Generally the types who go into environmental science are true believers to begin with.

In rare cases, there is some money to be made by whoring yourself out.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by mikeash on Friday January 22, 2016 @10:32AM (#10953250)
I don't doubt there's fraud in science. Stories pop up pretty frequently that show researchers claiming some new breakthrough with fudged data.

But what would be required here would be far more than that. Individual fraudsters wouldn't be enough. Even systemic fraud wouldn't do it. It would need to be universal fraud, across basically the entire world. And it would need to be coordinated, to ensure everybody gives the same kind of fraudulent results.

It's especially unbelievable because many countries have a vested interest in the world's ability to continue burning fossil fuels. If climate change were a fraud, they would have a huge incentive to show that. Why would places like Saudi Arabia, Russia, and indeed even the United States not massively fund climate science to debunk the climate change fraud?

I could buy the fraud argument if it were a few people. I could even buy it if, for example, there were a massive schism in the field, with one big group saying climate change is real, and another big group saying it's not. But when they all speak with one voice, aside from a few tiny dregs of dissent, fraud isn't a good explanation.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by JoeAltmaier on Friday January 22, 2016 @10:38AM (#10953296)
Another reason: the evidence is worldwide and obvious. Siberia melting in a couple of years, which it hasn't done in 40,000 years. All the glaciers receding drastically. The Antarctic ice shelf undergoing irreversible melting. It doesn't take a century of temperature measurement to see the result of heating up.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by midwest1 on Friday January 22, 2016 @05:22PM (#10955958)
Did a scientist tell you this? That is not how science works. You cannot attribute events around you to some notion of obviousness. That reasoning would not pass any physicist's approval.

Climate science is predicated upon a proper understanding of physics. Any scientist who tells you that worldwide evidence is obvious should be treated with the same level of respect as Dr. Oz.

The typical response would be that the physics is proven. Well, AFAIK, yes, at least to the degree that CO2 is a greenhouse gas and that it has SOME effect on climate. The magnitude of contribution to toal effect by various sources and sinks seems far from certain.

To draw a parallel, which a physicist (scientist) would do when instructing - this is like saying salt makes blood pressure go up, so it's bad for you... And ignoring all the ways the body can come to equilibrium. Stop eating salt, today, or you'll burst.

So if a physicist calls it bullshit, that's pretty much your trump card. Which is why people put so much stock in Dysons opinion, because he was an expert in properly using the tools that most climate scientists are not experts in.

Were you to go study physics at a masters level for a bit, and then read scientific studies yourself with a critical eye, you'd learn how much of what we call science is grade A bullshit.

Until then, I'm afraid I'm not going to be able to debate with you. It's kind of like me arguing American football with John Madden.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by JoeAltmaier on Friday January 22, 2016 @07:15PM (#10956458)
I'm not sure what you're getting at. The earth is heating up, we know, because all the ice is melting. And that hasn't happened for hundreds of centuries - long before people were a significant actor on this globe. What is in dispute? The cause, sure. That's still very much an interesting subject. But the fact of the earth heating up is, yes, obvious.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by midwest1 on Friday January 22, 2016 @04:45PM (#10955785)
Many of the sciences do suffer from systemic incompetence, if not fraud.

There is evidence that dissent in climate science is punished. That alone is enough for me to pull out the microscope and take the words of minority researchers seriously.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by mikeash on Saturday January 23, 2016 @04:56PM (#10960294)
Systemic incompetence isn't enough. Incompetence will get you wrong answers, but it won't get everyone the same wrong answer.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by TearsInTheRain on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:57PM (#10942052)
power? Almost every issue has at least one of the parties predicting disaster
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by ekianjo on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:58PM (#10942053)
Distract people from real issues and extract taxes, is usually how people use disaster predictions.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by moultano on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:04PM (#10942103)
The people making these predictions do not have the power to extract taxes. The people who do have the power to extract taxes (Congress) are ignoring the predictions.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by brc on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:38PM (#10942304)
With respect, that simply is not true at all. People (activists and their politicians) are continually using the constant threat of disaster to try and gain power. Witness how many times have we heard a politician say 'we have (insert timeframe here) to save the planet'?

The fact that the U.S. Congress has only done a little bit of tax and power extraction on the issue ignores the fact that most of the rest of the developed countries have extracted huge amounts of taxation by throwing around planetary doom. Personally I am thousands of dollars worse off from the application of this power, and my (enforced) sacrifices have not done anything at all to change the planets temperature.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by mikeash on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @07:51PM (#10942613)
The activists and politicians are irrelevant to this particular question. You have to look at the origin of the information, which is the climate scientists who gather this data and make predictions.

What's their motivation to make dire predictions? Sure, anyone with the slightest political awareness can see why politicians are motivated this way, but that doesn't matter to the question of "what is actually happening?" If you want to tell me that the climate change threat is made up, you need to tell me why all these climate scientists are either consistently wrong, or conspiring to hide the truth.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by ekianjo on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:17PM (#10942197)
The people making those predictions are PAID by the government.
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by knowaveragejoe on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:31PM (#10942265)
And? Are you trying to make a case for conflict of interest? Because, time and time again, it's a pretty weak one(unless you want to invoke some global conspiracy involving carbon credits).
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by brc on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:28PM (#10942249)
Yes, the central England temperature series (CET). Now run by the met office, it goes back to 1659.

There is no scientific doubt about the roman and medieval warm periods being as warm or warmer than today. The anthropological evidence of this is abundant, and it shows up in most proxies as well.

The most likely case is that the natural variations swamp whatever changes humans make. Based on evidence, it's unlikely that co2 is a major driver of climate, but more of a minor player that has a ceiling on how much effect it can make.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:51PM (#10942361)
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by brc on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @07:01PM (#10942407)
Which part? Are you saying the roman or medieval warm periods dont exist?
Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by orf on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @07:24PM (#10942502)
The "It was warm 1000 years ago, so climate change is a lie" bit. Choice quote from the link:

> "Even if the world were incontrovertibly warmer 1,000 years ago, it would not change the fact that the recent rapid rise in CO2 explains the current episode of warming more credibly than any natural factor does—and that no natural factor seems poised to offset further warming in the years ahead."

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by brc on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @08:10PM (#10942694)
I didn't write any of that. You have inserted words into my argument and then gone on to debate something I didn't say.

There is no scientific argument about the fact that the roman and medieval periods were as warm or warmer than today, because there is a lot of evidence. Even the linked article acknowledged this fact.

Re:2015 “smashed” 2014’s global temperature record by yongjik on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @08:37PM (#10942795)
The graphs I found seem to disagree...

https://www.skepticalscience.com/medieval-warm-period.htm

http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/globalwarming/medieval.html

> The various studies differ in methodology, and in the underlying paleoclimate proxy data utilized, but all reconstruct the same basic pattern of cool "Little Ice Age", warmer "Medieval Warm Period", and still warmer late 20th and 21st century temperatures.