News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by Someone1234 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:25PM (#10941479)
I haven't looked into this concept as much as some, I have some questions...

What happens if the hyperloop train gets stuck, or otherwise stops between stations? If I understand the concept correctly the tube is low pressure, so even if an escape hatch could be opened, it would be unlikely that people could breath.

Additionally what happens if the tunnel joint or a train leaks, and a train travelling extremely fast suddenly hits a wall of air? Would the change in volocity be potentially dangerous?

I will admit that the hyperloop is no more dangerous (on paper) than air travel. But air travel has been made safe through countless human lives, will we have to repeat that with a hyperloop?

Last question, not about safety, what is the relative energy usage of a hyperloop Vs. aircraft and or traditional (slower) trains?

Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by ck2 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:52PM (#10941656)
Not just those passengers, the whole system has to stop if there is only one tube because nothing else can pass.

Meanwhile airplanes can just pass each other and route elsewhere.

This almost looks like a half-way solution looking for a problem.

Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by cryptoz on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:43PM (#10941950)
Air travel is responsible for a very significant percentage of our pollution into the atmosphere, greenhouse gasses that are causing huge amounts of global climate change and will cost a fortune to adapt or fix. Any solution to rapid, high speed travel that significantly lowers greenhouse gas output is a very valuable thing, and certainly not a solution looking for a problem. The problem that hyperloop solves is high speed travel without gross pollution, something that no other solution has offered yet.
Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by Someone1234 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:08PM (#10942137)
> The problem that hyperloop solves is high speed travel without gross pollution, something that no other solution has offered yet.

Do you have figures or estimates on that?

How much energy does hyperloop use to decompress the entire tunnel, run the air locks, and move the trains? And are we assuming a perfect seal on every joint or are micro-leaks estimated in (e.g. due to weathering and wear)?

On a related note how does one maintain hyperloop? For example segment joint restoration, do you take the entire tunnel offline?

Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by notatoad on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @07:05PM (#10942425)
>How much energy does hyperloop use to decompress the entire tunnel, run the air locks, and move the trains?

whether it is more or less energy than it takes to keep an airliner aloft is kind of moot. Transport systems attached to the ground can be connected to the power grid, which is legally required to be at least 33% renewable energy by 2020. Jet engines can really only be powered by jet fuel, and exhausted directly into the stratosphere.

Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by dogma1138 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @09:02PM (#10942883)
Air travel is still only responsible for about 2% to 3% of global anthropogenic carbon emissions.

This figure has remained constant mostly because even though air travel has increased jet engines these days are much more efficient than 25 years ago.

Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by venomsnake on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:14AM (#10944331)
But it delivers them straight in the atmosphere. So you must check air travel emissions impact.
Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by dogma1138 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:01AM (#10944652)
Which makes it have less of an adverse effect actually.
Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by venomsnake on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:13AM (#10944323)
That has been true for any track system. There are solutions - create passing stations. two way tracks instead of one loop
Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by crocal on Friday January 22, 2016 @02:48AM (#10951363)
... Which brings another question mark. How do you switch tracks with a tube under vacuum and with running speed of hundreds of kph?
Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by venomsnake on Friday January 22, 2016 @08:37AM (#10952583)
very very carefully