AMP: http://tools.pingdom.com/fpt/#!/brWXpA/http://www.theguardia... Requests: 67 Load time: 485ms Page size: 627.3kB
Non-AMP: http://tools.pingdom.com/fpt/#!/eNuTPX/http://www.theguardia... Requests: 136 Load time: 2.88s Page size: 1.8MB
And to be fair, note that the non-AMP page has a lot more content, onward links, components, etc.
And don't a lot of these sources only start loading once the page has finished rendering? AMP is supposed to be fast-to-render firstmost, right?
Which is great and everything, but for a reader in Texas, that becomes 1.2s thanks to the fact that my site is hosted in London.
As you point out, AMP pages which weigh in at 4MB can be loaded in a seemingly underwhelming time: ~800ms. However, I think the important takeaway from this is that the pages load in ~800ms in two different continents.
The articles I publish on my blog use AMP-HTML. I don't include media or ads at all, just text and fonts. These pages fully load in 200ms.
I conclude that the free CDN offered by Google is, frankly, a very attractive feature.
And "Place a CDN in front of it" has been an available solution for... what, more than a decade?
If your site has meaningful traffic from multiple continents, you can spend the $10/mo it takes to add a CDN to it.
If the government can subpoena data from Google, are we sure they're not doing the same or more with CDNs, which don't seem as transparent as the consumer-facing companies.
Oh my: http://tools.pingdom.com/fpt/#!/bniZiH/https://www.theguardi...
"Such mobile performance, wow". 4 megabytes of video(Preloading two different videos. Why?), maybe 10 different domains, downloading JS before downloading images...
And this is the showcase for AMP.
It's almost as if "there is no silver bullet" for web performance, and "actual programming skill" is still a requirement.
There is a difference between AMP and non-AMP, yes: http://tools.pingdom.com/fpt/#!/bAnV7C/https://www.theguardi...
But at this point in time, it seems that installing an ad blocker has about the same impact as "conceding to view a crippled AMP-redesign of the page that doesn't even have navigation".