Re:OpenFace: Free and open source face recognition with deep...
by nl on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @12:21AM
(#10936220)
I strongly, strongly support the open sourcing and wide distribution of this functionality.
Face recognition is widely used by large players now. Some of those players are bad, some are good. It is important that this technology becomes widespread so people understand it better.
Re:OpenFace: Free and open source face recognition with deep...
by jcoffland on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @03:46PM
(#10933865)
Do you suggest they not release this code? Or would you post the code with out the disclaimer?
Re:OpenFace: Free and open source face recognition with deep...
by exolymph on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @04:14PM
(#10934087)
I think they're acting in good faith, but I wish they'd acknowledge that disclaimers are not a particularly effective preventative measure. I agree that putting this provision in the license would help, although it would still be subject to interpretation.
I guess my main objection is that it's naive to expect to have the best of both worlds -- there are always tradeoffs, and the disclaimer doesn't acknowledge that tools like OpenFace cannot be released without negative consequences along with the good ones. It is what it is.
Re:OpenFace: Free and open source face recognition with deep...
by AndrewGaspar on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @11:37PM
(#10936105)
They're not saying that you can't use it for that, they're saying they're not supporting use cases that do that. The disclaimer really just means "please don't file bugs and expect help if your scenario is to monitor a public intersection" for example.
Re:OpenFace: Free and open source face recognition with deep...
by comboy on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @02:04PM
(#10933034)
Depends if they put something related to it (probably formulated differently) in the license or not. If they do, then yes, I think it may stop some companies from using it.
Unfortunately currently their license page returns 404 http://cmusatyalab.github.io/openface/LICENSE
Re:OpenFace: Free and open source face recognition with deep...
by bdamos on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @02:11PM
(#10933099)
Thanks for pointing out the 404, I just corrected the link.
There's an interesting discussion on lobste.rs from a few months ago about privacy issues and licensing: https://lobste.rs/s/sajz0s/openface_face_recognition_with_go....
Oh okay. Surely this will stop any bad actors.