Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by timr on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:07PM
(#1093869)
One thing that should immediately pop out at even the casual observer: the traditional bugaboos of the right (social services for poor people, welfare, etc.) are a tiny, tiny minority of the budget. You can cut them down to an expenditure of 0, and you won't really change the bottom line.
If we're going to come to terms with the national deficit, we're going to have to accept the fact that military, social security and medicare expenditures are going to have to shrink. The problem is not poor people: it's old people and wars.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by xenophanes on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:27PM
(#1093909)
Isn't the 560 billion for "income security" a social services thing? Isn't it giving money to people who don't have jobs, or make very little money? So that's quite a lot of money in the welfare/social services category.
And personally I'd count social security and medicare in the same sort of category. It's the government spending a ton of money inefficiently providing services that should be provided by the free market, and saying this helps people.
It's good to help people, but it's not the right role for Government, which isn't very good at it.
On the other hand, the military spending may be a lot of money, but at least it's in one of the areas the free market has the hardest time with -- it's spending money in an area where the Government actually has some expertise and some business doing anything.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by jsz0 on Monday February 01, 2010 @08:48PM
(#1094044)
How does the free market provide services to people who have no money? I agree it's good to help people but we have social security and other social programs exactly because there was no help when people needed it. I don't think anything has changed since. It's probably gotten worse.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by xenophanes on Monday February 01, 2010 @09:29PM
(#1094100)
The free market does not provide forcible wealth redistribution.
Most Government social services are not designed to be efficient wealth redistribution and nothing more. They do other stuff like get involved with medicine or retirement. There is no good reason for that.
Even if you advocate forcible wealth redistribution, that is no justification for most Government social services. It'd only be justification for having one single program that gives no-strings-attached money to poor people straight out of the federal budget.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by dandelany on Monday February 01, 2010 @10:15PM
(#1094181)
Wait - so you don't think any government social services are worthwhile? You don't have any faith at all in 100 years of social progress?
I believe the reason that we have as many social services programs as we do is because this country has learned that helping out the poorest of our citizens significantly raises the productivity, happiness, and health of the country as a whole. Public health programs that keep those below the poverty line vaccinated prevent outbreaks of dangerous diseases. Unemployment insurance helps those who have lost their jobs get back on their feet before they become homeless and less likely to become employed, or desperate enough to commit crimes. Reduced-price meals for poor students ensure that they are focused on their studies rather than on trying to feed themselves, and therefore more likely to get the most benefit out of their education. The entire idea behind healthcare reform is the idea that if we work to insure every citizen, it will benefit all of us in the end by keeping us healthier, and hopefully driving down costs as a result.
I don't like my money being taken by force either, but to think that the free market would provide any meaningful wealth distribution without being directly forced to is just naive.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by xenophanes on Monday February 01, 2010 @10:25PM
(#1094193)
> Wait - so you don't think any government social services are worthwhile?
Correct. You shouldn't be surprised, this is the basic libertarian view, and it's not rare at YC.
> You don't have any faith at all in 100 years of social progress?
What progress? I don't see progress in social services programs. So, correct, I guess. I do see "social progress" in the sense of, say, people having less fist fights, but I don't think Government is responsible for that.
As to the rest, it basically says you aren't a libertarian, aren't a free market advocate, and don't want to be. It does not engage with libertarian ideas, or criticize them, or say anything new. It just repeats things libertarians have heard a thousand times, and refuted a thousand times. If you want to know more about libertarianism or free markets you can google them, but I don't think you do.
In very short what you have said is, "Government programs are useful" which does not address the issue of whether they are efficient or wasteful relative to the free market alternatives that could exist instead (remember TANSTAAFL).
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by bballant on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:18AM
(#1094448)
This mention of efficiency reminds me of the time when the energy market in California was de-regulated and the result was sky-rocketing costs and rolling black-outs.
America's free-market healthcare system is extremely inefficient. We pay roughly twice that of the UK (as percentage of GDP) and all the indicators (life expectancy, infant mortality, etc), are roughly the same.
In the last two years, in the face of the stock market crash, Social Security has remained solvent and stable. If it had been privatized, as Bush wanted, it not only would have made wealthy bankers more wealthy (redistribution of wealth upwards, which tends to happen in free markets) by infusing the stock markets with billions, but it would have sent Social Security into the gutter with the rest of the pensions and 401Ks.
In fact, lack of regulation in the markets, aka more free, lead to the great recession and the 10% unemployment that we find ourselves in.
I could go on about the inefficiencies of the free market, and there are equally many cases where purely social programs also fail. In the end, the middle path -- a mix of free makets and socialism, a mix of laissez faire and regulation -- works best.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by xenophanes on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @04:07AM
(#1094607)
America does not have a free market health care system. It has extremely large market distortions. While you are blaming the current state of affairs on the free market, I am blaming it on Government. What I advocate is not being tested out, and what you advocate isn't being tested out either, so we can't just look at the results to see who is right.
One of the market distortions in health care is tax subsidies for employer provided health care plans.
You blame recession on the free market. But how can that be? We don't have a free market. We have huge market distortions in all sorts of key areas. Those are more than capable of causing recessions.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by bballant on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @08:29AM
(#1094842)
Of course there is no purely free market anywhere in the world. Just as there is no pure socialism. My point is that free market reforms (i.e. deregulation and privatization) have lead to inefficiencies (and so have social programs).
If you're hoping for a completely free market, that's like wishing for the second coming of Christ. I think a pragmatic mix of free and social markets makes more sense.
I blame the recession on a more-free market, not a purely free market. The banking industry needs more regulation.
Finally, there are many reasons for our healthcare mess and government is but a small part. For example, A big reason healthcare in America is employer-based is, back in the 50's, auto, steel, and other huge companies were afraid of union power and government meddling, so they said "we'll take care of the health of our employees." They opted for a more-free market (not purely obviously) approach.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by dandelany on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @03:00AM
(#1094550)
I guess my biggest problem with your point is the fact that you say:
> The free market does not provide forcible wealth redistribution.
The fact that you draw this distinction seems to imply that you simultaneously concede that some redistribution of wealth is necessary, but also believe that this distribution can be possible without forcible intervention.
If this is not your position, I apologize. But if it is, I think it's naive at best. If the recent economic crisis has shown us anything, it is that, without force, not a penny will be pried from the hands of the financial institutions and corporations that control most of this country's wealth, let alone redistributed.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by xenophanes on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @03:54AM
(#1094597)
Non-forcible wealth redistribution is voluntary charity. I am not opposed to charity. I am also not making any claims about how much charity will be provided in a free market society. I don't assume there will be plenty, or any, though I actually would expect some, look at Bill Gates.
I do not consider any wealth redistribution necessary which people can't be persuaded to do completely voluntarily. What charity is good to do is a very controversial matter, but fortunately I don't have to get into that to oppose the use of force against rich people.
Persuade people to donate, and if you can't, don't assume you're right and they're wrong about the best use of their money.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by SapphireSun on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:04AM
(#1094430)
I'd be interested in hearing what the free market alternatives would be for some of these programs (such as universal vaccination). I'm not saying they aren't possible, but I have a hard time coming up with a business plan that doesn't rely on charity (which is also inefficient, although I'm not sure how it fares relative to government).
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by xenophanes on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @04:03AM
(#1094604)
You can find free market alternatives for many issues in the book
_The Machinery of Freedom_ by David Friedman
As to vaccines, I wonder what proportion of the population wouldn't be willing to pay for their own vaccines. For any vaccine that we make 300 million of it's gonna be cheap, so the unwilling people would either be very poor or have some philosophical objection to vaccine (weird religious view, anti-science, etc).
So the problem is only the size of, say, one million vaccinations.
Existing big drugs companies today voluntarily give away substantial amounts of free medicine to poor people. My friend is a recipient. They do it to create good will and word of mouth and that kind of reasoning. I imagine if no one else was willing to do it, and one company stepped up and provided vaccines for poor people for a high profile disease, thus staving off a public health risk, it'd make them look so much better than the other companies it'd pay for itself.
Or maybe that wouldn't work. It takes creativity to solve these problems. I don't see anything that makes this problem, in principle, more difficult than a variety of others. Also, it's not like the Government is offering a good solution. The Government's approach is to not find a way to do it for a profit, and not find a way to persuade people to do it voluntarily, and instead just to do it by force.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by adamc on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:42PM
(#1093941)
Social security provides money, which is about as efficient as it gets. Are you positing that private pension benefits are somehow spent more efficiently?
As far as whether it helps people, it unquestionably does. Maybe it hurts other people (those who pay taxes), but that income transfer would not likely happen under private plans. So it is not an apples-to-apples comparison.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by xenophanes on Monday February 01, 2010 @08:11PM
(#1093981)
Yes, private pensions have different rules and regulations about when to put money in, take it out, etc. For one thing, social security forces you to contribute. If you would rather spend your money on something else (in general, or just this month), you can't. Sometimes that hurts people who are trying to make rent. Sometimes it's inefficient b/c they could have used the same money for something better. Private pensions, if they get nothing else right, at least are voluntary.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by anamax on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @12:52AM
(#1094407)
> As far as whether it helps people, it unquestionably does. Maybe it hurts other people (those who pay taxes), but that income transfer would not likely happen under private plans.
SS is a big income transfer from blacks and hispanics because they don't live long enough to collect much. It's a modest income transfer to women and the poor.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by timr on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:49PM
(#1093951)
You're missing the point. Go ahead and cut income security entirely. You'll slash some incredibly popular (and useful) programs, and you'll save less than one social security.
Again, we can't keep slashing at the smallest parts of the budget and hoping to shrink the deficit. It's nothing more than political theater, designed to appease a vocal minority who don't have a sufficient understanding of the problem.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by jsz0 on Monday February 01, 2010 @08:31PM
(#1094014)
What do you purpose to do with the millions of elderly people who rely on it? It's easy to cut budgets on paper but there's a very real moral and ethical cost. Social security is a life or death issue for the elderly.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by ja30278 on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:57PM
(#1093966)
The 'usual bugaboo' is 'entitlements', which includes Medicare and Social Security, and is roughly $1.6 trillion.
I don't agree with the money we're pissing away in the Middle East either, but you can't honestly call social services a 'tiny minority' of that budget.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by timr on Monday February 01, 2010 @09:15PM
(#1094084)
Do I already need to remind you that a Republican president just enacted one of the largest expansions of Medicaid in the history of the program?
The Republican party is no more eager to cut senior entitlements than is the Democratic Party -- they both use Medicaid and Social Security as political bludgeons, and neither side has made a serious proposal to cut costs.
You can try to turn this into a partisan political debate, but the bottom line is that both sides have a strong incentive to leave these programs alone (they benefit active voters). On the issue of entitlements, the primary practical difference between Republicans and Democrats is that the Republicans have a long history of attacking entitlements for poor people, in order to maintain the illusion that they care about costs.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by timr on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @03:55AM
(#1094599)
"Do I need to remind you that not everyone interested in shrinking government expenditures is a Republican?"
Considering that I'm one of those people, probably not. Did you bother to look at my original post, or did you just read the last comment in the thread?
(C'mon folks...the parent comment doesn't even make sense in light of what I wrote. Don't just vote up comments because they sound vaguely like they come from people on your side of the political spectrum.)
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by Nwallins on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:56PM
(#1093965)
Are you not including Social Security and Medicare in social services?
The complaint from the right is that the federal government confiscates the wealth of its citizens and redistributes it, presumably suboptimally. Leaving aside the objections to coerced wealth redistribution, there are questions of inefficiency, corruption, fraud, etc. i.e. One can easily imagine that a free market in social services would result in a more prosperous nation.
In any case, I think the right does not distinguish between Social Security, Medicare, and other entitlements in its objections to a spendy fed.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by camccann on Monday February 01, 2010 @09:12PM
(#1094080)
The complaint from the right is that the federal government confiscates the wealth of its citizens and redistributes it, presumably suboptimally.
No, that's the complaint from the Libertarians. The complaint from most of the right wing is that it redistributes to the wrong people (e.g., ones who vote Democrat).
In particular, old people tend to vote more right-wing, so you're raving mad if you think they'd ever oppose Medicare.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by Nwallins on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:02AM
(#1094499)
As to libertarian complaints, really I am articulating the position of the fiscal right, i.e. fiscal conservatives. We are discussing the federal budget, after all.
Whether old people and the AARP embrace Medicare in a selfish stab at the identity-politics cookie jar does not affect the classical republican (and indeed, liberal) platform. Note that I am not referring to and am in fact counter-indicating the GOP.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by Nwallins on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:58AM
(#1094494)
Well, I am just saying that is the right's position, and I can see that it is at least plausible (i.e. I could imagine such a state of affairs). I am not claiming that it is correct, nor am I trying to convince others.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by jasondavies on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:03PM
(#1093861)
Unfortunately the colour spectrum is unfriendly to those of us with red-green colour blindness: it's hard to differentiate between positive and negative percentage changes without looking at the tooltips. Aside from that, nice treemap.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by dantheman on Monday February 01, 2010 @04:30PM
(#1093521)
Some Observations, I always find it interesting how the break it up.
1. Normally the FBI & DOE are not considered national defense
2. Why is Medicare separate from health?
3. Why are veterans benefits & Military Retirement not considered national defense
This diagram is very misleading as criminal investigations is squirreled away under Administration. From this breakdown you can't actually tell how much is being spent on each top level category, which defeats the purpose of this type of graph.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by las3rjock on Monday February 01, 2010 @05:25PM
(#1093653)
1. The Department of Energy appears in at least three places in the chart: once under "National defense", once under "General science", and once under "Energy". I assume the amount under national defense consists of the allocations for nuclear weapons stockpile stewardship and nuclear reactor production for the U.S. military.
I will agree that it is strange that the Federal Bureau of Investigation has been categorized as "National defense"; the rest of the Department of Justice seems to have been catergorized as "Administration".
2. One could categorize Medicare with Health, but one can already do that with the chart as shown by considering those two rectangles together. It is interesting to see that Medicare, by itself, has a larger allocation than everything else in the Department of Health and Human Services (and there are pieces in the Health rectangle that probably belong in the Medicare rectangle, e.g. "Grants to states for Medicaid" and "DoD Medicare-eligible retiree health care fund").
3. The Department of Veterans Affairs is a Cabinet-level department independent from the Department of Defense.
4. It looks like the Department of Justice and the Department of Treasury have been lumped together under "Administration".
I will agree that some aspects of this breakdown are strange, but I don't think it defeats the purpose of this chart.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by InclinedPlane on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:27PM
(#1094298)
I think he was making a dot-com (v1) boom joke. Wherein the overly simplistic business model math involving capturing just X tiny percent of a huge market was obvious justification for the profitability of a web venture. Turns out, there's no reason to assume that anyone can capture 1%, 0.1% or even 0.0001% of any market, merely because it's a small value doesn't mean it's easy to achieve.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by mattwdelong on Monday February 01, 2010 @09:24PM
(#1094095)
Next book on my reading list is The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith, so that I can finally understand all of this Economic mess the world is in. Of course it won't give me a full understand, but I have been told it will send me in the right direction.
Recently, I have been trying to understand what exactly a dollar is. From what I can tell, its pretty useless.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by jeffcoat on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:37AM
(#1094535)
Have you discovered that if you have something that someone else wants, and they have something you want, and you swap, then you can both end up happier?
Have you discovered that it's tricky to carry with you for exchange purposes every conceivable desire of the guy that owns the grocery store, and thought that it might be handy to introduce an abstraction layer?
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by dpatru on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @09:57AM
(#1095008)
For understanding money, you might try reading Murray Rothbard's "What has government done to our money?", available for free in both written and audio at mises.org.
I always thought this was a pretty good visual representation of budget distribution. Note this reflects the 2010 budget, not the proposed 2011 budget.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by Perceval on Monday February 01, 2010 @09:18PM
(#1094087)
It's not that good really. The site you linked to only displays the discretionary budget. The NYTimes infographic is much better, because it also includes all mandatory spending. Mandatory spending is over 50% of the entire federal budget, and includes pretty much all of the 'welfare state': social security, medicare, medicaid, unemployment and other income supplements, veterans' benefits, student loans, and on down the list.
Displaying only discretionary spending is a rather tendentious way of representing the federal budget, because it makes defense spending look like the largest expenditure. Such graphs are usually linked to by people decrying U.S. militarism or imperialism or the military industrial complex. This is not to say that the U.S. does or does not spend too much on the military, but simply to point out that the visual effect of cutting out over 50% of the budget biases people's perceptions and provides undue support for politicized arguments.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by robryan on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:18PM
(#1093888)
They should cut military spending and focus more on nuclear type weapons, sure they will no longer have the same power in tactical ground warfare but it would be basically saying, sure you may be able to out maneuver us now but we can defiantly blow you off the face of the earth if you try.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by robryan on Monday February 01, 2010 @09:49PM
(#1094133)
Guess my message was taken the wrong way? I'm not advocating nuclear weapons but rather scaling back military spending and using them as a deterrent to other countries so that the current US defense force size doesn't need to be maintained.
Re:Obama’s 2011 Budget Proposal, Department by Department (I...
by mquander on Monday February 01, 2010 @10:01PM
(#1094152)
Your message is insane. I don't even know where to start. Why would we prefer to have nuclear weapons as a deterrent instead of having a conventional military as a deterrent? Which is more favorable, defending one of our allies by deploying nuclear weapons, or defending them by deploying a few ten thousand soldiers, planes, and warships? Why would we want to put money into weapons we can never use without tremendous backlash and moral misgivings, instead of ones we deploy regularly to serve our interests?
The current U.S. defense force size doesn't need to be maintained; we haven't used a significant portion of it to defend us or our direct allies from a military attack since World War II. We use our military proactively, as a tool for enacting our will. We cannot hammer a nail if our only tool is a bulldozer.
If we're going to come to terms with the national deficit, we're going to have to accept the fact that military, social security and medicare expenditures are going to have to shrink. The problem is not poor people: it's old people and wars.
And personally I'd count social security and medicare in the same sort of category. It's the government spending a ton of money inefficiently providing services that should be provided by the free market, and saying this helps people.
It's good to help people, but it's not the right role for Government, which isn't very good at it.
On the other hand, the military spending may be a lot of money, but at least it's in one of the areas the free market has the hardest time with -- it's spending money in an area where the Government actually has some expertise and some business doing anything.
Most Government social services are not designed to be efficient wealth redistribution and nothing more. They do other stuff like get involved with medicine or retirement. There is no good reason for that.
Even if you advocate forcible wealth redistribution, that is no justification for most Government social services. It'd only be justification for having one single program that gives no-strings-attached money to poor people straight out of the federal budget.
I think taking people's money by force is bad.
I believe the reason that we have as many social services programs as we do is because this country has learned that helping out the poorest of our citizens significantly raises the productivity, happiness, and health of the country as a whole. Public health programs that keep those below the poverty line vaccinated prevent outbreaks of dangerous diseases. Unemployment insurance helps those who have lost their jobs get back on their feet before they become homeless and less likely to become employed, or desperate enough to commit crimes. Reduced-price meals for poor students ensure that they are focused on their studies rather than on trying to feed themselves, and therefore more likely to get the most benefit out of their education. The entire idea behind healthcare reform is the idea that if we work to insure every citizen, it will benefit all of us in the end by keeping us healthier, and hopefully driving down costs as a result.
I don't like my money being taken by force either, but to think that the free market would provide any meaningful wealth distribution without being directly forced to is just naive.
Correct. You shouldn't be surprised, this is the basic libertarian view, and it's not rare at YC.
> You don't have any faith at all in 100 years of social progress?
What progress? I don't see progress in social services programs. So, correct, I guess. I do see "social progress" in the sense of, say, people having less fist fights, but I don't think Government is responsible for that.
As to the rest, it basically says you aren't a libertarian, aren't a free market advocate, and don't want to be. It does not engage with libertarian ideas, or criticize them, or say anything new. It just repeats things libertarians have heard a thousand times, and refuted a thousand times. If you want to know more about libertarianism or free markets you can google them, but I don't think you do.
In very short what you have said is, "Government programs are useful" which does not address the issue of whether they are efficient or wasteful relative to the free market alternatives that could exist instead (remember TANSTAAFL).
America's free-market healthcare system is extremely inefficient. We pay roughly twice that of the UK (as percentage of GDP) and all the indicators (life expectancy, infant mortality, etc), are roughly the same.
In the last two years, in the face of the stock market crash, Social Security has remained solvent and stable. If it had been privatized, as Bush wanted, it not only would have made wealthy bankers more wealthy (redistribution of wealth upwards, which tends to happen in free markets) by infusing the stock markets with billions, but it would have sent Social Security into the gutter with the rest of the pensions and 401Ks.
In fact, lack of regulation in the markets, aka more free, lead to the great recession and the 10% unemployment that we find ourselves in.
I could go on about the inefficiencies of the free market, and there are equally many cases where purely social programs also fail. In the end, the middle path -- a mix of free makets and socialism, a mix of laissez faire and regulation -- works best.
One of the market distortions in health care is tax subsidies for employer provided health care plans.
You blame recession on the free market. But how can that be? We don't have a free market. We have huge market distortions in all sorts of key areas. Those are more than capable of causing recessions.
If you're hoping for a completely free market, that's like wishing for the second coming of Christ. I think a pragmatic mix of free and social markets makes more sense.
I blame the recession on a more-free market, not a purely free market. The banking industry needs more regulation.
Finally, there are many reasons for our healthcare mess and government is but a small part. For example, A big reason healthcare in America is employer-based is, back in the 50's, auto, steel, and other huge companies were afraid of union power and government meddling, so they said "we'll take care of the health of our employees." They opted for a more-free market (not purely obviously) approach.
> The free market does not provide forcible wealth redistribution.
The fact that you draw this distinction seems to imply that you simultaneously concede that some redistribution of wealth is necessary, but also believe that this distribution can be possible without forcible intervention.
If this is not your position, I apologize. But if it is, I think it's naive at best. If the recent economic crisis has shown us anything, it is that, without force, not a penny will be pried from the hands of the financial institutions and corporations that control most of this country's wealth, let alone redistributed.
I do not consider any wealth redistribution necessary which people can't be persuaded to do completely voluntarily. What charity is good to do is a very controversial matter, but fortunately I don't have to get into that to oppose the use of force against rich people.
Persuade people to donate, and if you can't, don't assume you're right and they're wrong about the best use of their money.
Hope that's clear.
_The Machinery of Freedom_ by David Friedman
As to vaccines, I wonder what proportion of the population wouldn't be willing to pay for their own vaccines. For any vaccine that we make 300 million of it's gonna be cheap, so the unwilling people would either be very poor or have some philosophical objection to vaccine (weird religious view, anti-science, etc).
So the problem is only the size of, say, one million vaccinations.
Existing big drugs companies today voluntarily give away substantial amounts of free medicine to poor people. My friend is a recipient. They do it to create good will and word of mouth and that kind of reasoning. I imagine if no one else was willing to do it, and one company stepped up and provided vaccines for poor people for a high profile disease, thus staving off a public health risk, it'd make them look so much better than the other companies it'd pay for itself.
Or maybe that wouldn't work. It takes creativity to solve these problems. I don't see anything that makes this problem, in principle, more difficult than a variety of others. Also, it's not like the Government is offering a good solution. The Government's approach is to not find a way to do it for a profit, and not find a way to persuade people to do it voluntarily, and instead just to do it by force.
As far as whether it helps people, it unquestionably does. Maybe it hurts other people (those who pay taxes), but that income transfer would not likely happen under private plans. So it is not an apples-to-apples comparison.
SS is a big income transfer from blacks and hispanics because they don't live long enough to collect much. It's a modest income transfer to women and the poor.
Again, we can't keep slashing at the smallest parts of the budget and hoping to shrink the deficit. It's nothing more than political theater, designed to appease a vocal minority who don't have a sufficient understanding of the problem.
Of course I would like to slash at social security too.
There may be better and faster plans too, I don't know, but this one would work without hurting anyone.
I don't agree with the money we're pissing away in the Middle East either, but you can't honestly call social services a 'tiny minority' of that budget.
The Republican party is no more eager to cut senior entitlements than is the Democratic Party -- they both use Medicaid and Social Security as political bludgeons, and neither side has made a serious proposal to cut costs.
You can try to turn this into a partisan political debate, but the bottom line is that both sides have a strong incentive to leave these programs alone (they benefit active voters). On the issue of entitlements, the primary practical difference between Republicans and Democrats is that the Republicans have a long history of attacking entitlements for poor people, in order to maintain the illusion that they care about costs.
And the Dems who objected did so because they thought that the increase was too small.
The fact that the Repubs have been horrible does not imply that the Dems are no worse.
Considering that I'm one of those people, probably not. Did you bother to look at my original post, or did you just read the last comment in the thread?
(C'mon folks...the parent comment doesn't even make sense in light of what I wrote. Don't just vote up comments because they sound vaguely like they come from people on your side of the political spectrum.)
The complaint from the right is that the federal government confiscates the wealth of its citizens and redistributes it, presumably suboptimally. Leaving aside the objections to coerced wealth redistribution, there are questions of inefficiency, corruption, fraud, etc. i.e. One can easily imagine that a free market in social services would result in a more prosperous nation.
In any case, I think the right does not distinguish between Social Security, Medicare, and other entitlements in its objections to a spendy fed.
No, that's the complaint from the Libertarians. The complaint from most of the right wing is that it redistributes to the wrong people (e.g., ones who vote Democrat).
In particular, old people tend to vote more right-wing, so you're raving mad if you think they'd ever oppose Medicare.
Whether old people and the AARP embrace Medicare in a selfish stab at the identity-politics cookie jar does not affect the classical republican (and indeed, liberal) platform. Note that I am not referring to and am in fact counter-indicating the GOP.
The are plenty of old democrats, too.
1. Normally the FBI & DOE are not considered national defense
2. Why is Medicare separate from health?
3. Why are veterans benefits & Military Retirement not considered national defense
This diagram is very misleading as criminal investigations is squirreled away under Administration. From this breakdown you can't actually tell how much is being spent on each top level category, which defeats the purpose of this type of graph.
I will agree that it is strange that the Federal Bureau of Investigation has been categorized as "National defense"; the rest of the Department of Justice seems to have been catergorized as "Administration".
2. One could categorize Medicare with Health, but one can already do that with the chart as shown by considering those two rectangles together. It is interesting to see that Medicare, by itself, has a larger allocation than everything else in the Department of Health and Human Services (and there are pieces in the Health rectangle that probably belong in the Medicare rectangle, e.g. "Grants to states for Medicaid" and "DoD Medicare-eligible retiree health care fund").
3. The Department of Veterans Affairs is a Cabinet-level department independent from the Department of Defense.
4. It looks like the Department of Justice and the Department of Treasury have been lumped together under "Administration".
I will agree that some aspects of this breakdown are strange, but I don't think it defeats the purpose of this chart.
Is the chart only about the executive branch? Does it include congressional spending & the federal judiciary?
Recently, I have been trying to understand what exactly a dollar is. From what I can tell, its pretty useless.
I've determined that money != wealth.
Have you discovered that it's tricky to carry with you for exchange purposes every conceivable desire of the guy that owns the grocery store, and thought that it might be handy to introduce an abstraction layer?
I always thought this was a pretty good visual representation of budget distribution. Note this reflects the 2010 budget, not the proposed 2011 budget.
Displaying only discretionary spending is a rather tendentious way of representing the federal budget, because it makes defense spending look like the largest expenditure. Such graphs are usually linked to by people decrying U.S. militarism or imperialism or the military industrial complex. This is not to say that the U.S. does or does not spend too much on the military, but simply to point out that the visual effect of cutting out over 50% of the budget biases people's perceptions and provides undue support for politicized arguments.
Edit: Looks like there are two different "mass transit" boxes with differing figures.
The current U.S. defense force size doesn't need to be maintained; we haven't used a significant portion of it to defend us or our direct allies from a military attack since World War II. We use our military proactively, as a tool for enacting our will. We cannot hammer a nail if our only tool is a bulldozer.