News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What I learnt from being sexually harassed at Google by hluska on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @09:15AM (#10930848)
You are wrong. Sexual harassment laws are somewhat tipped in the victim's favour, but only because law in general is tipped slightly in the victim's favour. This is not about laws favouring women, it is just about how the law works.

Simply, the victim's feelings matter.

There is a difference between a wink and a wink after something sexually suggestive. If you can't understand that difference then yeah, there's nothing else I can say.

Re:What I learnt from being sexually harassed at Google by sheraz on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @09:23AM (#10930889)
And there in lies the problem -- we are legislating about "feelings."

We have delegated to the state what our personal responsibility should have been all along.

"Hey, asshole -- keep it in your pants or I will tell the whole office that you went through an Asian-fetish. Now can we discuss this TPS report or not?"

Secondly, a wink after something sexually suggestive is a little redundant, wouldn't you say?

Re:What I learnt from being sexually harassed at Google by hluska on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @09:51AM (#10931083)
You have stopped trying to be productive and are just being argumentative now. Your third and fourth paragraphs are in particularly poor taste.

I don't understand what is so difficult here. Her manager harassed her and the fear and embarrassment that she felt were real. If the genders were reversed, the result would have been the same. That is because in a civilized society, if you act in a way that makes someone uncomfortable, there needs to be accountability.

Re:What I learnt from being sexually harassed at Google by sheraz on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @10:28AM (#10931329)
This whole topic is unproductive. We are "having an argument on the internet" :-)
Re:What I learnt from being sexually harassed at Google by tomp on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @05:01PM (#10934431)
> law in general is tipped slightly in the victim's favour

Not really, at least in the US it's tipped in the innocent person's favor (i.e. innocent until proven guilty).

> Simply, the victim's feelings matter.

So, if I'm hurt by how stupid what you wrote is, should you be lose your job or be jailed?

Basing laws on feelings is the most stupid and abuse-prone idea I've ever heard.

Re:What I learnt from being sexually harassed at Google by hluska on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @11:05AM (#10939007)
> Not really, at least in the US it's tipped in the innocent person's favor (i.e. innocent until proven guilty).

That is only in the criminal system. And, that truism has nothing to do with what we are discussing. Even in the criminal system, if you yell, "I'm going to kill you" and run at me with a knife, you may feel that you are joking. But, if I feel fear for my physical safety, my feeling of fear overwhelms your feeling that it was a joke.

You're also not thinking through the entire system. You seem to be under the belief that criminal/tort law requires an actual physical injury. That is simply not the case.

> So, if I'm hurt by how stupid what you wrote is, should you be lose your job or be jailed?

> Basing laws on feelings is the most stupid and abuse-prone idea I've ever heard.

And, that is why we have lawyers and judges.

Consider laws about assault. Assault does not require actual physical harm in order to be a criminal or tortious act. It only requires two elements:

- the assaulter needs to demonstrate intent. This requires more than words.

- the victim needs to feel fear for his/her safety.

Or, let's consider laws about sexual harassment. In the United States, simple teasing is not illegal, but it can become illegal if it creates an offensive or hostile work environment. The feeling has to be justified (hence the role of judges and lawyers), but it is still all about feelings and reactions.

You should read the US civil rights act. It's well written and quite interesting.

I think it's obvious but I'm neither American not a lawyer.