News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by gyardley on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:28PM (#1092838)
While I enjoyed the article, and I appreciate you posting it, one quibble: it's off-putting whenever anyone mentions a number they got on a test as evidence for intelligence. If you write intelligently, I'll happily consider you intelligent.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by btilly on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:07PM (#1092961)
I normally don't do that. However for perspective I really wanted to give an idea of how intelligent I consider myself to be, and giving that relatively objective number sounded like the least assholish way I had to convey that to people who don't know me.

You'll note that immediately upon giving the number I pointed out that there are issues with that method of measurement and gave an honest self-assessment whose upper range was well below what the number said.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by jlees on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:18PM (#1092998)
That's a fairly common thing to do though. "My IQ is 200, but I don't believe in IQ tests. By the way did I mention my IQ was 200?"

(Joking aside, I think you conveyed it pretty well, though I have no real clue what a GRE score of nearly 20 years ago means relatively speaking, or how you can convert it into a measure of intelligence at all...)

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by btilly on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:32PM (#1093214)
I don't see the site I used to estimate my IQ before.

But http://www.davidpbrown.co.uk/psychology/iq-conversion.html presents a calculator. And if you google around you can find other conversion charts that vary slightly from each other.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by jlees on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:54PM (#1093278)
I could create a conversion calculator and it'd still be pretty meaningless. I just don't really understand how you can draw a direct comparison - it's not like the tests are that similar, although there is some overlap, and even using percentile of people taking the GRE is presumably pandering slightly to the fact it's a self-selecting audience and therefore not necessarily a bell curve, etc. I don't know, perhaps there are real proper studies on this to satisfy the lack of real science that's niggling me here, but given the grey area of 'measuring intelligence' I don't know how well-founded any of those are either.

Add to that the fact that things change as you age - I scored jolly well on an IQ test when I was 14, which gives me a nice score to slap down posturing pseudo-intellectual guys who like to compare mental dicksize at parties, but I'm well aware that I'd score nowhere near that now. I don't know. As I say, I think you brought it up well, I just don't quite see the relevance.

(Weirdly, though, converting the GRE score I got when I was 21 on that calculator results in almost exactly the IQ score I got when I was 14; perhaps there is something to it..!)

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by dschobel on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:46PM (#1093257)
Again... why worry about converting to/from a figure most people are skeptical of as representative of anything meaningful?
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by nostrademons on Monday February 01, 2010 @03:12PM (#1093325)
2340 on the calculator puts you at the 100th percentile, and at about 2100 on the pre-95 SAT (which only went up to 1600). You sure this has the right version of the score?
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by btilly on Monday February 01, 2010 @04:28PM (#1093515)
The GRE has 3 parts. Verbal, analytical and quantitative. For that you're supposed to put in the sum of the first 2 of them, not the sum of all three.

I got 800 on the quantitative part, so put in 1540.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by tokenadult on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:09PM (#1093875)
"The closest thing that I have to an estimate for my IQ is scoring 2340 on the GRE exam in 1991. Based on conversions that I've seen, that puts me at about the top 0.01% in IQ. Now I was really "on" that day, happen to believe that there are problems with the measurement of intelligence by an IQ test (a subject which I may devote a future blog post to), but without false modesty I wouldn't be surprised to find that I'm as high as being in the top 0.1% in general intelligence (however that could be measured)."

I see you got snarky replies for writing this. But I'm glad you did. I look forward to seeing you post somewhere, with discussion of the post here on HN, about the issues with IQ tests.

Anyone else who likes to discuss the issue of what to think about IQ tests is someone whose thoughts I'd like to read on a new thread

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1093619

about an article several friends told me about today.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by statictype on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:37AM (#1094471)
While I don't doubt your smart, I distrust the use of GRE scores for that. I got a 2280 on mine, which isn't too bad, but I had a lot of friends who were significantly smarter than me but didn't do quite as well on the test. At that point, I realized, it was dangerous to correlate GRE (or SAT for that matter) scores with IQ.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by btilly on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @10:44AM (#1095120)
Given the design of the GRE, SAT, and standard IQ tests, correlating them with each other is actually on safer ground than correlating any with intelligence.

Actually thinking of intelligence as a one-dimensional thing is dangerous in and of itself.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by elblanco on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @07:53AM (#1094808)
It may also be dangerous to correlate IQ with intelligence as well.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by elblanco on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:33PM (#1093034)
I'm surprised you don't know your own IQ score. I couldn't even make it to middle-school without having undergone a battery of at least a half-dozen IQ and aptitude evaluations. By the time I made it out of High School I knew probably more than any person should know about their own intelligence and had a pretty clear idea of the range my IQ would fall into as well as my learning styles, cognitive strengths and weaknesses, perceptual processes, learning disabilities, talents and gifts and aptitude scores on at least 3 standardized exams, and various other cognitive measures.

And I went to Public School.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by btilly on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:24PM (#1093182)
Where I grew up in Canada we didn't bother with all of that.

The SATs and GREs are the only standardized tests I've taken. And I only took those because I was considering going to US schools.

If you're curious, on the SATs I got 1300. (For the younger people in the audience, the SATs were rescaled, that score was a lot better then than it would be now.) I believe that I'd have done better if I wasn't sick that day. Having to get up between sections to go vomit in the bathroom is not exactly good for your concentration...

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by elblanco on Monday February 01, 2010 @03:01PM (#1093297)
It may sound crazy after my previous comment, but I never took the SATs or GREs, GMATs etc. I managed to slip through schooling using a couple loopholes and skip the entrance exams all the way to my M.S.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by RK on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:11PM (#1093149)
Or maybe because you went to public school.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by Retric on Monday February 01, 2010 @03:15PM (#1093339)
I had all that same testing, but my parents would not tell me my scores.

PS: I was classified as Exceptionally Gifted / Learning Disabled and I am perfectly happy to leave it as that. In theory I could take another IQ test, but I think I am a little old to focus on my potential. IMO, your potential is only important when you have yet to accomplish anything.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by elblanco on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:49PM (#1093949)
Your parents probably did the right thing. I fretted over my scoring through most of school. It's only now, many years later that I realize how irrelevant those scores are to what I need to do.

The only thing I really wish is that my parents, and the various school administrations had ignored the tests too, because they usually resulted in all kinds of "special programs" that did very little to help me deal with school and adolescence and had negligible impact if any on me when I got older.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by alexgartrell on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:57PM (#1093103)
Having read this article, numerous other articles, heard from Google Employees in large and small settings, and knowing a few Google Interns, I can say one thing with absolute confidence.

Google Engineers know that they're the best engineers, ever.

I've always found it offputting, but maybe I'm just jealous or something.

edit: Worth adding that this is a common thing among many engineers. Also, I know and like a number of Google interns (and engineers). All that said though, the one expression I've heard more than anything else is "Google hires smart people".

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by jheriko on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:57PM (#1093286)
That can't be right... because I /know/ that games programmers are the best engineers, and Google doesn't make games...

;)

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by nostrademons on Monday February 01, 2010 @06:20PM (#1093777)
There're a bunch of ex-games-programmers at Google. One of my interviewers used to do 3D shooters and stuff before she came to Google. And Amit Patel, the co-creator of "Don't be evil" and one of the initial architects behind AdWords, runs a pretty popular game programming website.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by gridspy on Monday February 01, 2010 @03:20PM (#1093345)
The best engineers willing to work in low pay, crunch environments and high staff turnover.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by chipsy on Monday February 01, 2010 @08:50PM (#1094045)
i.e. the engineers who are more interested in solving problems than in monetary incentives.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by neilk on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @12:54AM (#1094412)
Google makes games... just not very well.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Lively

Ok, that's a bit harsh perhaps. In its favor it was a decent idea to merge social gaming and the web, perhaps a bit ahead of its time. I could easily see 3D elements as commonplace on the web in 2012 or so.

And then there's:

http://images.google.com/imagelabeler/

Which is the same concept as Luis von Ahn's ESP Game, only Googlified and drained of any interface elements that would make the thing actually fun.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by btilly on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:57PM (#1093287)
Actually you'd be wrong about that.

The truth is that people don't improve unless they can find shortcomings in themselves that can be improved upon. Which means that good people usually have no problem identifying people who are better at some things than they are. In my experience most have no trouble listing people who are simply better than they are.

So sure, I believe I'm pretty good. But am I as good as any of Robert Morris, Damian Conway or Alan Kay? Of course not, and I'd be an idiot to think otherwise.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by alexgartrell on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:45AM (#1094538)
I think it's safe to say that you guys think, at a company-wide level, that you're smarter, on average, than any other Software Company (I hesitate to suggest that Google is merely a Software company, but failed to come up with a better way of putting it) around. That's kind of what I was driving at with what I said before, and I apologize if it came off at all snarky or anything.

However, I think it's only fair to add that, in my interactions with "Googlers" in other situations (i.e. not recruitment) have been really fantastic. Namely, I'd say that the Chromium guys have been amazing, and they're making it a joy to try to get involved (related to a school project out of the scope of this conversation).

In short, I'd be more swayed by the recruiters (who are often engineers) if I felt like they weren't just trying to intimidate me with Google's prestige all the time. We know already :)

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by JesseAldridge on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:09PM (#1093144)
Why should that be off-putting? Standardized tests are pretty much the only way to objectively measure intelligence. Writing ability doesn't capture stuff like mathematical skill.

Yes, yes, tests are imperfect. Everyone understands this. But they're the best measurement we have -- short of getting to know someone over the course of a few months or years.

Also, tests, because of the way they establish some people as "better" than others, can be very bad for maintaining social harmony. But social harmony isn't a good reason to beat around the bush when one's intelligence is essential to the conversation. People should accept reality.

Edit: And, no, I'm saying this because I have a super-genius level iq. I don't.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by jheriko on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:54PM (#1093279)
I dunno about others but when I read it sounded a little arrogant.

For example, I have a Mensa gold certificate saying that I scored in the top 0.5% percentile on a test (actual IQ scores vary based on the type of test but mine was 143.5).

Sounds pretty arrogant, eh?

Generally any statement that equates to "I am intelligent" gets taken this way.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by mortehu on Monday February 01, 2010 @06:25PM (#1093794)
I think IQ tests sound arrogant because they are always given as rank in the population, rather than in absolute terms. "I can recognize any of 9 fundamental patterns in less than 10 seconds, perform 0.3 FLOPS and know the 10 most common heuristics for beating IQ test problems" doesn't sound nearly as arrogant in my opinion.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by wtallis on Monday February 01, 2010 @04:38PM (#1093540)
Any sentence containing the word "Mensa" is arrogant.
Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by waterlesscloud on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:22PM (#1093899)
Once in college, I was meeting with my advisor, who was also the department head. He had all my school records, including my test scores. He said something about me qualifying to join Mensa if I wanted, and I said something about not liking Mensa since everyone I'd met who had been in the organization seemed arrogant.

It was only later that I realized he must have been in Mensa himself and was recruiting me.

Proving I wasn't nearly as smart as my test scores indicated.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by portman on Monday February 01, 2010 @10:36PM (#1094216)
My initial reaction was "Mensa?! Are they still around?". So I head over to http://www.mensa.org/ ...

If there are any Mensa members reading this, you really need to update your website if you want to be taken seriously. OnMouseOver/OnMouseOut makes it look like you're stuck in 1998.

Re:Things I've learned at Google so far by ja27 on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:32PM (#1093030)
I guess it's a bad sign that it took me a few seconds to figure out whether he included the analytical section in his score.