News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by jackowayed on Monday February 01, 2010 @10:45AM (#1092562)
Because corporations aren't people. You can't arrest a corporation and send it to jail. You can't draft a corporation into the military (though drafting some of those defense contractors and paying their workers military salaries would sure help with the deficit).

Corporations have separate rights and responsibilities from the people that own them.

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by mseebach on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:00AM (#1092604)
> You can't arrest a corporation and send it to jail

No, but you can sue it and rule against it. Ever seen a ruling with a name like "Smith vs. Acme Inc."?

> Because corporations aren't people.

No, and corporations also can't speak. So free speech for corporations is an oxymoron if you don't mean free speech by the people that make up a corporation.

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by DannoHung on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:11AM (#1092633)
> No, but you can sue it and rule against it. Ever seen a ruling with a name like "Smith vs. Acme Inc."?

Not in a criminal court.

> No, and corporations also can't speak. So free speech for corporations is an oxymoron if you don't mean free speech by the people that make up a corporation.

The board of directors, actually, or, even more accurately, whoever holds a controlling share of the corporation.

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by mseebach on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:13PM (#1092790)
> Not in a criminal court.

Because a corporation isn't a person, and can't commit felonies. If it could, it'd be tried in criminal court.

> The board of directors, actually, or, even more accurately, whoever holds a controlling share of the corporation.

Yes, they have free speech, just as any minority shareholder as well and managers and all employees. The latter just don't have the same access to spend company resources on said speech.

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by DannoHung on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:17PM (#1092802)
> Because a corporation isn't a person, and can't commit felonies. If it could, it'd be tried in criminal court.

And yet they should be granted all the rights of a person?

> Yes, they have free speech, just as any minority shareholder as well and managers and all employees. The latter just don't have the same access to spend company resources on said speech.

Any access to spend company resources. If you don't have a controlling interest, you can do just about jack and shit. I suppose you could embezzle or misuse funds though.

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by hga on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:21PM (#1092810)
See my above comment, corporations such as Arthur Anderson have been convicted of felonies.
Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by tsuraan on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:07AM (#1092618)
The ruling isn't really about speech, though, it's about money. The ruling doesn't affect any person's ability to speak, it affects a company's ability to spend its money on political candidates, with a clear expectation of a positive ROI. How can that possible be legal? If money really is speech, why isn't it legal to talk my way out of a speeding ticket with a wallet full of bills?
Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by mseebach on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:07PM (#1092776)
> The ruling isn't really about speech, though, it's about money.

Its about money spent on speech. Free speech that you can't spend money on, isn't free speech. If a news paper was told that it was welcome to print a specific story, except you can't spend money on ink for it, it'd still be censorship.

> spend its money on political candidates, with a clear expectation of a positive ROI. How can that possible be legal

It's not, that's corruption. What you're referring to is rent-seeking, and it's been around as long as politics itself. The best solution is to give politicians less power, simply because there's less rent to seek.

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by yummyfajitas on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:53PM (#1093088)
It is legal to use money/speech to talk yourself out of future speeding tickets. You can spend money on posters entitled, "Vote Smith, No More Speeding Tickets!" in the hopes that it will persuade people to vote for Smith (who presumably promised to end laws against speeding).
Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by hga on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:17PM (#1092801)
You're essentially wrong: while arrest and jail are obviously not in the cards for corporations, they are subject to criminal charges (RICO was in fact established to do this with a lower threshold for making the charge). Arthur Andersen was convicted of obstruction of justice WRT to Enron, and while that conviction was reversed, it was too late since it had lost its CPA license as a result.

You're also wrong about the draft bit: while the mechanism is different, private companies have found themselves taken over by the Federal government during e.g. WWII ... or at least the credible threat was made (most recently I read such a case WRT to the Manhattan Project, that threat was required to light a fire under one company that supplied them).

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by protomyth on Monday February 01, 2010 @10:54AM (#1092587)
given that, why would unions have more rights than corporations?
Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by bokonist on Monday February 01, 2010 @10:59AM (#1092600)
But corporations do not speak, people do. The management are all people, and the owners are all people. These people can and have been drafted into the military or arrested for illegal conduct. Congress can make no law abridging any person's freedom of speech, period.
Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by jackowayed on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:15AM (#1092651)
There's no law keeping them from speaking just like any other person. There's (well, there was) a law keeping them from using millions of corporate dollars to broadcast that speech.