Re:How Measurement Fails Doctors and Teachers
by yummyfajitas on Monday January 18, 2016 @10:14PM
(#10928669)
I think a very important part of learning math is learning that it's not magic or memory, it's just mechanical procedure transforming inputs to outputs (and therefore the output must contain the input).
I.e., you aren't just teaching the test, you are also improving understanding.
Now consider a question like "length of alpha, beta=2, gamma=3, a) sqrt(2^2+3^2) b) sqrt(2+3), c) 2^2+3^2, d) 7". Using your heuristic the student can rule out (d) and has a 33% chance of getting the right answer. The test reveals (averaging this over many questions) that they know a little bit, but nothing close to 100%.
Re:How Measurement Fails Doctors and Teachers
by pps43 on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @07:13AM
(#10930184)
The test would reveal that the student knows a little bit about taking the test. The heuristic would still work even if the test was written in Russian and the student did not understand a single word in the question.
More importantly, non-interactive nature of the test does not allow for follow-up questions. A few follow-up questions on oral exam let the examiner probe a lot deeper in less time, therefore getting a much better picture of student's ability and skill level.