Re:WebTorrent – BitTorrent over WebRTC
by currysausage on Sunday January 17, 2016 @09:24PM
(#10922193)
Very curious about the legal implications if every site that I visit can transfer files to unknown peers in the background. P2P is, AFAIK, a big source of costly cease-and-desist orders in Germany. With WebTorrent, I guess I could tell the right holder to bring the matter to court and plausibly state that some malicious ad iframe must have distributed that MKV without my knowledge.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Not just that, but why wouldn't ads start using your bandwith for this sort of thing ? Do you get a legal claim for your bandwith costs (especially on mobile) against the site owner for doing this without your permission ?
Do you get a claim against your browser maker ?
Is there a difference between using bandwidth this way, or loading say 150MB image? (bandwidth costs wise)
I would certainly say yes. They're using your bandwidth to serve another one of their customers, for free, without compensating you in any way.
Whereas loading a 150MB image from their server is using their bandwidth (that they're paying for) to serve you.
Legally, I have no idea. Morally, it'd be nice if they at least asked and actually had a working site if you say "no".
Those cease and desist orders are toothless. You can either ignore them or write them a nice letter that you didn't violate the copyright and don't plan to in the future.
Re:WebTorrent – BitTorrent over WebRTC
by CyberDildonics on Monday January 18, 2016 @10:17AM
(#10924823)
They aren't toothless if the only ISP in your city cuts you off.