Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones
by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:57PM
(#10916059)
I'm not saying it is a crime, I'm asking if decryption would help to clear the case then why is a bad thing?
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones
by spdustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:17PM
(#10916152)
Not at all. Because your premise, based on there being a "case", is flawed. In many jurisdictions, infidelity doesn't matter in divorce. And in criminal matters, at least here in the US, there's that pesky fifth amendment right to contend with.
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones
by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:38PM
(#10916234)
>In many jurisdictions, infidelity doesn't matter in divorce
In witch judiriction infidelity is no motive for divorce, I don't know any, and if that is the case? what about those judirictions where it is? why is a bad thing using decryption there?
Or, as the saying goes, "it doesn't matter where you get your appetite as long as you eat at home." If the racy conversations are a result of unhappiness in a relationship, it's a symptom and not a cause. If it were medicine, we'd aim to treat the cause in order to mitigate the symptoms, not punish the symptoms by making the patient parade them for the world to see.