News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @11:52AM (#10915772)
But will still be used to fight crime, so?
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by cm2187 on Saturday January 16, 2016 @11:59AM (#10915807)
Not everything courts deal with is crime. A divorce case isn't about crime (and I bet they will be major consumers of decrypting devices, looking for nasty pictures or conversations!). The president investigating who in his administration is talking to the press isn't about crime.
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:06PM (#10915829)
>(and I bet they will be major consumers of decrypting devices, looking for nasty pictures or conversations!).

OK, and why would that be a bad thing? if it is done in the context of a case investigation.

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by spdustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:25PM (#10915912)
#1) because in many jurisdictions it has no bearing on the divorce itself, and

#2) in many jurisdictions a person who flirts with a consenting adult over text hasn't actually committed any crime in doing so

Which leads to...

#3) what is the point of decrypting said personal communications except to vindicate the estranged party's already fully-formed assumption that their spouse is a wicked person, or to exact some kind of court-sanctioned revenge.

I swear, sometimes in threads like this it's hard to tell if someone is trolling or legitimately can't ponder the unintended (or, perhaps, fully intended but thinly veiled) consequences of laws that serve to grant the state access to private communications.

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by hiq on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:40PM (#10915988)
> I swear, sometimes in threads like this it's hard to tell if someone is trolling or legitimately can't ponder the unintended (or, perhaps, fully intended but thinly veiled) consequences of laws that serve to grant the state access to private communications.

The post you're answering to basically asks why removing privacy from society is a bad thing. I think that a simple link such as [1] is enough as an answer to this fairly common question, troll or not.

[1]: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=998565 ('I've Got Nothing to Hide' and Other Misunderstandings of Privacy)

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:56PM (#10916054)
Nobody is saying it is crime (I also mentioned unloyal behavior in my original post), but, in cases where there is evidence of infidelity why would that be a bad thing to decrypt the information if it helps in the case?

And why are getting angry? do you feel unfortable that my concerts my be legit?

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by spdustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:21PM (#10916167)
If one suspects a spouse of infidelity, there are personal concerns related to trust and affection that need to be resolved. By the persons involved. Not by a judge, or a legislatively mandated compulsion to disclose every little thing, no matter how unrelated, you've ever said, into public record.

Edit: You keep using the word "case". I do not think it means what you think it means.

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:46PM (#10916264)
And what about those situations where there is actually a case, why is a bad thing to use decryption to find the truth?
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by runesoerensen on Saturday January 16, 2016 @02:17PM (#10916401)
You've asked this question at least seven times in this thread. People have been surprisingly patient and given you a few answers. You may or may not agree, but please stop repeating yourself as it adversely affects the quality of the discussion.
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by spdustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @03:46PM (#10916758)
I'm responding to adrianlmm's child post here due to nesting limits.

1) Because (in the US) of the fifth amendment, as I had mentioned before and you, it seems, either missed or chose to ignore.

2) Decrypting the device would, due to forensic procedures, result first in an image being taken of the entire device, meaning that content outside the scope of any discovery process or search warrant would then become available to the judge/state/prosecutor/government, and said content, depending on specific judicial rules in effect, may also end up as a matter of public record. It also means that anything you've said on your device's record, no matter how relevant, can be held against you without your ability to exercise your rights to refrain from speaking.

Privacy isn't about keeping secrets, it's about controlling access to the truth and ensuring that you are able to take an active role in any action that results in the truth being disclosed to a party who has the authority to take said actions against you.

Similarly, the fifth amendment isn't designed to protect criminals from confessing a crime which they in fact committed, but to protect an innocent person's "truth" from being taken out of context and used to bias a judge or jury against them.

Honestly, the more I think about it, it does boil directly down to freedom from self-incrimination (e.g. saying something that would get you in trouble regardless of its applicability or truth). Leaders in our history had the presence of mind to recognize that an authority figure could easily choose to punish anything said by someone who was, according to procedure, supposed to be innocent.

It's a moot point (encryption) in civil issues anyway. A civil complaint should not allow any random person to use the power of the courts as a bully to force their enemies to disclose their private information. There's a reason civil and criminal procedure are so different.

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @03:02PM (#10916592)
>You've asked this question at least seven times in this thread

w/o a proper answer, all I get is "Is not a case" and if I ask wht if there is case? I get people like you, so, do you have answer to the next question?:

What if there is case? why is it bad to use decryption there?

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by miscellaneous on Saturday January 16, 2016 @07:23PM (#10917576)
Encryption enforces privacy. In a world with no privacy vulnerable people are easily abused by people in positions of authority. Also note that the legal system is not a perfect mapping to human morality - things that are are legal are not always moral and things that are moral are not always legal. Hence it is dangerous to have a world where right and wrong is determined only by an all-powerful legal system.

In my opinion it is important for society to maintain the privacy that humans have experienced for thousands of years. Remember that mass surveillance of every conversation that you have ever had is new thing. Before the internet society had much more privacy. Encryption is a way to ensure privacy in the internet era.

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by spdustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @03:48PM (#10916764)
I'm getting the sneaking suspicion that you want to decrypt the device of your spouse/partner. Is that your intent?

I'm taking your speech and applying my own context to it. Precisely what would happen to someone whose private communications are laid bare in a court of law, or indeed, to anyone.

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by spdustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:30PM (#10915934)
Civil cases are, by definition, not dealing with crimes. They're typically dealing with contractual obligations, or agreements of mutual and fair performance by two parties. If one was a good husband/wife in every respect, and occasionally got their libido raised by flirting with someone online, are they a bad person?

Or, as the saying goes, "it doesn't matter where you get your appetite as long as you eat at home." If the racy conversations are a result of unhappiness in a relationship, it's a symptom and not a cause. If it were medicine, we'd aim to treat the cause in order to mitigate the symptoms, not punish the symptoms by making the patient parade them for the world to see.

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:57PM (#10916059)
I'm not saying it is a crime, I'm asking if decryption would help to clear the case then why is a bad thing?
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by spdustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:17PM (#10916152)
Not at all. Because your premise, based on there being a "case", is flawed. In many jurisdictions, infidelity doesn't matter in divorce. And in criminal matters, at least here in the US, there's that pesky fifth amendment right to contend with.
Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by adrianlmm on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:38PM (#10916234)
>In many jurisdictions, infidelity doesn't matter in divorce

In witch judiriction infidelity is no motive for divorce, I don't know any, and if that is the case? what about those judirictions where it is? why is a bad thing using decryption there?

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by spdustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @03:50PM (#10916768)
In most, where divorces are "no fault".

Friend, if you suspect someone has cheated on you, HN isn't the place to go for validation. Talk to your partner.

Re:New York Wants to Force Vendors to Decrypt Users’ Phones by CamperBob2 on Saturday January 16, 2016 @03:04PM (#10916602)
You commit several crimes a day, just like the rest of us. Do you want them to use this law to fight those crimes?