Re:Many programming languages have infix expressions, but ge...
by jamesbritt on Sunday January 31, 2010 @07:35PM
(#1091428)
The author, in an adorable little attempt to wear big-boy pants[0], seems not to know that '<' is a message passed to a receiver. You can even redefine it if you like.
Better pseudo code would be
1.lt(2).lt(3)
In fact, this is correct (albeit ungainly) ruby code 1.<(2) # true
and so 1.<(2).<(3) # Say wha ... ?
makes no sense.[0]: Yes, a cheap shot.
Re:Many programming languages have infix expressions, but ge...
by mikedouglas on Sunday January 31, 2010 @07:52PM
(#1091459)
The underlying mechanism doesn't matter if it's wrong.
Those familiar with the mathematical notation would think:
1. '1 < 2 < 3' parses to '(1 < 2) and (2 < 3)'.
2. '3 - 4 - 5' parses to '(3 - 4) - 5'.
3. '3 ^ 4 ^ 5' parses to '3 ^ (4 ^ 5)'.
Ruby's convention is clever, but ultimately wrong, and this is one of the cases.
Re:Many programming languages have infix expressions, but ge...
by psygnisfive on Sunday January 31, 2010 @08:46PM
(#1091553)
Unfortunately Ruby is not wrong. Ruby is simply being strictly correct from a logic point of view, where < is R^2 -> {T, F}, as opposed to being strictly correct from a math-notation point of view, where < is treated syncategorematically. Neither is correct, sans qualification; given that Ruby is not aimed at mathematicians, it's not unsurprising to find that it's not going to go through the extra parsing effort to use math notation.
Re:Many programming languages have infix expressions, but ge...
by xenophanes on Sunday January 31, 2010 @08:50PM
(#1091562)
1 < 2 < 3 DOES evaluate to (1 < 2) < 3
And 1 < 2 evaluates to true. What else would it evaluate to?
That leaves (true < 3)
Which fails. This isn't a mistake by ruby. When you chain methods you have to think about what they return.
And the issue here isn't associativity.
Re:Many programming languages have infix expressions, but ge...
by ubernostrum on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:22AM
(#1091851)
The comment you're replying to was not asserting that Ruby fails to follow its own rules, but rather arguing with the rules Ruby follows; other languages have made an exception to their normal rules for this case, and apparently some people feel it would be better for Ruby to do the same.
Re:Many programming languages have infix expressions, but ge...
by brettnak on Monday February 01, 2010 @03:35AM
(#1092040)
> 3. '3 ^ 4 ^ 5' parses to '3 ^ (4 ^ 5)'.
I actually think that a trained mathematician would have no idea what to do with 3 ^ 4 ^ 5. It's a completely ambiguous statement and has no proper mathematical parsing.
Is the condescending tone necessary?
An alternative:
"Ruby turns this expression into the following pseudo-code"