News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by lukev on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:42PM (#10911976)
Except that there are strong social incentives for anyone who is capable of getting a paying job and going off welfare to do so.

If it were socially acceptable for an artist, scientist or entrepreneur to fall back on "welfare" for some amount of time to work on a project, improve themselves or bootstrap a startup, I think you'd see that more often (including outcomes that end up contributing back to society.

Which is why basic income is such a good idea. If it's unconditional, and not tied to an assertion that "I am poor and cannot feed myself otherwise", I think you'll start to see more capable people leverage it for uses other than basic survival.

It still doesn't answer the question of whether that investment (as a society) would pay off, but its a fair bet that it would at least be a different group of people leveraging it.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by dawnbreez on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:55PM (#10912081)
>Except that there are strong social incentives for anyone who is capable of getting a paying job and going off welfare to do so

Debatable. In the US, many welfare programs are designed to cut off anyone who actually gets a job...even if that job pays less than what you'd get from welfare. This problem gets even bigger as you factor in the fact that multiple welfare programs exist, making it nigh-impossible to prevent that drop from being catastrophic.

This is a major incentive to stay on welfare.

Meanwhile, with a BI, a person who seeks a job will earn more money than one who does not. That's it. No complicated math involved, not even subtraction; a guy who works will have more money than one who does not.

Assuming all the participants want more money, the second set of rules will lead to more work than the first.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by stevesearer on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:10PM (#10912176)
One question I have about BI is if it replaces other forms of social welfare (food stamps, unemployment, etc...), what happens when some percentage of people inevitably make decisions and still cannot afford the basics of what BI should cover? Will a new set of social welfare programs replace the ones that were previously removed?
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by bsder on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:24PM (#10913063)
This ... is complicated.

If you have someone in your family going through Alzheimer's or dementia, you suddenly realize that there is a spectrum of functionality as a human being.

There is no single point where there is changeover from human being who is "functional" and "not functional". There is no bright line where we can say "this person is still responsible for their actions" and "this person is no longer responsible for their actions and the someone must step in".

We, as modern societies, do NOT handle this with any amount of grace.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by DanBC on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:45PM (#10912363)
Someone on benefits who spends all their money on alcohol will find themselves grinding their way through civil debt recovery - their landlord will sue for loss of rent and will evict them from the home; utility companies will sue to recover the debt and will cut off the utilities.

and whether that's BI or benefit makes little difference to that. You get the money and it's up to you what you spend it on, once you've spent it that's it, you don't get another dollop if you make unwise choices.

At least in England someone who becomes homeless through non-payment of rent (even as a result of alcoholism) is declared to have made themselves homeless, and they're not eligible for public housing. They might be able to get emergency accommodation in homeless shelters.

There are some slight complications if children are involved - a parent who causes the children to become homeless through alcoholism is going to find considerable child protection social services involvement in their life, but the presence of children may make emergency bed&breakfast housing available. Those are pretty terrible places. They're often not fit for human habitation, and are over crowded.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by Alupis on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:56PM (#10912461)
> Someone on benefits who spends all their money on alcohol will find themselves grinding their way through civil debt recovery

I think the point being made was, do we continue to provide other welfare services to an individual like this, or do we just cut them loose and let them fail?

Many people would argue we would still have to provide assistance to this individual... so then it begs the question, how is a BI any better than the slew of welfare programs we already run? At this point, wouldn't it be better (and probably cheaper long-term) for the government to just buy all the homes in the nation, and provide them free of cost to anyone? Perhaps food should be free as well.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by manicdee on Saturday January 16, 2016 @02:08AM (#10914583)
Your straw man certainly draws a long bow :D

Here are the types of "welfare" that habitual failures might have access to under BI:

- Budgeting advice - Free housing for the homeless - Free psychological consultations - In extreme cases, a controlled spending card (i.e.: an EFTPOS card that can't be used for drugs and gambling)

But we wouldn't give them more money, because they've made a habit of using it badly.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by jnbiche on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:01PM (#10912928)
Yes, it replaces all other forms of social welfare. Here in the US at least, the welfare system is problematic enough (bureaucratic snafus, etc) that a robust private charity exists to back things up.

So there are private soup kitchens, food banks, etc. Someone who used up all their basic income would need to turn to friends, family, church, or these private charities.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by beat on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:19PM (#10912216)
If BI isn't enough to replace existing welfare systems, then it isn't enough. You can't half-ass something like this.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by flubert on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:36PM (#10912298)
I don't think you've captured the nature of the question. If you give everyone a cash handout, some percentage of them might spend all of their allowance on alcohol and lottery tickets, and not have enough left over for food or rent at the end of the month, leaving them hungry and homeless. Under BI, is this situation acceptable, because it is their own fault for "wasting" the money?
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by beat on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:56PM (#10912467)
If someone is so disabled that BI alone won't save them, then yes, other things will step in. This is a great opening for private charity, in fact. Given BI as a baseline, the conservative dream of having private charity handle things might actually work, because it would be limited to the exception cases.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by dllthomas on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:40PM (#10912327)
If someone can't keep their lives together with a reasonable income, sure it's their fault for wasting their money. I wouldn't say that they don't deserve help at that point, but I would say that it's clear they need some deeper kind of help than money (targeted or not).
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by patmcc on Friday January 15, 2016 @05:05PM (#10912551)
People can do this currently with food stamps too (by selling them for 80% of face value or whatever), so it's not a new situation. So I'd say yes, we obviously can't give people unlimited funds.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by stevesearer on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:31PM (#10912255)
I'm more speaking to what I believe is the inevitability of some people making bad decisions (like buying a bunch of powerball tickets or betting your money at the racetrack or something.) with the money they receive and then not being able to afford the basics.

There would obviously be many people who are benefitted by BI, but my question is more wondering what happens to the percentage of people that end up still needing extra help.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by dllthomas on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:38PM (#10912305)
If someone needs extra help after a basic income, clearly they need non-monetary help. Making it easier to distinguish those cases seems like an improvement.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by Alupis on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:50PM (#10912416)
I question how a "BI" can be paid for long-term.

Presumably BI is taxed like any other income, but of course that means the amount of tax revenue collected will not balance the amount of money paid to citizens... unless we really raise the rates on "wealthy" people (who's definition may shift if everyone is provided a free "comfortable" standard of living). In which case this "BI" becomes a Robbin Hood tax on the nation's wealthy, job creators, innovators, etc.

Knowing several people personally that would be likely to only exist off of the BI (and not produce anything, or do anything with their free time), I have my doubts about a BI nation-wide leading to a boom in productivity. This may be a selection bias, but it seems to me as time goes on, we have more and more individuals content to not produce, leaving their days to just games and other "fun" activities.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by ctolsen on Friday January 15, 2016 @05:33PM (#10912774)
Many people tend to think of BI as a solution to a world where scarcity is no longer that much of an issue. In a world where a lot of wealth is created by automation, the picture starts to look different, to the extent that BI becomes not just desirable, but inevitable. At that point, it shouldn't matter too much if those people choose to stay unproductive.

But even now, while those people may not produce, they would certainly still have to consume. So there is some economic activity created. The question, of course, is whether it's enough to support the greater economy and if the incentives to do extra work are good enough.

Also, I sincerely doubt that these people you talk about are the norm. As mentioned in the article, there's certainly evidence that people may tend to get more education, act more creatively, and pursue productivity at a higher rate when they are removed from the fear of poverty – likely because basic needs are met and aren't a primary source of stress.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by beat on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:57PM (#10912479)
Are those people you mention actually productive now? Most of the people I know who would do nothing are already doing nothing.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by Alupis on Friday January 15, 2016 @05:23PM (#10912691)
> Are those people you mention actually productive now?

Well, kind of, but only enough to pay rent and eat.

But that's my point, individuals like this, who only work the bare minimum to just keep existing and have no drive or motivation to achieve more, are very likely to just not work anymore at all since their basic needs are now provided.

At the moment, they at least work somewhat. This helps keep local businesses running (even if just barely). With a BI, these folks stop all production and resort to their ideal lifestyle of not doing anything.

It's a little naive to think these individuals will suddenly change in light of all this new-found free time, and run out to create businesses or new things.

We can examine lottery jackpot winners for evidence of what many people would do if they didn't have to worry about money anymore (they do nothing in large part).

I just don't see any scenario where a BI leads to increased productivity like what is being claimed.

In contrast, I can foresee unemployment rates increasing, as fewer individuals participate in the workforce at all (to no determent of themselves, since their standard of living is provided free of cost). This will ultimately put strain on the system since not enough production is happening to offset this behavior, which will lead to drastic measures like dramatically increasing tax rates more and more.

I just don't buy the argument that giving someone a free living without any expectation of productivity in return will lead to a net increase in productivity.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by sanderjd on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:04PM (#10912949)
You are linking human labor to production, which is not necessarily wrong, but not necessarily right either. Many of us who are cautiously supportive of BI think it sounds like an awful idea that is nonetheless one of the few that has a somewhat credible vision of a plausible future where production is almost completely independent of human labor.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by greedo on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:53PM (#10916294)
That's the rub. I don't believe there's a "plausible future" where production is independent of human labor. Manual labor in assembly lines etc, sure. But humans are cheap. Cheap to build, cheap to feed, cheap to house. Compared with a robot, a human is extremely adaptable to situations and circumstances that far exceed robotic solutions. Now if you handwave and say "but AI" then you're not being realistic.

And never mind "work" that requires more creativity and intelligence. Programming, writing, art, sales, marketing, policing, military, the list goes on and on. There's a reason that humans are at the top of the food chain, and that's our brains and adaptability. The idea that these traits will have no or limited value doesn't track with history.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by beat on Friday January 15, 2016 @05:51PM (#10912870)
It's different for me. I know a bunch of people who are deeply creative, artists and musicians and such, who spend enormous amounts of time volunteering their productivity - or what's left of it, after "earning a living". I'd love to see them with the opportunity to not have to worry about eating, so they could make things instead.

The conflation of value and money is one of the worst things about our society. Money is, in many ways, units of suck. Jobs pay because no one would do them if they didn't pay.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by Alupis on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:21PM (#10913048)
> I know a bunch of people who are deeply creative, artists and musicians and such, who spend enormous amounts of time volunteering their productivity - or what's left of it, after "earning a living". I'd love to see them with the opportunity to not have to worry about eating, so they could make things instead

Well, I'd love more time for my hobbies too, however it's not realistic to think more time spent doing pleasureful activities will yield more productivity in general. The world is filled with musicians and artists, but very few of them actually produce anything beneficial to society.

Art and music are important components of society, but the influential pieces come from a very small minority, and that's unlikely to change. The successful people are more closely paralleled with an entrepreneur than a typical street artist... they posses the drive and motivation to do what it takes to become great. This involves schooling/training, often more than 40 hour work-weeks, managing people and the business around your work, etc. Everyone else is a hobbyist, producing things for self-consumption in large-part, which does not contribute towards society in a meaningful way.

The people we're discussing here are the types that loathe and bemoan a 20 hour workweek, let alone a 60+ hour workweek the Jay-Z's of the world find routine.

> Jobs pay because no one would do them if they didn't pay.

I disagree. There are many types of occupations which do not pay (volunteer work comes to mind). Further, if there was no means to generate income, there wouldn't be a way to purchase goods, which in turn keeps others employed, etc. In a society where things are all totally provided for free, society will stop innovating (there's no reason to push the boundaries anymore).

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by chipsy on Saturday January 16, 2016 @09:12AM (#10915291)
Remember, the stuff we want to get rid of by automating is the boring stuff! And we discourage automating it now because our economic model is centered on full employment with abundant labor. What this model has produced is consumer demand that is perpetually shaped by price sensitivity, which encourages bullshit work, bullshit results, and bullshit pay.

We don't need more packaged food with the top ingredients being one or more of "HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP, MILK PROTEIN, SOYBEAN OIL". We don't need fashion that falls apart within one season. We don't need pay-to-win video games, or advertorials, or Buzzfeed. Neither do we need gold Apple Watches, $9000 pens, or palatial mansions. Scarcity of our environmental resources is real, but scarcity in manufactured products? Hardly! We can and should shift towards a quality-centric model - practical quality, not slapping gold leaf on everything.

What we have inherited is a way of seeing the world that is not really using our full potential, but is simply insistent that it is the climb to the top that produces the rewards, in spite of ample evidence to the contrary. BI is not the solution to all of that, but it will shift the demand profile towards quality in all sectors and allow consumers the option of choosing quality. If some of those consumers are "wasting their time" noodling on a guitar, so what? They aren't working at McDonald's.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by dllthomas on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:37PM (#10913150)
I reject the notion that influential music is the only music of value.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by JoeAltmaier on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:23PM (#10913059)
Pretty pessimistic - I'd suggest that only a small minority are influential precisely because of the making-a-living issue. Some of the most influential are lucky art-lottery-winners, not geniuses.

And I wouldn't worry about society falling around our ears if the work ethic is replaced by a creative-energy ethic or something like that. I'd love to try it.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by kwhitefoot on Saturday January 16, 2016 @11:39AM (#10915722)
Why is this comment grey?
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by beat on Saturday January 16, 2016 @05:33PM (#10917192)
Because political partisan trolls went through and downvoted everything I said on this subject. Happens every time. :(
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by cmurf on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:58PM (#10913579)
The free loader problem exists but it's also known that it's essentially an edge case. It's not going to get smaller by making people poor or envious of others so that they work harder. It's a fixed problem.

And this is hardly "a free living", £6000 pounds is $8550. The average monthly Social Security benefit per year is $16092.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by bufordsharkley on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:03PM (#10912942)
I think in order for it to be sustainable, it can't be tied to taxation on production, but rather taxes on rent.

For if production goes down, it becomes impossible to fund this entitlement. But if the entitlement is strictly tied to land rent (analogous to the citizen's dividend that Alaskans get for the extraction of natural resources), this can't completely disappear.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by noonespecial on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:24PM (#10913693)
The system we've got now isn't even working quarter-ass. Finding a "replacement" is a pretty low bar.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by gaius on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:41PM (#10912334)
Also if it replaces the existing complicated system, what happens to the million-odd public sector workers who manage and administer it?
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by dawnbreez on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:55PM (#10912458)
I figure, a BI in the US would be handled through local DMVs (triple acronym combo!) and thus at least some of the officials involved in the old welfare process will be transferred to the DMVs to help keep up. Others will, inevitably, find themselves out of a job; there's a massive, massive number of people in that bureaucracy, far more than we really need even before a BI comes in and makes most of that paperwork obsolete.

The good news is, the money that once went into their paycheck will now be used to fund their Basic Income, and they can find other lines of work.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by rorykoehler on Saturday January 16, 2016 @03:03AM (#10914670)
Then they are not mentally healthy and should be treated as such.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by e40 on Friday January 15, 2016 @05:17PM (#10912630)
The GP was talking about social incentives. You're talking about monetary incentives. Different things. I agree with the GP. There is a real stigma about being on welfare. Someone close to me would rather be homeless than be on welfare. Homeless in the sense that he sleeps on people's couches, and has for several months.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by jonwachob91 on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:51PM (#10912057)
I don't think he's referencing welfare but programs such as disability.

It's not a knock against those with serious disabilities that prevent them from working, but the individuals who sham the system to collect $3k /month in disability pay for their diabetes, and refuse to work. We ALL know someone with diabetes who doesn't sham, but there are lots who do.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by laaph on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:18PM (#10912214)
The people shamming the system have the ultimate incentives not to have income. If you are shown to be able to work, you have to pay back all the income you've ever received from it.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by AlexandrB on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:51PM (#10912056)
Yes! I think you've captured the idea perfectly. It also removes much of the administrative cost of other types of welfare. Cost that's a product of highly complicated rules for who deserves how much welfare.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by vinceguidry on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:56PM (#10912088)
My point is that basic income should be treated as a welfare program, not as a stimulus package. We are bound to be disappointed in the ROI of basic income if we are looking for it to accelerate social evolution all by itself.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by thwarted on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:48PM (#10912399)
This is a good point. I'd go so far to label it a "social program", because even "welfare program" is a loaded term.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by eanzenberg on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:16PM (#10913015)
Why do you assume people behave this way, when there's every indication that human's don't behave with "utopian ideals"? This is exactly why BI is such a terrible idea, along with communism, socialism, and free-market capitalism. The system we have now works "pretty-ok" which is leaps and bounds better than this theory and others which require people to act as "honorable actors".