News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by DanBC on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:45PM (#10912363)
Someone on benefits who spends all their money on alcohol will find themselves grinding their way through civil debt recovery - their landlord will sue for loss of rent and will evict them from the home; utility companies will sue to recover the debt and will cut off the utilities.

and whether that's BI or benefit makes little difference to that. You get the money and it's up to you what you spend it on, once you've spent it that's it, you don't get another dollop if you make unwise choices.

At least in England someone who becomes homeless through non-payment of rent (even as a result of alcoholism) is declared to have made themselves homeless, and they're not eligible for public housing. They might be able to get emergency accommodation in homeless shelters.

There are some slight complications if children are involved - a parent who causes the children to become homeless through alcoholism is going to find considerable child protection social services involvement in their life, but the presence of children may make emergency bed&breakfast housing available. Those are pretty terrible places. They're often not fit for human habitation, and are over crowded.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by Alupis on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:56PM (#10912461)
> Someone on benefits who spends all their money on alcohol will find themselves grinding their way through civil debt recovery

I think the point being made was, do we continue to provide other welfare services to an individual like this, or do we just cut them loose and let them fail?

Many people would argue we would still have to provide assistance to this individual... so then it begs the question, how is a BI any better than the slew of welfare programs we already run? At this point, wouldn't it be better (and probably cheaper long-term) for the government to just buy all the homes in the nation, and provide them free of cost to anyone? Perhaps food should be free as well.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by manicdee on Saturday January 16, 2016 @02:08AM (#10914583)
Your straw man certainly draws a long bow :D

Here are the types of "welfare" that habitual failures might have access to under BI:

- Budgeting advice - Free housing for the homeless - Free psychological consultations - In extreme cases, a controlled spending card (i.e.: an EFTPOS card that can't be used for drugs and gambling)

But we wouldn't give them more money, because they've made a habit of using it badly.