News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by Silhouette on Friday January 15, 2016 @01:09PM (#10910966)
Content industries can and have changed their minds on DRM when consumers force them to.

However, it's also worth noting that the music industry is the only major content industry where this has been achieved.

If anything, things are going the other way with video content. There have been stories this week about Netflix cracking down on those who are circumventing region locking using VPNs. It seems big name shows are increasingly being offered via proprietary pay-per-view systems run by their production organisations, and centralised libraries like Netflix are either not carrying the material or dropping content they used to offer. We still have different release dates for movies in theatres in different countries, and for films and TV shows on DVD/Blu-ray. A recent trend seems to be for US TV shows not to release new seasons on Blu-ray at all here in the UK, so you can buy the lower quality version on DVD or you have to sign up for yet another online service to watch in HD, assuming you even have access to such a service from where you live. All of these measures are overtly consumer-hostile, but there is little the consumer who enjoys TV and movies can do if the entire industry moves that way (short of resorting to illegal channels and risking the consequences, which obviously is what a lot of people do in practice).

The software industry is similarly screwed up. We've gone from buying a copy of something and being able to use it, to buying a copy but needing remote activation, to buying a copy but needing varying degrees of ongoing online access to continue using it, to not even being able to buy a copy and merely renting. Personally I draw the line before I get that far, and refuse to pay for any important software unless I can reasonably expect it to continue working indefinitely. Even then, my businesses have been screwed repeatedly by varying degrees of ongoing online access or cutting off support, and slightly surprisingly, the most expensive professional software is by far the worst for this and for fixing the mess is something goes wrong.

I really hope that before too long the law starts to reflect the real relationships with modern technologies, where the original vendor who would traditionally be the main second party in a purchase contract is effectively just providing an introduction to the real other party, which is the organisation that makes the software/service and is (or isn't) going to provide ongoing support and/or retain ongoing control over it. I also hope that smaller, disruptive software businesses who are starting to take on industry heavyweights can demonstrate that money talks and enough customers are willing to vote with their wallets for less one-sided arrangements. But for now, the possibility that industry heavyweights like Microsoft, Adobe and Autodesk are going to give up their vice-like grips built on DRM and related technologies seems more remote than ever, and all of them are pushing hard in the opposite direction.

Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by JoshTriplett on Friday January 15, 2016 @01:47PM (#10911228)
Apple and Amazon managed to change the practices of the music industry because they had enough power. Netflix has started down the path of building more power, by having their own content. Perhaps when Netflix has enough power they can push back on the video industry.

At least in public, Netflix has claimed that they don't want DRM themselves, and would remove it if they could, but that their content providers require it.

Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by derekp7 on Friday January 15, 2016 @02:06PM (#10911353)
Actually, I think the main reason that music went DRM free was to circumvent Apple's dominance. Since they had by far the most popular portable digital music platform, and wouldn't allow third party DRM on it, the music industry had a choice -- either deal with Apple, or forego DRM altogether.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by tjl on Friday January 15, 2016 @09:04PM (#10913835)
That's basically what happened. Apple wanted to go DRM-free (see Steve Job's Thoughts on Music letter) and did so as soon as they were able according to their contracts. But before they did, the publishers offered DRM-free music to Amazon first allowing them a head start on Apple.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by cpeterso on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:36PM (#10911936)
I think DRM is mostly forced upon Netflix by Hollywood. If Netflix didn't need to DRM every stream, they could reduce their hosting costs and network latency by pushing static video content to CDNs and caching servers. For example, Google hosts YouTube server appliances in ISPs to reduce latency.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by JoshTriplett on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:47PM (#10912019)
While removing DRM would certainly help Netflix, it doesn't stop them from offering such edge boxes already; ISPs can already host a box on their network that supplies Netflix videos to that ISP's customers.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by paulddraper on Saturday January 16, 2016 @11:49PM (#10918323)
That's what they say, but the Netflix original content is still DRM'ed, last time I checked.

The dance doesn't match the music.

Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by arama471 on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:05PM (#10911724)
> However, it's also worth noting that the music industry is the only major content industry where this has been achieved.

Video games are a major industry where there was significant pushback from DRM thanks to sellers like GOG. There are still many games with DRM, but the portion that don't use DRM has increased significantly.

Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by Silhouette on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:31PM (#10913107)
I'm personally very happy for GOG's success, but as I mentioned in response to 'Zikes, we do have to keep that in perspective here. Sadly, that "significant pushback" doesn't seem to stop certain big name game developers from pushing out new products that people will still pre-order by the zillion even though the launch of the previous title in the franchise fell over for days because the servers died or some such.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by Zikes on Friday January 15, 2016 @01:30PM (#10911103)
gog.com is an example of the software industry (or video games, at least) eschewing DRM on an ethical/consumer rights basis. They're highly successful, and may well pressure Steam and other similar markets to follow suit if their upward trend continues.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by Silhouette on Friday January 15, 2016 @02:19PM (#10911429)
Good point, GOG is another modest success story for DRM-free content. That said, success is a relative scale here: even a hit like Witcher 3, where there is an obvious commercial association between GOG and the developers, only sold slightly more copies on GOG than on Steam, while most big name titles either aren't released on GOG at all or sell many times more through other channels like Steam. If we saw the likes of EA and Ubisoft backing off DRM for their new AAA titles instead of doubling down on it even in the face of some very obvious problems, it would mean a lot more in terms of industry direction.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by jMyles on Friday January 15, 2016 @01:52PM (#10911265)
It's no surprise that music leads the way, video (and especially live video) next, and software after that - they are ordered here by complexity.

However, the anti-censorship instinct of the internet will eventually drive all of these forms media to an open distribution model.

Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by icebraining on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:09PM (#10911751)
Ebooks are still DRM'd in the major distribution networks, so I'm not sure the complexity model explains everything.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by cwyers on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:36PM (#10911938)
In an echo of what derekp7 said above about the music industry turning to no-DRM as a way around Apple's restrictions on the iPhone, there are publishers who are turning to DRM-free sales of books directly to consumers to bypass Amazon's control of the Kindle ecosystem. O'Reilly and Packt come to mind immediately, but I'm not sure if it's a function of their audience or I just know of them because I'm in their audience.

EDIT: Which, to the larger point -- DRM is two things, a content play and a platform play. Standardizing DRM is one way to limit the power of platform holders over content providers. Eliminating DRM is another. Deciding whether standardizing DRM is a lesser evil than leaving DRM up to platform holders is a question of who do you fear more, the content owners or the platform owners.

Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by gsnedders on Friday January 15, 2016 @05:15PM (#10912619)
> Standardizing DRM is one way to limit the power of platform holders over content providers.

Half the problem is EME doesn't even attempt to standardise DRM in any real way: it just provides a JS API to deal with DRM'd content, decrypted by some "module" which interfaces with the browser in an undefined way (and in every case except Firefox, does so by bundled with no possibility of any other modules being installed).

Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by tjl on Friday January 15, 2016 @09:06PM (#10913842)
Tor has gone DRM-free for their e-books as well and Baen has been DRM-free from the start.
Re:You Can't Destroy the Village to Save It: W3C vs. DRM, Ro... by jMyles on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:35PM (#10911932)
Hmmm, good point. Perhaps it's a partial explainer, and other factors like inertia, popularity, reach, etc. need to be factored.