Re:Why I'm proud to be a vegan
by cholantesh on Friday January 15, 2016 @10:22AM
(#10909775)
I'm not a vegan and I think the article is self-aggrandizing fluff. However, this rhetorical question you pose:
>Carnivores eat other animals, are they immoral beings? Is nature immoral then?
is one that has been addressed by vegans for a long time, usually on the basis of biology (carnivores are literally incapable of extracting nutritional content from plants, where we generally have that choice), intelligence (some animals are just as intelligent as young humans), and moral agency (the question of whether animals have it). I'm not saying I agree with these arguments, but they exist, and are worthy of discussion. Peter Singer's Animal Liberation is the work that explained these ideas best, much better than I could. I think it's a great read.
If I understand correctly, this line of reasoning states that because animals can't make the choice, we can't make it for them (we could feed them all kibbles if we wanted), but since humans can make the choice, then we should make that choice for all of them.
The author is trying hard to convey the supremacy of vegans over the rest of humanity.
You know somebody is just trying to stir up a flamewar when they bring sexism into the mix for no good reason.
Carnivores eat other animals, are they immoral beings? Is nature immoral then?
Contrary to what the author is trying to make you believe, by definition being a vegan is a personal choice, and nothing more.
If you care about animals, you should support PETA.
If you want to personally protest against the horrible treatment of animals on a lot of the farms, choose to buy free range products.
If you just want to be vegan, fine, do that and respect that not everyone is like you(the same thing vegans ask) and a lot of people prefer that juicy meat.