News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DiY Fiber Optic Light Using ESP8266 by dang on Thursday January 14, 2016 @11:10PM (#10907118)
You're right that the submitted title ("Philips Hue Fiber Optic Light Using ESP8266") was misleading, since the blog post makes clear it's a clone. But your comment would be a lot more valuable if it dropped the personal swipe ("it's like you have no idea") and taught us specifically why. As it stands, it's just an acerbic dismissal, and that makes for a poor HN comment, especially when the target is someone's work.
Re:DiY Fiber Optic Light Using ESP8266 by adysan on Friday January 15, 2016 @12:01AM (#10907301)
got similar feedback on reddit too https://www.reddit.com/r/arduino/comments/40w7et/philips_hue...

I can see how people can get worked up over this. Here's what I replied over there:

Thanks for pointing that out. I agree that from a technical standpoint this is not the same as a Philips Hue bulb or light strip. If you look at it from a users point of view, all Philips Hue is a lamp that you control the Brightness and Hue of. This gives you that functionality. No Zigbee protocol. True, but in the context of HomeKit/HAP-NodeJS, does it matter how the bridge talks to the light? I might as well be using 433MHz transceivers, nRFs, or directly controlling the Raspberry Pi's GPIOs. For that matter, ZigBee would be doable too, but I don't know enough about the protocol to see it's benefits. No smart mesh network where each device extends your coverage. True, but a mesh network can be implemented with ESP8266. But if my whole house has WiFi, I don't see the point. No possible compatibility with either Phillips' Hue bridge, Hue remotes, or any other kind of Hue hardware (like Phillips' Hue+Ambilight TV's). Actually, using the Philips Hue shim in Homebridge, I believe it should be possible to make it compatible to Hue bridge. My motivation behind making this was to prove that with ESP8266 based projects, you don't need to have a clunky web UI or a custom app. This lamp can be controlled with any app that support HomeKit. Philips Hue was just the most similar commercial product I could think of. Btw, HAP-nodeJS can be completely eliminated here by using nRF51/52 BTLE chips. They can emulate the HomeKit API and control the NeoPixels both in one chip, so no bridge necessary!

Re:DiY Fiber Optic Light Using ESP8266 by kefka on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:37AM (#10908610)
Oh, and I think what you did is small (in terms of deployment), but tremendously important.

Current IoT implementations all rely on a corporate link to their servers, which I heartily disagree with. You can see a lot more of my acerbic complaints on my blog crankylinuxuser.net as well as reddit /u/crankylinuxuser :)

People like us add to a growing force that says "We will not accept non-standards." I don't care of BigCo makes IoT gear: Just use MQTT/CoAP/AMQP or make doing so trivial. Don't make me use your garbage API on your servers.

Re:DiY Fiber Optic Light Using ESP8266 by mappum on Friday January 15, 2016 @12:02AM (#10907307)
Also, I find it strange they felt so strongly about the whole thing that they created an account just to comment.
Re:DiY Fiber Optic Light Using ESP8266 by dang on Friday January 15, 2016 @01:04AM (#10907526)
HN users are often passionate about correctness, which is a fine thing, but it's best if they share their knowledge with the rest of us.