"Consultants invent these kinds of phrases to label things we’ve all known all along—it’s a perversion of business life that fancy words always cost more than plain ones, even though the plain ones are more valuable."
From Agile Development with Rails, 4th edition.
I assume the irony is intentional?
While Valve isn't perfect either, their system appears positively utopian when contrast with Holacracy.
[0] http://www.valvesoftware.com/company/Valve_Handbook_LowRes.p...
The interview process is pretty intense, so I talked to a lot of people there. They mostly seemed aligned on their opinions of what was working well, what wasn't, etc. None of their opinions matched what I heard from Tony.
I have to imagine then, that this Holacracy experiment, as implemented at Zappos, must have been even more bizarre than it seems generically.
Try some of the documentation here: http://www.holacracy.org/constitution#art1
(Oh, and it looks like there are companies that will consult with you and help you move to a Holocracy. Big surprise).
I work in an org that is flat. There's none of that nonsense. You don't need it. You really don't.