The idea that hard forks are dangerous or irresponsible is a belief that is not well supported. However it's a rather good piece of Bitcoin Core propaganda to scare people away from doing what's necessary.
bip99 - https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0099.mediawi...
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitcoinxt/comments/3t21dh/dangerous...
https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3griiv/on_consensu...
> scare people away from doing what's necessary
Most block size hard-forks can be deployed as a soft-fork. "It's necessary" is highly contentious and you have failed to cite any of the arguments you disagree with- you're wasting everyone's time.
An accidental hard-fork is a completely different animal from an intentional contentious hard-fork where half of the network goes one way and the other half the other way for the foreseeable future.
Could a cryptocurrency not be controlled by those who can afford to spend the most in CPU power (like governments)?
Could consensus occur by human power?
Something that's really confusing is that the word "fork" actually means at least two different things in the block-size debate context. The first is forking the bitcoin software, and the second is forking of the bitcoin blockchain/network. Bitcoin XT, Hearn's project, was the former, a software fork, that would cause a "hard-fork" in the blockchain. Hard-forks in Bitcoin are very dangerous. There has never been an intentional hard-fork of the Bitcoin blockchain since its inception 7 years ago.
There's a very difficult question of just simply, "how do hard-fork?" A hard-fork would separate the p2p network into two different networks with incompatible rules. A hasty hard-fork could very easily destroy people's money and bitcoin all together. Many, including myself, strongly disagree with Bitcoin XT's hard-fork procedure.
It's also not clear that this particular software fork, Bitcoin XT, is better. I'm not going to go into that issue here as it's extremely complicated. We have an alternative solution, segregated witness, which is effectively equivalent to Bitcoin XT's short-term plan implemented as a blockchain soft-fork. Soft-forks are significantly less dangerous as they do not segregate the network.
[1] https://bitcoin.org/en/bitcoin-core/capacity-increases-faq