News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by kevhsu on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:49PM (#10904804)
There's also an explicit racial component to college admissions that I think plenty of us suspect does actually exist in the form of quotas, higher average scores/academic performance. That part can go pretty easily.
Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by hackuser on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:54PM (#10904858)
Do you mean the preference for white upper middle-class kids, or the affirmative action-like preferences?
Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by kevhsu on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:13PM (#10905077)
I mean the preference for other races besides Asian when academic performance is held equal. Which I guess would fall under 'affirmative action.' The typical argument is that colleges want kids who are more 'well-rounded' and Asian kids are stereotyped to be less so.
Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by hackuser on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:47PM (#10905366)
> The typical argument is that colleges want kids who are more 'well-rounded' and Asian kids are stereotyped to be less so.

I didn't know any college used that argument. Certainly those kids should be judged on their own merits and not on stereotypes.

> I mean the preference for other races besides Asian when academic performance is held equal.

My point above, which I might not have explained well, is that racial preferences are unavoidable. Academic performance can't be held equal because the various applicants are competing on playing fields that can differ radically. (Also, as I point out at the end, Harvard admits students on many factors that aren't due to performance but due to the applicants' families' social networks and wealth.)

The best Harvard can do is manage the situation to make it as fair as possible, which may include balancing the discrimination against some races with preferences in their favor. I can understand arguments either way but I don't think it's realistic to eliminate that component withhout looking at its affect on the whole system.

Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:51PM (#10906209)
If they really wanted to make it as fair as possible, they'd set some minimum admissions standards, and then just select randomly from the set of students who meet those.
Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by wbl on Thursday January 14, 2016 @08:11PM (#10906328)
>Academic performance can't be held equal because the various applicants are competing on playing fields that can differ radically

Caltech manages to do this just fine. So does UC Berkeley. Harvard could stop racism if it wanted to.

Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by brownbat on Thursday January 14, 2016 @08:57PM (#10906548)
Interesting. Googling led me to a post[1] which claimed that Caltech uses a "pure meritocracy" and avoids consideration of race in admissions.

hackuser's original post noted that there are race-based sorting effects outside of the admissions department. To that point, Caltech's admission policy, flaws or merits of it aside, is not a counterexample to hackuser's claim[2]. That's exactly the sort of system hackuser was talking about.

[1] http://jadeluckclub.com/caltech-meritocracy-from-the-america...

[2] Which I took to be, essentially, "racial discrimination in admissions is inevitable due to selection factors beyond the control of admissions policies."

EDIT: readability.

Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by jonsterling on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:42PM (#10906151)
"well-roundedness" includes all sorts of stuff, like sports (especially WASP-y sports, like things involving boats) as well as volunteering and voluntourism.
Re:A Push to Make Harvard Free Also Questions the Role of Ra... by igonvalue on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:07PM (#10905014)
Honest question. Have you read the article?

> But they have tied the notion to another equally provocative question: Does Harvard shortchange Asian-American applicants in admissions?