News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by davidw on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @05:20PM (#10898061)
Look at Knuth's future book plans, and consider all the things he's not putting in them that are current. He's also revisited the books some, and plans to do so again in the future.

I don't mean to take away from the books - they're beautiful and full of a lot of timeless knowledge. There's just something that seems a bit ... I can't even find a word for it ... about the endeavor.

Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by zzalpha on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @07:07PM (#10898694)
I believe the word you're looking for is sisyphean, and I actually don't agree.

You've yet to make the case that the fundamentals of computing science are changing so much that documenting them is not a worthy task.

Again, basic algorithms and data structures simply have not changed. Their performance characteristics, methods for optimal implementation, etc, certainly have as computer architectures have evolved (think reordering CPUs, multi-level caches, changes to data storage technology, etc). But the basic algorithms remain the same. Quicksort is still quicksort.

It's true that over the last decade some new concepts have reached a new prominence (e.g., lock-free data structures), but those are additions to the field. They certainly don't invalidate the basics.

Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by mylons on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @07:32PM (#10898803)
you are very correct. I've spent the last 7 years in bioinformatics doing algorithm development and it's almost entirely specialized versions of existing and established algos from decades ago.
Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by ethbro on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @08:06PM (#10898932)
Yup, because the math (ironically, the part most people find most difficult about the series) doesn't change. Algorithmic complexity, number theory, set theory. These are things that show up again and again in "higher level" concepts.

These are computer science books, not software engineering books.

Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by davidw on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @09:44PM (#10899324)
> documenting them is not a worthy task.

Woah there! No one ever said anything about 'not worthy'. I have tremendous admiration and respect for Knuth and his work, and like you say, a lot what he's written is timeless.

Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by mturmon on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @06:52PM (#10898623)
You totally have a point.

TAOCP is not only hyper-focused, obsessive, bloated, difficult, and outdated, but also genius and foundational and connected to everything.

Kind of like TeX and Metafont.

Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by paisawalla on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @05:52PM (#10898296)
It would really help if you could list some specific ways that the theory of computation has changed since the writing of TAOCP, and some evidence for why you think that theoretical CS is changing faster than can be documented.
Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by davidw on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @06:13PM (#10898418)
TAOCP has not been written, several volumes of it have. It remains to be seen whether Knuth will even be able to finish what he set out to do, let alone include new things.

> faster than can be documented.

By one person, I wrote.

Here's one that I think is interesting, difficult and evolving: distributed systems. This shows interesting work happening with version vectors, for instance, over the past 15 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Version_vector

Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by marvy on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @07:25PM (#10898767)
No need to worry about that one. Looking at Wikipedia's list of volume's, looks like distributed systems are not being covered. But I agree with you anyway. Let's quote the man himself (taken from his website): "As I continue to write Volumes 4 and 5, I'll need to refer to topics that belong logically in Volumes 1--3 but weren't invented yet when I wrote those books". He plans to complete Volume 5 by 2025. Tune in ten years from now to see how it goes.
Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by laichzeit0 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @02:41AM (#10900084)
Knuth is currently 78 years old. It would be interesting to see if he lives to 88, never mind still have the intellectual and or physical capacity to complete such a work.

I wish him the best of lucky and sincerely hope he pulls it off.

Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by damcedami on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:04AM (#10900286)
Yes, he will revisited the first three books after the fifth finish, cmiiw.
Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? by mooreds on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @07:00PM (#10898652)
quixotic?