News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by xlayn on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @11:07AM (#10895281)
My opinion: “I don’t want to sound arrogant,” This is critical, remember Ballmer dismissing the iPhone? and Blackberry... and telcos...

"Apple doesn’t know how to handle a supply chain, or market its wares" that could also mean they can disrupt and disruption points are associated with market changes (check vapor engine vs fuel or iPhone vs every other phone).

“We are going to build smart cars, but we also need to build smart roads, smart parking, smart public transportation systems, and more,” and this is the critical point, I'm old in tech years... and I like my clockwork internal combustion engines, I like to be able to drive them but the future people may not, getting what that future mass wants is the million dollar goal. For example... people may not want a car but to get somewhere and for example in NY that sound more rational than in TX, can we build a company around providing "Car as a service" (you hear it first here from xlayn :p)

"the Ford executives believe that the firm’s in-house tech expertise is under-appreciated" or it can also mean they could leverage someone else expertise... (this is a question, I don't really know the answer).

Last but not least... he want's to get the company into something while keeping the strong advantage they have in what they are strong and not becoming a hipster startup (as in lets make a trillion dollar company around 140 characters but there is no revenue model)...

Edit: typos

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by jessriedel on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @12:16PM (#10895844)
> "the Ford executives believe that the firm’s in-house tech expertise is under-appreciated"

5 minutes trying to use a Ford's music system makes it pretty clear that, at least for tech UI, they are awful. That they aren't publicly sheepish about it suggests that the guys in charge don't even notice the differences.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by sisk on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @01:03PM (#10896188)
... but isn't Sync a Microsoft product built into Ford cars? It certainly was when I worked there in the mid-2000s.

EDIT: Gen 1 and 2 are while the upcoming Gen 3 is built by Blackberry.

"Ford cited issues with Microsoft's complex software dragging down its scores with Consumer Reports and other consumer magazines being a reason it switched to BlackBerry."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Sync

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by SilasX on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @01:38PM (#10896425)
I tried out Sync myself, and I strongly agree with jessriedel. What's more, I don't think the bad design can be blamed on MS; much of Ford's side of it was a failure too. From my review at the time [1]

- They don't make it easy to get someone to show you the system. (pts 1 and 2)

- They make it so that if you just leave your iPod (a lot of people didn't have the phone at the time) plugged in, it has to be prominently visible to thieves (pt 4)

- Despite them expecting you to use Sync for anything and everything, it's on an inner row of the steering wheel, requiring a really long thumb stretch to reach. (pt 6)

- Hitting the phone button when you don't have a phone set up with it, will disable the audio system (and thus, further Sync action) until next time you turn the car on. (pt 8)

[1] http://blog.tyrannyofthemouse.com/2008/07/setting-sync-strai...

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by bduerst on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @04:46PM (#10897799)
That blog post is from eight years ago.

I am currently driving a C-Max and some of your points aren't relevant:

- The dealer rep went to lengths to train me on the sync system even though I insisted I didn't need it. (Maybe it's different elsewhere)

- The USB connection is inside the cubby between the seats, so you don't need to leave mp3 players in visible locations.

- The sync activation is on the steering wheel, near the volume buttons, and is not at all difficult to tap.

All in all, Sync has a weird tiered command system which is why I don't use it much, but it's not for lack of physical design.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by SilasX on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @05:56PM (#10898319)
I know -- the point was to criticize how many serious blunders they committed in their initial attempt and which couldn't be blamed on Microsoft, to substantiate the point about poor UX expertise. Certainly, they eventually got it right 8 years later, but the point stands that they don't have some stellar in-house team.
Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by merpnderp on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @01:01PM (#10896168)
This times 100. I have a 2011 Ford truck and hate the Sync system. It is absolute garbage, from blutooth syncing, usb syncing, to having a finicky mostly unusable interface. Add in that it was upgradeable for a while by myself, but then for some reason I had to take it in for $150 at the shop to get further upgrades.

I've been burned so bad, I'll only look at vehicles that support Carplay in the future.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by eitally on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @01:13PM (#10896248)
They upgraded to a new major version of Sync either this year or last, and it's MUCH better (I recently rented a 2015 Expedition XLT). It's still MUCH WORSE than even Chevy's system, though, so ymmv.
Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by ErikAugust on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @01:42PM (#10896458)
Woof.

Right.

If you can't design a music system UI, what about something mission critical like the critical interface between human driving, and self-driving automation?

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by lsc on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @11:24PM (#10899629)
>That they aren't publicly sheepish about it suggests that the guys in charge don't even notice the differences.

My impression is that part of the 'being in charge' job is not acting sheepish, no matter how bad your product is, unless you have a solution that is dramatically different at hand.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @02:40PM (#10896887)
Are you seriously suggesting that the music system should be considered part of an automobile's core feature set?

Personally, I'll swap a radio out in a heartbeat. A transmission, not so much.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by Retric on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @03:25PM (#10897209)
Replacing radios has become far less common. Also, wheels and hubcaps are 'core' features that people often replace.

PS: Car people sometimes do end up replacing the drive train. One guy I heard about replaced everything until his gear shaft was the weak point and it ended up breaking.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by djloche on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @12:21PM (#10895889)
Apple looks obvious in hindsight, but at the time that was the reputation Apple had established for itself. Supply chain problems. Marketing problems. Money problems.

eg. Blackberry is getting into the car automation business too. Right now that's a "lol, ok" response from most people, but if you look at the tech they own and are working on (QNX) it makes sense as a possible direction forward for the company. Will it pay off? I suppose in 10 years time we will look back and it will be obvious whether the investment was worth it or not.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by sbov on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @02:57PM (#10897012)
I took the original Ford quotes regarding Apple/Tesla a bit differently.

People keep these things for up to 30 years. I haven't had a car I kept for less than 10 years, and the average is over 10. There is a huge support network that goes into enabling this. At this stage in the game, are you willing to buy an Apple or Tesla product that you plan to keep for more than 10 years? Are you willing to bet that those Tesla supercharge stations will still exist in 10, 20, or 30 years?

This is what the average consumer wants.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by orky56 on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @02:37PM (#10896869)
Thanks for pulling such a great excerpt. SV culture is about innovation, find solutions <i>in spite of</i> constraints. If the infrastructure is lacking, a combination of hardware & software can work around it to still accomplish the goals. It's funny but the auto industry, specifically Ford with the Model T, created the demand for cars arguably spurring the development of the network of roads required to take full advantage.

What makes this time exciting is that there is an intersection of some amazing technologies, business models, and objectives for transportation: on-demand, renewables & energy, self-driving/autonomous, environment, etc. The best part is that multiple companies, new and old, are involved and want a piece of the increasingly bigger pie.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by ambicapter on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @01:48PM (#10896503)
"Apple doesn’t know how to handle a supply chain, or market its wares"

...Aren't these Apple's strengths?

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by gamblor956 on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @02:34PM (#10896841)
They are, now. That was the point of the comment. Apple's weaknesses are now their biggest strengths.
Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by Spooky23 on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @03:47PM (#10897359)
A company like Ford with a massive dealer network, good relationships with fleet buyers and other things that a new entrant doesn't have.

If I want to buy a Tesla, I need to drive 150 miles and hope the thing never breaks. I have 4-5 Ford dealers within 20 minutes.

Those dealers are sales channels, service channels and capable of doing more stuff. With the right strategy, those legacy disadvantages can be advantages. If Apple is able to build the capability to build a car in a couple of years, it's ridiculous to think that a company in the car business for a century cannot do it.

Re:Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple by surge on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @03:10PM (#10897092)
lol, a company that has to meet the demand of people lining up out the door across the world everytime they release a new product, doesn't know how to manage a supply chain...