News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by lutusp on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @06:23AM (#10893567)
> If a black hole can never form, as viewed by me, then black holes don't exist.

But they do -- the evidence is copious:

http://www.galacticcenter.astro.ucla.edu/animations.html

Arguing that, because the event horizon collapses the time dimension (from the perspective of a distant observer), therefore BHs aren't real, is like saying that sum(2^-n,(n,1,oo)) can't equal 1 because it's an infinite series and an infinity of additions takes too long.

Think of black holes as objects of great mass, that have very bright accretion disks, surrounding an event horizon that is perpetually almost forming a singularity but never quite completes it (from the perspective of someone far from the horizon).

> This means that time is stopped for the center of mass of the black hole ...

From the perspective of a distant observer, the time horizon is located at the event horizon.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by ars on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @07:06AM (#10893716)
> But they do -- the evidence is copious:

The evidence is non-existent. The only evidence is for supermassive objects, not event horizons.

> Arguing that ... BHs aren't real, is like saying ... an infinite series and an infinity of additions takes too long.

That's a terrible argument. One is an actual physical process, the other is a mathematical abstraction. Do you not understand infinity? Infinity means you can't actually do it. It doesn't mean you can't calculate it.

> Think of black holes as objects of great mass, that have very bright accretion disks, surrounding an event horizon that is perpetually almost forming a singularity but never quite completes it (from the perspective of someone far from the horizon).

Eh? If it never forms a singularity, it has no event horizon. i.e. it has none of the physic breaking properties of black holes.

And accretion disks don't have to be bright BTW, as stuff falls in time dilation makes them much less bright (they "slow down", and emit photons less often).

> From the perspective of a distant observer, the time horizon is located at the event horizon.

When I say center of mass of the black hole I am naming the object I am talking about, not describing the location of the time horizon. Sorry if it was confusing.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by lutusp on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @02:07PM (#10896647)
>> But they do -- the evidence is copious:

> The evidence is non-existent.

If you're familiar with Occam's razor, you know that, for a given phenomenon, the simplest explanation is to be preferred. There certainly are massive objects at the center of most galaxies, and the most economical explanation is that they're black holes. No one is closing the book on these ideas -- that would be unscientific -- but there is strong evidence that these things are black holes.

That they exist is beyond question. That they have super-high masses confined to a small space is beyond question. General Relativity then fills in the blanks in our observations.

> That's a terrible argument. One is an actual physical process, the other is a mathematical abstraction.

So is General Relativity. But because nature follows the same rules, General Relativity accurately predicts many aspects of reality (certainly not all).

> And accretion disks don't have to be bright BTW ...

Well, yes, they do -- they're giving up a huge amount of gravitational potential energy, and that energy must be conserved -- it's converted to kinetic energy, it becomes heat and light.

Consider a satellite in an elliptical orbit. At the orbital apoapsis, potential energy is highest and kinetic energy is lowest. Not surprisingly, this is the point of smallest velocity. Now consider periapsis -- it's the reverse: lowest potential energy, highest kinetic energy, therefore highest velocity.

In a normal planetary elliptical orbit with no friction, even though the two kinds of energy are constantly changing, they sum to a constant at each point in the orbit, so there's no net dissipation of energy. But as matter falls into a black hole, in order for it to pass through the event horizon, it must give up most of its energy (both potential and kinetic). Most of that energy is converted into heat and light.

Most accretion disks preserve the rotational momentum of the infalling mass, so they're in the form of disks surrounding the event horizon. In theory, mass could fall directly into the BH without any rotation -- in that case, there would still be a huge energy conversion process and much radiated energy. Sp accretion disks are very bright.

Here's a graphic of the imagined BH from "Interstellar", thought to be fairly accurate as movie graphics go:

http://www.wired.com/2014/10/astrophysics-interstellar-black...

> Eh? If it never forms a singularity, it has no event horizon.

Yes, and by the same reasoning, because a Calculus limit expression never gets to its limit, therefore Calculus is bunk. My point? Just as (1+1/n)^n approaches e as n approaches infinity (http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=limit+n+-%3E+inf%2C+%28...), a black hole approaches its final form as mass approaches it from the perspective of a distant observer.

You might as well have argued that, because this classic-physics gravitational equation:

f = (G m1 m2) / r^2

assumes that all the mass is a dimensionless point at the center of the central body, therefore if m1 and m2 occupy the same point in space, the result is infinite, therefore (because infinity isn't a number) Newtonian gravitation is bunk.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by ars on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @06:09PM (#10898397)
> There certainly are massive objects at the center of most galaxies, and the most economical explanation is that they're black holes

That is just not true. To be a black hole it must first be possible for black holes to exist, otherwise they are simply supermassive object - to us they would look EXACTLY the same!

A black hole is NOT the simplest explanation! It's the most complicated one. You are using your razor very incorrectly.

> That they exist is beyond question.

Absolutely not true. That massive objects exist? Sure. Are they black holes? Not so clear.

> That they have super-high masses confined to a small space is beyond question. General Relativity then fills in the blanks in our observations.

No, actually General Relativity does NOT fill in the blanks - it claims things are impossible. The math does the equivalent of divide by zero.

> So is General Relativity. [a mathematical abstraction]

Great, so since GR predicts it would take infinite time, I guess case closed. Since infinite time, by definition, can not actually happen, it means black holes can not form. Just because you can calculate what something will do doesn't mean it will actually do it.

> Well, yes, they do -- they're giving up a huge amount of gravitational potential energy, and that energy must be conserved -- it's converted to kinetic energy, it becomes heat and light.

Kinetic energy does not become heat and light. Kinetic energy is velocity. To make heat and light you need some other process. Have you never heard of conservation of momentum?

On top of that, the discs are dim because time is dilated to nothing not because there is no energy there.

> But as matter falls into a black hole, in order for it to pass through the event horizon, it must give up most of its energy (both potential and kinetic). .... in that case, there would still be a huge energy conversion process .... Most of that energy is converted into heat and light.

How in the world are you writing this stuff? You can't just "give up" velocity. You have to transfer that velocity to something else. You can't just wave your hands and say "magic". Friction might cause objects to equalize in velocity, but can not actually reduce velocity (only share it amongst the objects).

> a black hole approaches its final form as mass approaches it from the perspective of a distant observer.

And takes infinite time to do so, and since right now is not infinitely in the future, right now, today, black holes do not exist.

Infinite. Do you not understand that word? It means forever, it means it never actually does it, just gets closer and closer.

> therefore if m1 and m2 occupy the same point in space, the result is infinite, therefore (because infinity isn't a number) Newtonian gravitation is bunk.

Nice question, wrong conclusion. The actual conclusion is that since infinity is not actually seen in the real world (as opposed to math), there must be some method that prevents the two masses from ever occupying the same spot.

Your argument is entirely backward, you think that if infinity shows up in the math then it must show up in the real world. No. If infinity shows up in the math then your math is wrong, or incomplete. In this case there is something else that prevents r from hitting zero.

Maybe you should read this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_of_a_function

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by lutusp on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @06:40PM (#10898558)
>> it's converted to kinetic energy, it becomes heat and light.

> Kinetic energy does not become heat and light.

So have you told the LHC people that they're misguided for thinking they can produce the Higgs Boson by colliding protons together? I'm sure you can persuade them how wrong they are.

> Kinetic energy is velocity.

Yes, among many other things: http://physics.info/energy/ (see the table "Types of kinetic energy")

Electromagnetic energy (heat and light) is a kind of kinetic energy.

But you know what? I've decided not to try to correct all the errors you've made. If you actually understood physics, you wouldn't have objected to the things you have (you might have found a better reason to object).

> Friction might cause objects to equalize in velocity, but can not actually reduce velocity ...

Wow. Those fools in Europe are sure misguided to have spent so much money on a circular 17 mile pipe dream. if only they had consulted with you before building that monstrous contraption. They actually think their gadget can convert near-light-speed velocities into many other kinds of energy, including electromagnetic, and the creation of particles from energy and the reverse. Do them a favor -- set them straight, as you've set me straight.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by ars on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @07:10PM (#10898708)
You have GOT to be trolling me. There is no way.

The LHC collides TWO protons! The net velocity between them is zero.

You seem to know at least some physics, how can you possibly not know this?

But in your black hole scenario there are not two opposite velocities adding up at the horizon.

You can not just directly turn velocity into light, it's not possible, you need another object.

> Electromagnetic energy (heat and light) is a kind of kinetic energy.

Some people define only two kinds of energy: Potential and Kinetic, in that definition electromagnetic energy is a type of kinetic energy, and velocity is a type of kinetic energy.

But it does NOT follow that electromagnetic energy is the same as velocity energy!

It's like an apple is a fruit and an orange is a fruit, but an apple is not an orange.

> They actually think their gadget can convert near-light-speed velocities into many other kinds of energy, including electromagnetic, and the creation of particles from energy and the reverse.

I take it you've never heard of conservation of momentum? You can not just turn the velocity into other things, you have to react it with something else (which is what I said - go back and read it). In this case they react it with a proton going the other way.

They could also react it with the earth, or a slab of metal.

None of these apply to a black hole.

We have also gotten way off topic from time dilation.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by lutusp on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @09:24PM (#10899255)
> The LHC collides TWO protons! The net velocity between them is zero.

Yes, but only because their original velocity has been converted into other forms of kinetic energy, like heat and light, among other things like Higgs bosons. Here is what you said:

> Kinetic energy does not become heat and light.

I proved your statement to be false. End of story. Now stop trolling.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by ars on Thursday January 14, 2016 @02:17AM (#10900045)
LOL LOL LOL.

You most certain did not.

Is this like some kind of contest to you to see if you win? Even if you win, you'll still be wrong.

Instead of focusing on that, why not actually learn something?

"To make heat and light you need some other process." For example, another proton to crash into. You can't just directly convert the velocity to energy, you need another object take the velocity from you.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by lutusp on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:48AM (#10900404)
Before:

> Kinetic energy does not become heat and light.

Now:

> "To make heat and light you need some other process."

Translation: "You were right." Apart from the fact that heat and light are kinetic energy.

Further reading: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/gravitational-wave...

Quote from the above article: "LIGO's detectors, at their current sensitivity, could pick up only gravitational waves of frequencies well above 10 Hertz. So if they have picked up a signal, they would have captured the final stages of the drama, when the black holes circle more than 10 times per second, speeding up to several thousand times a second just before they merge. Simulations show that the resulting waves, if played as an audible sound, resemble a bird’s ‘chirp’ (http://www.ligo.org/science/GW-Inspiral.php) (http://www.ligo.org/science/GW-Overview/sounds/chirp40-1300H...)."

My original remark from yesterday, to which you ignorantly objected: "... eventually two black holes will merge, which will produce a completely fantastic observation consisting of a rapidly rising frequency (as the two BHs circle each other closer and closer, shedding their orbital energy as gravitational waves), followed by a very loud cosmological pop as the BHs finally collapse into each other."

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by ars on Thursday January 14, 2016 @03:31PM (#10904229)
You clearly have problems reading.

I have said exactly the same thing the entire time, only you kept ignoring it. Or, to be charitable, maybe just not understanding it. Just because you don't understand the words I said, doesn't mean I didn't say it.

Do you need me to quote myself?

Also, I take it you did not ever study physics? If you did you would know this on your own without me telling you.

What I said, over and over, is you can not turn velocity into light directly, you have to transfer that velocity to something else. In an event horizon there is nothing to transfer the velocity to, since everything is moving more or less at the same speed.

I don't know why you can't seem to absorb this. I really don't. It's basic highschool physics, plus I've said it over and over and over and over. In as many different ways as I can think of.

> Apart from the fact that heat and light are kinetic energy.

Are you totally incapable of absorbing information? I know that sounds insulting, but I am serious. You keep saying the same wrong thing over and over despite being told different.

You are wrong. Period.

It's like you have a mental block stopping you from understanding this, I don't get it.

> ... eventually two black holes will merge, which will produce a completely fantastic observation consisting of a rapidly rising frequency (as the two BHs circle each other closer and closer, shedding their orbital energy as gravitational waves), followed by a very loud cosmological pop as the BHs finally collapse into each other."

Back to this, very nice. The problem is that they won't actually do this - time dilation means it will take infinite time for this to happen, so we'll never see this.

Not sure what the point of telling you this is though. If you can't understand Conservation of Momentum there is zero chance you'll understand relativity.

Try this - stop arguing with me. Clearly I'm not the teacher for you.

Go find some other people - show them this thread if you like. Then have them explain Conservation of Momentum to you. Also ask them to explain the difference between kinetic and electromagnetic energy.

Please do that before replying, otherwise we'll just be going in a circle.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by lutusp on Thursday January 14, 2016 @09:08PM (#10906597)
> I have said exactly the same thing the entire time

This is a lie -- you keep changing your claim to keep up with the facts other people provide you with. Examples below.

> What I said, over and over, is you can not turn velocity into light directly, you have to transfer that velocity to something else.

That's not what you said originally, and you are now lying. You said that "Kinetic energy does not become heat and light. Kinetic energy is velocity." Both statements are false (velocity is one of many examples of kinetic energy but the reverse claim is an error of omission), and I provided the literature references, which you refused to read.

You earlier said:

> Friction might cause objects to equalize in velocity, but can not actually reduce velocity (only share it amongst the objects).

Totally false -- velocity is not conserved, energy is conserved. There's no conservation of velocity law. If you were a scientist, if you knew anything about physics and possessed intellectual integrity, you would drop a lump of clay, watch it abruptly stop at the floor as it efficiently converts velocity into heat. Or two billiard balls on a collision course, or two protons at the LHC, etc. etc..

> Clearly I'm not the teacher for you.

"The teacher?" You're utterly ignorant and a narcissist to boot. You're severely mentally ill, unfortunately there's no cure for malignant narcissism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malignant_narcissism).

We're done -- you have to learn this on your own without embarrassing yourself further in this public forum. Have a nice day.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by ars on Friday January 15, 2016 @01:56AM (#10907689)
> velocity is not conserved, energy is conserved. There's no conservation of velocity law

But there is, it's called Conservation of Momentum. It's velocity times mass. Go look it up - it will take just a few seconds on google. I'll wait.

> you would drop a lump of clay, watch it abruptly stop at the floor as it efficiently converts velocity into heat

No, it transferred its velocity to the entire planet.

> Or two billiard balls on a collision course

One has positive velocity, the other negative. They cancel out.

But go try making two billiard balls stop when they are both going the same way (as in your example about particles near the event horizon). You can't. Try it - maybe it will help. You have to transfer the velocity to something else.

> We're done -- you have to learn this on your own without embarrassing yourself further in this public forum. Have a nice day.

Oh, we were done ages ago.

One you do learn some physics you'll recall this conversion and cringe in embarrassment, not at your ignorance, but at your refusal to learn.

Your attempt at "diagnosing me" doesn't perturb me, because I know this stuff backward and forwards. Your obstinacy just amuses me. This stuff is so basic your comments are just laughable.

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by dllthomas on Saturday January 16, 2016 @09:42PM (#10918049)
"One you do learn some physics you'll recall this conversion and cringe in embarrassment, not at your ignorance, but at your refusal to learn."

Just FYI, your conversational partner's website says:

"Paul Lutus has a wide background in science and technology. He designed spacecraft components for the NASA Space Shuttle and created a mathematical model of the solar system used by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory during the Viking Mars mission."

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by ars on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:40PM (#10941932)
That doesn't make any sense at all. How is it possible that someone with a "wide background in science" has not heard about conservation of momentum?

Are you sure it's the same person?

Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi... by dllthomas on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:42PM (#10950419)
Am I sure? I've done no verification. But while I'm occasionally frustrated with the holder of that account I've seen no particular reason to believe that they are not who they claim to be. I am sure that the account holder claims to be Paul Lutus, as the link is on his profile.

'How is it possible that someone with a "wide background in science" has not heard about conservation of momentum?'

It's probably not; but this comment thread (wading through the jibes, snipes, and nonsense) doesn't seem to demonstrate with much clarity that he hasn't.