Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi...
by dllthomas on Saturday January 16, 2016 @09:42PM
(#10918049)
"One you do learn some physics you'll recall this conversion and cringe in embarrassment, not at your ignorance, but at your refusal to learn."
Just FYI, your conversational partner's website says:
"Paul Lutus has a wide background in science and technology. He designed spacecraft components for the NASA Space Shuttle and created a mathematical model of the solar system used by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory during the Viking Mars mission."
Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi...
by ars on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:40PM
(#10941932)
That doesn't make any sense at all. How is it possible that someone with a "wide background in science" has not heard about conservation of momentum?
Are you sure it's the same person?
Re:Scientists struggle to stay grounded after possible gravi...
by dllthomas on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:42PM
(#10950419)
Am I sure? I've done no verification. But while I'm occasionally frustrated with the holder of that account I've seen no particular reason to believe that they are not who they claim to be. I am sure that the account holder claims to be Paul Lutus, as the link is on his profile.
'How is it possible that someone with a "wide background in science" has not heard about conservation of momentum?'
It's probably not; but this comment thread (wading through the jibes, snipes, and nonsense) doesn't seem to demonstrate with much clarity that he hasn't.
But there is, it's called Conservation of Momentum. It's velocity times mass. Go look it up - it will take just a few seconds on google. I'll wait.
> you would drop a lump of clay, watch it abruptly stop at the floor as it efficiently converts velocity into heat
No, it transferred its velocity to the entire planet.
> Or two billiard balls on a collision course
One has positive velocity, the other negative. They cancel out.
But go try making two billiard balls stop when they are both going the same way (as in your example about particles near the event horizon). You can't. Try it - maybe it will help. You have to transfer the velocity to something else.
> We're done -- you have to learn this on your own without embarrassing yourself further in this public forum. Have a nice day.
Oh, we were done ages ago.
One you do learn some physics you'll recall this conversion and cringe in embarrassment, not at your ignorance, but at your refusal to learn.
Your attempt at "diagnosing me" doesn't perturb me, because I know this stuff backward and forwards. Your obstinacy just amuses me. This stuff is so basic your comments are just laughable.