My limited personal experience of the results of disincline (of all kinds) is that inconsistent or random discipline from a parent is worse than almost all others. Children who live in fear of being disciplined for what appears to them to be for no reason, or where their actual behaviour plays very little role in affecting the discipline they experience, fair far worse. It is really hard as a parent, but being consistent is critically important. No means no.
> Spanking remains a common, if controversial, childrearing practice in the United States. In this article, I pair mounting research indicating that spanking is both ineffective and harmful with professional and human rights opinions disavowing the practice. I conclude that spanking is a form of violence against children that should no longer be a part of American childrearing.
My stance is consistent with the recommendations of the American Psychological Association [2] and the American Academy of Pediatrics [3].
The issue is can we have a discussion about it without unfriending each other on Facebook building protective bubbles.
[1]http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3768154/
[2]http://www.apa.org/about/policy/corporal-punishment.aspx
[3]https://www.healthychildren.org/English/family-life/family-d...
Good grief. Come on Dan, you know that comments like this are not allowed here, whether you agree with someone's parenting practices or not.
Europeans think hitting your children is abhorrent - many EU countries have made it illegal.
If someone posted messages about hitting their spouse they'd have similarly strong responses. And there's no difference. The people who hit their children use the same language that was used by people who used corporal punishment on their wives.
In this situation a parent didn't keep their child safe in a potentially dangerous situation (by their own admission the child was poking things into an electrical socket). And for that lack of parental awareness the child gets hit?
It's a revolting interference with the child's human rights and I have no problem telling violent bullies that their behaviour fails to meet the standards a decent society demands.
The modal incivility on HN is probably caused by people commenting on issues that they believe are important enough to override the civility norms on HN. Everyone has issues like this. Coming from a very large very Irish very Catholic family, I find it helpful to think about pro-life activism when issues like this crop up for me. I'll wager you don't think that people who believe abortion is murder should be allowed to prosecute that argument uncivilly here. The same applies to things we believe too.
Aside: I agree with you about hitting children, but (a) corporal punishment is quite common in Europe, and, particularly, in the UK, and (b) the norms against spanking are still new, and it will take a few more generations before you can draw conclusions about how good a parent someone is by whether they believe in spanking.
On the topic of punishment I have never met anyone who ever experienced the odd smack as a young child to be serious concerned about it when they grew up. I have met many people who were never smacked as children, but who were subjected to terrible emotional abuse by their parents, that have been scarred for life.
The reason why spanking is so effective is it ties the action and punishment very close together. Children get pretty used to you yelling at them to stop doing something they want to do, so when they do something really dangerous you need to have someway of getting across to them that whatever they have done should never be done again. Spanking is a tool that should be rarely used, but I have no issue with being used in the appropriate situation.
I don't hit them when I've been inattentive in dangerous situations.
In regards a child playing with a power point this is not a case of being inattentive - you cannot watch what a child does every second of the day inside your own home. It is probably worse for a child to be watched every second of their life than for them to have some freedom and the occasional smack.
Can I ask if your children were placed in child care when they were young?
You always hear some fucking idiot saying "my child ran out into the street, so I hit him". Hear the useless parent put their child at risk of harm by not teaching the child about road safety, by not providing adequate supervision in a dangerous situation, and then punishing the child for the parent's lack of skill.
"I hit my children" is no different from "I hit my spouse" or "I hit my employees".
I think we can avoid false emotional comparisons between spanking a young child and beating your wife.