Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by jakeogh on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:38PM
(#10878027)
Good. Do we really want ISP's (or anyone) deciding who and who is not a "cybercrime gang" anyway? It's trivial to expand the current vogue definition.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by caf on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:43PM
(#10878055)
It doesn't seems like they would need to decide who is and isn't a "cybercrime gang", just whether or not their customer actually owns the IP blocks that they're asking to be routed.
Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by Dylan16807 on Sunday January 10, 2016 @07:57PM
(#10878135)
Uh. Replace "cybercrime gang" with "people that do not own these IPs" and reread the article.
Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by jakeogh on Sunday January 10, 2016 @10:56PM
(#10878689)
In another universe, a "cybercrme gang" lost it's /16 today due to a xyz regulatory body's decision deeming it as such.
"In addition, spamming from these stolen IP addresses is a felony under the US CAN-SPAM Act." said another way.... "In addition, sending information in a unauthorized fashion is a felony under the US CAN-SPAM Act."
Should we really be cheerleading more rules and tighter restrictions on comms? Uh. Lets require biometrics to xmit!
Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by Dylan16807 on Monday January 11, 2016 @12:57AM
(#10879088)
If you're against the entire concept of allocating IPs, I can't help you there.
Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by jakeogh on Monday January 11, 2016 @02:35AM
(#10879393)
I'm against the implied idea that this is a problem we need more rules to fix. If V's peers are really annoyed, they can take their own action.
Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by superuser2 on Monday January 11, 2016 @12:30AM
(#10879005)
The problem is not their distasteful use of IP addresses, but that they are committing the IP-address equivalent of identity theft: doing business under identifiers which are not theirs.
BGP is a trusting protocol, with expectations enforced by social contract rather than cryptography. Part of the social contract among ISPs is that only competent, legitimate entities get to participate in BGP, and Verizon is violating that.
Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by jakeogh on Monday January 11, 2016 @12:38AM
(#10879020)
"competent, legitimate entities" aka whatever that's decided to mean at the moment. BGP is trivially broken, but that's not what's happening here, and even if it was it's a proto flaw, not something that we should be "fixing" with more prior restraint.
It's too easy to restrict people by 'fixing' a non-problem (junk mail from 'gangs' in this case).
Re:Verizon Routing Millions of IP Addresses for Cybercrime G...
by superuser2 on Monday January 11, 2016 @12:57AM
(#10879084)
It is simply not your right advertise routes that aren't yours. Doing so intentionally is solid proof that you have no business participating in BGP, gang or not.