Okay so now you're in a situation where other people who don't work as hard or as smart as you are getting paid close to you, or the same. That doesn't feel good, but what happens next? Well, if you continue working harder than them, you'll be promoted and get a raise, and they won't. And there, the system re-corrects itself.
Now, I COULD buy the argument that seeing people who you know don't work as hard suddenly make the same money as you would make you yourself get lazy and not try as hard. Because surely they can't fire you for performing the same as the rest. But if that's the type of person you are, maybe the company would be better off without you anyway?
When it comes to money, humans are generally irrational in their decision making, mostly biased towards emotional decision making.
*
This actually happened to me when I was 16 years old. I started working at fastfood job making $4.90/hr, WA state's minimum wage. I was a very strong worker, and was offered a position as a manager a few months later. I politely declined (read: my mother told me I was dumb to sacrifice my education in order make an extra $1.00 or so an hour).
Eventually I was making $5.15 an hour through a series of wage increases due to good reviews. Then the Federal government raised minimum wage to $5.15/hr. I went to the store manager and asked for a raise. My argument was that my wage increases were do to my performance and seniority. Any unproven new-hire would start making the same wage as I do. They did not see it that way, and declined to provide me with a compensation increase.
The feeling was irrational. I still made my wage, and new employees wages didn't come out of my pocket, so it had no impact on me. Still, I felt that my salary should reflect the value I bring to the company.
I ended up putting in my two-weeks about a year later when they promoted an inept person to manager.
Or not, if the company has no money left for merit raises because they're paying well above market salaries to others.
But if that's the type of person you are, maybe the company would be better off without you anyway?
So you expect employees to perpetually go above and beyond the job requirements without consideration of whether they'll be rewarded for it?
So were those who got a raise, but the company decided to hand out raises as a gift (not as a reward) to lower performers only - of course this discrimination will be frustrating.
What the company was trying to do was correct a perceived culture wrong that some people were compensated less because their job was perceived as less important.
The reality is that those "less important" jobs frequently actually keep businesses running smoothly. Only a smoothly running business can afford to invest in strategy, thus smooth operation should be as important as strategy.
That (^) right there is another "perception" and is increasingly the one reasonable people are adopting EXACTLY because of what Seth notes:
"It's possible to create dignity and be successful at the same time."
Because the frustration came from being treated unfairly by the management, which they've cut ties with. Also, they might earn more at their new jobs now as well.
Wanting to feel valued in one's "community" isn't comparing yourself to others, it's a basic human emotional need.
I don't see how that follows. Imagine the minimum wage were doubled, do you think McDonald's would respond by laying off half their staff? What do you think that would do to their business?
Companies hire people because they need the work done, not because they have $X allocated to payroll and it's burning a hole in their pocket. If minimum wage goes up then payroll costs will go up, forcing them to either cut profits or find cost savings elsewhere.
No, but a person will definitely think twice before starting a new McDonald's franchise. A small restaurant owner who had been eyeing a second location will think twice about opening up another restaurant.
The incentives will also shift towards higher automation (not necessarily a good or bad thing in and of itself) of tasks as much as possible instead of hiring humans.
Companies don't work like this: "We have X amount of work to do, no matter what it costs". It's more along the lines of whether a project is a net positive (say through a net present value analysis) and if it isn't, then the whole project is scrapped.
Look at how supermarkets now have self-checkout. 4 self-checkout stations going with one employee monitoring, and customers don't mind using them. In fact many customers prefer them because they help them get out of the store more quickly. There's no reason to think that McDonalds won't eventually try to eliminate some of the staff that takes orders. It's just a question of when they'll be incentivized enough to try it.
Which leaves us with a minimum wage in many areas which does not actually allow someone to survive, and a growing population who will end up on welfare anyway regardless (who usually are on welfare anyway because oh look Walmart's HR practices).
http://www.ctvnews.ca/business/mcdonald-s-canada-introducing...
As to state-wide minimum wages - "the" argument against it is that less people are employed at a higher price of labor and that those priced out of the market are likely to be the ones hurt the most by it, though their numbers might be smaller than the numbers of those employed at the higher wage. (Of course this applies to the company with the $70K minimum wage as well: that company could have used the money it cost to implement this policy to instead hire more people.) There are counter-arguments along the lines of the demand for labor being inelastic and other such, but it's kinda off to not present a sensible argument against a minimum wage while presenting a crazy strawman argument against it, the latter implying with a high likelihood that the author supports a high minimum wage.