Re:Lead and Crime: Another Look
by Houshalter on Saturday January 09, 2016 @12:36PM
(#10872051)
Also he's disputing a straw man. No one has claimed that all crime can be explained by a single variable. Only that a variable can have a big effect. Other "simple explanations" for crime could be poverty, broken homes, education, all the traditional explanations. All those are simple explanations and single variables.
Re:Lead and Crime: Another Look
by omginternets on Saturday January 09, 2016 @01:02PM
(#10872157)
I understood his claim a bit differently, namely as "Lead is an epiphenomenon, and a single variable with a big effect is likely to be an epiphenomenon".
To be sure, I think the logic goes like this:
- Lead is positively correlated with crime
- Reduction in lead-levels is associated with multiple factors that are in turn associated with gentrification
- Thus, these gentrification factors are the true cause, and lead-levels just happen to correlate with them.
Most things really are simple; If you see smoke, the simplest explanation happens to be correct: there's fire.
The bias towards simplicity can also be seen as a bias towards parsimony, which is almost always a good thing. We don't immediately recognize this truth because we don't conjure up trivial examples, even though the overwhelming majority of our reasoning is spent on trivial phenomena.