News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lead and Crime: Another Look by refurb on Saturday January 09, 2016 @10:22AM (#10871504)
I'm not surprised. Any time I see a research paper that suggests a highly complex issue, like crime, can be neatly explained by a single variable, my BS meter goes off.

Could a reduction in lead levels contribute to the drop in crime? Sure, but any effect would likely be drowned out by the multitude of other changes that have happened over the past 60+ years.

I'm not sure what it is, but humans seem to be highly suceptable to simple explanations for the world. If you need some examples, just browse snopes.com

Re:Lead and Crime: Another Look by omginternets on Saturday January 09, 2016 @10:33AM (#10871540)
>I'm not sure what it is, but humans seem to be highly suceptable to simple explanations for the world.

Most things really are simple; If you see smoke, the simplest explanation happens to be correct: there's fire.

The bias towards simplicity can also be seen as a bias towards parsimony, which is almost always a good thing. We don't immediately recognize this truth because we don't conjure up trivial examples, even though the overwhelming majority of our reasoning is spent on trivial phenomena.

Re:Lead and Crime: Another Look by Houshalter on Saturday January 09, 2016 @12:36PM (#10872051)
Also he's disputing a straw man. No one has claimed that all crime can be explained by a single variable. Only that a variable can have a big effect. Other "simple explanations" for crime could be poverty, broken homes, education, all the traditional explanations. All those are simple explanations and single variables.
Re:Lead and Crime: Another Look by omginternets on Saturday January 09, 2016 @01:02PM (#10872157)
I understood his claim a bit differently, namely as "Lead is an epiphenomenon, and a single variable with a big effect is likely to be an epiphenomenon".

To be sure, I think the logic goes like this:

- Lead is positively correlated with crime

- Reduction in lead-levels is associated with multiple factors that are in turn associated with gentrification

- Thus, these gentrification factors are the true cause, and lead-levels just happen to correlate with them.

Re:Lead and Crime: Another Look by lordnacho on Saturday January 09, 2016 @12:00PM (#10871916)
Same with the abortion thing. The problem with complex causality is there's arrows going everywhere.
Re:Lead and Crime: Another Look by bluejekyll on Saturday January 09, 2016 @12:32PM (#10872038)
What's interesting to me is less the question of violent crime trending with lead exposure (or abortion), but more the holistic view of society getting more liberal.

As violent crime goes down, as dangerous chemicals/metals are removed from the environment, as the economy improves: all of these have an effect on the other (and I'm sure there are more). Clearly it would be difficult to create a study across all of those cohorts, but the point is that everything is improving, and with it the tendency for our society to be more accepting of differences.