News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by api on Friday January 08, 2016 @03:56PM (#10868169)
I somewhat agree with Graham: economic inequality is not intrinsically the problem and startups are not the problem.

The problem IMHO is rent and profiteering off taxpayer subsidies, both of which more or less force me to pay tribute to the rich.

I don't care one bit if someone else is infinitely richer than me as long as I don't have to pay tribute to them or otherwise be lorded over by them. I would not care if (hypothetically) there were people alive today who were biologically immortal cognitively enhanced cyberpunk demigods with control of wealth flows in excess of present-day US GDP. In an abstract philosophical sense it seems likely that such sentient entities do in fact exist somewhere in our vast universe and I don't see how this likelihood impacts me at all. There are also (statistically speaking) probably a minimum of several hundred million to a billion people smarter, healthier, and better looking than me.

What I do care about is being forced or at least heavily pressured/coerced into paying tribute to those who are above me economically.

A prime example: housing costs are insane and this is partly a result of rich people from around the world parking their wealth in real estate and extracting rent in exchange for little to no investment in anything productive. In general, idle rent extraction is a social ill and should be taxed to hell and back. I would support cuts to capital gains, employment, and income taxes and large increases in taxes on property speculation (non-primary residences) and other non-productive rentier activity. (We might distinguish between productive capitalism and rentier capitalism, though it's hard to draw an absolute black-and-white distinction.)

Other examples of tribute include the many cases where public insurance is used to back-stop private losses while private gains remain private, such as the 2008 bank bailouts or the government paying in part for the cleanup of BP's gulf oil spill, and cases where taxpayer subsidized research and development is privatized for exclusively private gain (and patented!). How many huge companies have been built on the back of government-funded research? (The fact that so much wealth is built on the back of public research and public infrastructure is a common argument for progressive taxation.)

A huge reason I've lost my faith in libertarian politics is that the 2008 bailouts convinced me it's a scam. The rich advocate laissez faire until their wealth is on the line, at which point they become socialists. It's clear to me that for the poor and middle class to forego the use of government coercion is for them to engage in unilateral disarmament. I've heard today's economy described as a casino in which public funds are used to backstop the losses of the highest rollers, and that seems fairly accurate to me.

It's not transformed me into a conventional liberal though. Personally I don't think anyone on the present-day right or left has a clear path out of this. Both sides advocate things that would make the problem worse.

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by mpweiher on Friday January 08, 2016 @05:03PM (#10868666)
> economic inequality is not intrinsically the problem

People keep saying that, and I personally agree that there are other related problems that are bigger than inequality, but inequality by and of itself is a problem, and a significant one at that.

"The average well-being of our societies is not dependent any longer on national income and economic growth. That's very important in poorer countries, but not in the rich developed world. But the differences between us and where we are in relation to each other now matter very much."[1]

And even the wealthy in more unequal societies are less well off than less wealthy people in more equal societies. I think this is an important finding because it is counterintuitive, even surprising.

[1] https://www.ted.com/talks/richard_wilkinson?language=en

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by replicatorblog on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:13PM (#10868294)
This is where things get complex. High rent isn't a natural state of nature—it's the result of building policies that prohibit housing. Austin Texas has roughly as many people as SF/Oak, but housing is plentiful and cheap, even close to the down town. Why? When the population increases, they build more housing.
Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by api on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:15PM (#10868319)
Those policies are an example of the wealthy using the government as a tool to extract rent, hence my comment about unilateral disarmament.

While couched in liberal or eco-whatever rhetoric, make no mistake about it: SF's NIMBY policies are there so that urban property owners can extract rent and homeowners can profit off appreciation. NIMBYism of this sort is an example of regulatory capture.

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by graeme on Friday January 08, 2016 @08:51PM (#10869672)
San Francisco's city population density is 6x Austin's, according to Wikipedia. Are you sure you're comparing apples to apples?

And San Francisco's metro area has more than double the population with about 85% of the land.

People ignore this stuff when talking about the San Francisco. It's already pretty dense, compared to the median US city. It's just that a LOT of people want to live there, and those people have the money to pay.

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by dnautics on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:51PM (#10868591)
> A huge reason I've lost my faith in libertarian politics is that the 2008 bailouts convinced me it's a scam.

This is rediculous. Libertarians were leading the charge against the 2008 bailouts before they even happened, and it was liberals, (e.g. barney frank, paul krugman) who were among the chief architects of the bailouts.

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by DannoHung on Friday January 08, 2016 @05:02PM (#10868657)
> This is rediculous. Libertarians were leading the charge against the 2008 bailouts before they even happened, and it was liberals, (e.g. barney frank, paul krugman) who were among the chief architects of the bailouts.

I forgot about that time that Henry Paulson and Ben Bernanke were actually Barney Frank and Paul Krugman's secret identities.

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by dnautics on Friday January 08, 2016 @05:10PM (#10868703)
Of course, Paulson and Bernanke are nominally "not liberals" because they were appointed by a "not liberal" executive, but orchestrating a bailout like this requires support in the legislature and support in the court of public opinion. Frank and Krugman were important figures in those spheres.
Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by aljones on Friday January 08, 2016 @07:30PM (#10869387)
Why are you not using the word conservative?
Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by dnautics on Monday January 11, 2016 @05:58PM (#10884273)
because OP refers to libertarians who are not necessarily conservative.
Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by api on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:57PM (#10868631)
I should have been more precise: right-libertarian and Reagan-style economic libertarian politics. I would still say though that libertarians of the more independent type have been played as political tools to push for one-sided policies that deregulate in ways that only benefit certain select groups of people.

I would also dispute that liberals (or at least only liberals) were architects of the bailouts, which mostly happened under the Bush administration.

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by dnautics on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:59PM (#10868645)
I mean I don't know how much more right-libertarian you can get than, say Ron Paul, who basically ran on the platform of no bailouts, having predicted the crash of 2008 (he's a perma-bear so that could be a bit of broken clock being right twice a day, nontheless sticking to his guns on the policy). Keeping history in mind: Ron Paul, who supported Reagan in the beginning publically broke with the Reagan administration because of Reagan's non-libertarian economic policy and ran against bush in 1988.
Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by dnautics on Friday January 08, 2016 @05:04PM (#10868679)
> I would also dispute that liberals (or at least only liberals) were architects of the bailouts, which mostly happened under the Bush administration.

Bush himself called the process of the bailout "breaking capitalism to save capitalism". This is a philosophy that aligns strongly with liberalism - that the government must intervene when the market fails. Should it be surprising that liberals helped architect the bailout?

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by ZenoArrow on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:45PM (#10868560)
> "which more or less force me to pay tribute to the rich"

> "I would not care if (hypothetically) there were people alive today who were biologically immortal cognitively enhanced cyberpunk demigods with control of wealth flows in excess of present-day US GDP"

The resources of the Earth are not infinite. If you lived in a world with super wealthy cyberpunk demigods, you're almost inevitably going to clash with them over resources, and as they have the upper hand you'd more than likely going to be paying tribute/rent to them.

Re:An Optimist's Reply to Ezra Klein by api on Saturday January 09, 2016 @01:17AM (#10870315)
That's a valid point so I gave you a compensatory upvote. It would depend a lot on the nature of the economy in such a world and how these hypothetical beings got and maintained their wealth.

At the risk of totally derailing into sci-fi speculation, I'll also say that I suspect any civilization that advanced would also be truly spacefaring. That would probably make a difference too.