News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I love Rust by k__ on Friday January 08, 2016 @06:02AM (#10864095)
Rust and Go are going into different directions.

Rust is trying something new and Go tries to only use the stuff that worked in the past.

It's no surprise that people favor Go instead of Rust.

Also the last time I saw a video about a low level language discussion, only Rust had a dev there nobody really knows. C++, D and Go had prominent people speaking for them.

The tooling really isn't the problem, as far as I can tell, Cargo is really one of the best package manager out there.

Re:Why I love Rust by tatterdemalion on Friday January 08, 2016 @07:57PM (#10869495)
> Also the last time I saw a video about a low level language discussion, only Rust had a dev there nobody really knows. C++, D and Go had prominent people speaking for them.

They were each represented by a prominent member of their language design team. Its tragic that more people don't know of Niko Matsakis, but his blog is one of the best resources on the design of the Rust language: http://smallcultfollowing.com/babysteps/

Re:Why I love Rust by nickpsecurity on Friday January 08, 2016 @10:32AM (#10865525)
"Also the last time I saw a video about a low level language discussion, only Rust had a dev there nobody really knows. C++, D and Go had prominent people speaking for them."

That has nothing to do with anything.

"Rust is trying something new and Go tries to only use the stuff that worked in the past. It's no surprise that people favor Go instead of Rust."

That's a good point. Anyone doing something critical wants low risk. Using a proven tool or one with proven concepts is lower risk. Go's methods were proven in Pascal, Oberon, etc. So, Go is less risk.

Not to knock Rust in any way with the above. Might be safer in long run due to design and improving toolchain. However, there is a risk perception and a real issue of new concepts taking time to spot then eliminate problems. So, I encourage Rust for systems use on less critical stuff right now but was shocked Dropbox uses it in storage functions.

Re:Why I love Rust by pcwalton on Friday January 08, 2016 @11:59AM (#10866299)
> Go's methods were proven in Pascal, Oberon, etc. So, Go is less risk.

Totally disagree. Rust's ideas are tweaks of decades-old research. These tweaks are what make it interesting and constitute research in their own right, but Go did that too with their tweaks to CSP and interfaces.

Re:Why I love Rust by nickpsecurity on Friday January 08, 2016 @12:31PM (#10866561)
You disagree that the basic functionality of Go, including type and memory safety, have been proven by prior language and production deployments? That's my basic premise. If Pascal/Oberon-like languages and GC's are proven, then one that's very similar to them will likely maintain those properties and deliver the same results. That's supported by the number of amateurs that ported and re-implemented Oberon OS & compilers successfully in 6 months to 2 years at ETH.

Whereas Rust uses a combination of proven primitives and exotic techniques to achieve its goals. The exotic stuff, integration strategy, and implementation are new territory that exposes a level of risk a tried-and-true method (eg knock-off Oberon) doesn't have. It's new and unfamiliar territory to programmers at large even if some methods were seen in academia (eg Cyclone). It must be shown to be effective in terms of daily usage, standard libraries, and tooling because it's such new and unfamiliar territory.

When it is, as I have confidence in the team(s), it will then have a different argument where it eliminates way more risks than it introduces. Already has it at application level if compiler is robust. Overall thing needs more deployment, though, so people can see if it lives up to it, how much, and in what scenarios. That's the risk perception I'm talking about. Right now, it's a big unknown to many outsiders compared to traditional languages and platforms.

Re:Why I love Rust by kod on Friday January 08, 2016 @12:06PM (#10866360)
Rust is actually pretty conservative regarding "new stuff".

Every single feature of Rust, with the exception of the borrow checker, has been around since the 80s.

Even the borrow checker is based on linear / affine types that had been researched in other languages at least over a decade ago.