News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by cushychicken on Thursday January 07, 2016 @12:47PM (#10859424)
>it's a big deal if a bunch of academics are spending time working on the wrong things

At the risk of sounding a little prickly with my comment - isn't it a little presumptuous to write off a certain amount of research as "wrong"? There are plenty of examples of research that didn't have a clear purpose leading to breakthroughs - safety glass, microwave ovens, and Teflon all spring to mind.

Also, focusing on efficiency doesn't really align with academia's purpose, which (to my mind) has more to do with fundamental research. This article about Xerox PARC springs to mind:

http://www.fastcodesign.com/3046437/5-steps-to-recreate-xero...

Re:Academics, we need to talk by mdwelsh on Thursday January 07, 2016 @01:14PM (#10859619)
That's a fair point. I'm trying to draw a distinction between "speculative" research (which might pan out long term) and "industry-focused" research (which tries to solve problems we have today). My concern is not with speculative research -- that's great -- but rather flawed industry-focused research: making incorrect assumptions, failing to deal with the general case, not considering real-world constraints.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by gradstudent on Thursday January 07, 2016 @08:21PM (#10862248)
> but rather flawed industry-focused research: making incorrect assumptions, failing to deal with the general case, not considering real-world constraints.

I find this point rather condescending. What you term "incorrect assumptions" are often necessary simplifications that reveal the core of the problem at hand. The point is to try and understand what makes problems hard and to develop new ways of solving them; not to deliver to companies like Google ready-made solutions that cater to their every operational need. Don't like that? Too bad. Fund your own research.

Re:Academics, we need to talk by mdwelsh on Thursday January 07, 2016 @11:36PM (#10862956)
No, I mean incorrect assumptions. It doesn't matter if we're talking research in industry or academia; doing research based on flawed (not simplifying) assumptions is bad science.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by gradstudent on Friday January 08, 2016 @09:44AM (#10865143)
If you want to make a concrete point about bad science then do it. At the moment however you are not making that point. Your argument is that "the assumptions" (whatever those are; you provide no specifics) made by researchers don't match up with industry expectations; a wholly different point for which I have little sympathy.

In my opinion the scientific authors doing the work are in the best position to judge what assumptions are and are not appropriate for their work. If the science is bad we expect the community to pick up on that via peer review or in a subsequent publication.

Re:Academics, we need to talk by mdwelsh on Friday January 08, 2016 @11:41AM (#10866140)
I was originally going to list examples of bad industry-focused science in the original post, but decided against it, since I didn't want to offend anyone. Your username is "gradstudent", suggesting you have read a few papers. My bet is that you've read papers where you scratch your head and say, "is that really how things work?" I read lots and lots of those papers - usually they don't end up getting published.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by cushychicken on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:01PM (#10866789)
>My bet is that you've read papers where you scratch your head and say, "is that really how things work?" I read lots and lots of those papers

That sort of contextualizes your post as a long winded statement of "My job is hard".

Re:Academics, we need to talk by s986s on Thursday January 07, 2016 @05:08PM (#10861196)
Honestly, if the academics didnt choose their research the private industry wouldnt have to hire r and d. This sounds more of a ploy to save costs by having academics build for the industry on government money than to hire people to further a companies interests.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by incepted on Thursday January 07, 2016 @04:19PM (#10860867)
> making incorrect assumptions

If it was easy to know when you make incorrect assumptions, nobody would.

Re:Academics, we need to talk by mdwelsh on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:50AM (#10863359)
Well, the whole point of my post is to give some tips on how not to.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by kevan on Thursday January 07, 2016 @12:57PM (#10859500)
I understood that as more of a lament that a lot of work is being duplicated because academics aren't aware of prior work in the industry. But then again, how are you supposed to know that someone has a solution unless they tell the world about it in a publication?

> It drives me insane to see papers that claim that some problem is "unsolved" when most of the industry players have already solved it, but they didn't happen to write an NSDI or SIGCOMM paper about it.

Re:Academics, we need to talk by sanderjd on Thursday January 07, 2016 @01:36PM (#10859772)
There are more ways to "publish" work than in academic publications. I'm not sure to what extent it is unrealistic to expect academics to be keeping up with what is going on at industry conferences or on github or by talking to people at user groups or wherever, but the reality will always be that academic publications are not the only, or the most up-to-date, source of information.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by kevan on Thursday January 07, 2016 @01:50PM (#10859852)
Agreed, blog posts and open source projects can be just as helpful as journal-published articles. I didn't intend publications to mean only academic journals.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by Scarblac on Friday January 08, 2016 @06:03AM (#10864098)
The problem is that many academics are not aware of anything outside the academic journals, and thus work on "unsolved" problems that already have well known solutions in industry.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by sanderjd on Thursday January 07, 2016 @04:07PM (#10860763)
I didn't think that's what you intended, but in the quote you included, the author is specifically lamenting the lack of knowledge of things published outside academic journals, not the lack of knowledge of things that aren't published anywhere.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by knughit on Thursday January 07, 2016 @12:56PM (#10859497)
Matt is talking about academic who publish papers showing that System X is Y% better than System Z, under completely nonsensical conditions. They aren't advancing the state of the art, they are mapping the terrain of the compost heap, but don't realize it.
Re:Academics, we need to talk by mcguire on Thursday January 07, 2016 @11:14PM (#10862886)
Is he? Maybe he should have said that.