I was originally going to list examples of bad industry-focused science in the original post, but decided against it, since I didn't want to offend anyone. Your username is "gradstudent", suggesting you have read a few papers. My bet is that you've read papers where you scratch your head and say, "is that really how things work?" I read lots and lots of those papers - usually they don't end up getting published.
Re:Academics, we need to talk
by cushychicken on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:01PM
(#10866789)
>My bet is that you've read papers where you scratch your head and say, "is that really how things work?" I read lots and lots of those papers
That sort of contextualizes your post as a long winded statement of "My job is hard".
In my opinion the scientific authors doing the work are in the best position to judge what assumptions are and are not appropriate for their work. If the science is bad we expect the community to pick up on that via peer review or in a subsequent publication.