News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by wstrange on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:06PM (#10846850)
What I really wish the cloud providers would do is reduce network egress costs. They seem insanely expensive when compared to dedicated servers.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by fpgaminer on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:16PM (#10846918)
Agreed. I've heard some people say that those prices are kept high to encourage keeping data locked within the platform; forcing people to use the provider's services versus shipping data off to other platforms. I'm not sure if I believe that or not, but it's an interesting theory.

Honestly, the high bandwidth costs have killed a number of ideas I would have liked to tinker with on AWS. I find the cost of EC2 to be quite good, and storage cost is tolerable, but $.10/GB of bandwidth-out is horrific.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by Vendan on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:32PM (#10847032)
Seriously, I pay $20 for a VPS with good stats and 3TB of outbound bandwidth per month. It's with Linode, who have been apparently hard hit, but I've suffered about 10 minutes of downtime over the course of the last 2 years, and all of that was in the past week, when the DDOS crap started. Since then it's been fine.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by noir_lord on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @07:15PM (#10847287)
Apart from the breach and global password resets today.

http://www.zdnet.com/article/cloud-firm-linode-resets-user-p...

I have been a big fan of linode in the past, I still have a fair amount with them but honestly at this point I'm seriously considering AWS even at the increased cost (which compared to my time isn't that large really and reputational cost which is).

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by meowface on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @10:17PM (#10848214)
This is the third time they've had a critical breach in the past 5 or so years, and that's excluding all the DDoS downtime they've had in that time span. I stopped using them after their second breach, and frankly am glad I did. I'm very happy with Digital Ocean.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by jonathanoliver on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @11:06PM (#10848444)
I just wish DO hardware has a bit faster (or not so over-subscribed?). All of our tests show Linode beat DO hands down for at similar price points.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by sauere on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:55AM (#10850209)
True. But DO seems to have more downtimes. I have had several scheduled forced reboots, some network downtime and just plain outages.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by meowface on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:12PM (#10854990)
I've only had one in the past year I've been using them.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by LeoPanthera on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:40AM (#10849179)
Wow. Disappointing that I found out about this here, 7 hours after it was posted, before hearing anything from Linode.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by threeseed on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:00AM (#10849810)
I was a Linode customer back when it first happened.

I found out on Slashdot/Reddit first and got the email from Linode about 3 days later. I have known ever since then that Linode is the type of provider you don't want to be involved with. A VPS provider has one responsibility above all else: be honest and transparent.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by pritambarhate on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:57AM (#10849219)
Yes, with Linode and other VPS providers we get good amount of bandwidth quota. Also if you have 2 instances running then they combine the monthly quota for you. But, how much network capacity one can use is actually limited by the network connectivity the machine offers.

For example, the $20 a month VPS on Linode offers only 250 Mbps connectivity (outgoing bandwidth). So as soon as you saturate that, you need one more VPS to handle the load. So this leaves a lot of bandwidth quota unused. Especially since in the real world traffic tends to come in spikes. AWS is similar, depending on the instance size the network connectivity differs. This makes the calculations for estimating costs for hosting even more difficult.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by Vendan on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:17AM (#10849270)
yeah, but 250 Mbps will chew up your bandwidth quota in a day or 2... so you already needed more quota anyways... unless your traffic is incredibly spiky.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by tacos on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:48PM (#10847132)
Common misconception. The prices are highly negotiable. Nobody with significant traffic is paying anything close to book rates.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by wstrange on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @08:13PM (#10847644)
Network egress costs on AWS appear to be a factor of 10x more than dedicated servers. Google GCE is pretty much the same.

That is a lot of negotiation that needs to be done. Will they get anywhere close to that kind of discount?

How big a customer do you need to be?

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by Scoundreller on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:40PM (#10848067)
Reading between the lines, I think AWS has a huge upstream bandwidth bottleneck that it can't get around easily, while spread out small dedi providers have everything but this problem.

(Speculation based on how AWS prices things: Build big, charge for everything, charge what it actually costs with a small markup, and put every high-margin provider out of business)

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by davidu on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @11:06PM (#10848446)
This isn't the case. (speaking from knowledge)
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by nopzor on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @11:54AM (#10851602)
Definitely not so. AWS is the most profitable part of AMZN. They are printing money on the markup on egress.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by iofj on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:05PM (#10847909)
Keep in mind that if you're sufficiently large, you can negotiate better rates on dedi as well. Because of the massive competition in that market, you don't have to be that large to do it either.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by kijin on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:36PM (#10848052)
Transparent pricing is one of the greatest selling points of the "cloud". Nobody in the startup scene wants to deal with traditional enterprisey "call us for a quote" pricing unless they really have no other choice.

So if what you're saying is right, that would be just another reason for most small companies to avoid Amazon. If you're wrong, other comments in this thread have also given a good reason for small companies to avoid Amazon.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by tacos on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @10:09PM (#10848185)
Huh? It's totally transparent AND you can get a better deal if you pick up the phone and negotiate. They'll ask you to sign a commitment and (unenforceable) exclusivity clause.

Some people even take that "confidential" offer letter for volume pricing and shop it around to other cloud providers. Shocker!

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by awsnegotiate on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @11:32PM (#10848563)
I have trouble believing that this is actually true. I say this as a customer who spends a half million a month with AWS (and that spending is rapidly increasing).

There are some growth incentives (eg, prepay $3MM for next year, get 6% off all services), and there are some tiered savings (e.g. 5% off on more than $500k of RIs in a single region), but I've never seen a plausible, verifiable incident of people successfully negotiating AWS rates downward.

Do you have any evidence of this at all?

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by tacos on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @11:47PM (#10848624)
"You agree that the existence and terms of this Addendum and the Private Pricing Program are not publicly known and constitute AWS Confidential Information under the Agreement."

Maybe they're milking your investors. Maybe you've built some absurd contraption that they know you won't be able to move elsewhere. Or maybe you need to hire a better negotiator.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by awsnegotiate on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @10:25AM (#10850947)
That text matches what we got from a growth commitment that included a pretty modest discount.

Given that we couldn't get it; and that nobody from our company's entire VC network could get it; and that nobody on my CTO email list could get it... I'm going to continue thinking that the anonymous HN commenter is talking out of his ass.

But if you can prove me wrong, I'd be thrilled to be wrong.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by tacos on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @10:53AM (#10851126)
"the anonymous HN commenter is talking out of his ass"

Anonymous commenter versus 11-hour old throwaway account... who wins?

Looking at a few words in your rebuttal above and combining it with the tone you're using, I can come up with quite a few reasons you might not have gotten the discount you sought.

I'd suggest you put down the "CTO email list" and let an actual business person handle this for you. Handshakes and existing relationships still matter in this world. Good luck!

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by awsnegotiate on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:43PM (#10852588)
If you're going to complain about tone; don't be a rude son of a bitch in the first place.

That said, no point in arguing further with a liar and/or troll. You're not getting 10x discounts on your AWS bill. You're not fooling me or anybody else.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by marincounty on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:40AM (#10850148)
I can't even get my head around paying $500,000/month--for anything. I'm really out of this new economy.

What would use this much computing power, besides bitcoin mining, or popular top 100 site? Maybe an online game? Just curious.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by awsnegotiate on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @10:26AM (#10850956)
The median AWS based SaaS company spends around 6% of their revenue on AWS. (this compares to a median of 7% for those who choose to manage their own servers).

As such, $500k/mo isn't a terribly elite club. Essentially every SaaS company that does more than $10MM/mo of revenue is spending as much or more than we are.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by chrisseaton on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @09:33AM (#10850649)
You don't think any traditional economy companies pay $500k a month for anything? How much do you think airlines spend on fuel a month for example?
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by tacos on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @10:07AM (#10850835)
Do people really think AWS got to be a 10 billion dollar business by hosting node.js to garage door opener gateways?

When situations like this come up I always suggest people read the history of Western Electric. Talk about scale!

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by soccerdave on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @08:12PM (#10847634)
What do you consider significant? If you are doing over 10TB then you'll be paying lower and even lower the higher you go. This doesn't help the smaller players doing under 10TB. Do you know of people under 10TB that have negotiated better rates?
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by tacos on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @08:22PM (#10847695)
I don't consider $900/month in bandwidth significant. And I'm sure Amazon account managers don't either -- but it can't hurt to ask, especially if you've got a growth plan that makes sense.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by geofft on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @08:31AM (#10850363)
At that point you're rapidly approaching the scale where cloud-style on-demand provisioning isn't really helping you (unless you prefer AWS's tooling to any "private cloud", which is legit), and you might as well put a bunch of dedicated servers in colo, right?

That is to say, the reason you can negotiate a discount once you get well past that point (or if you intend to grow well past that point) is because staying on AWS makes increasingly less sense for you.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by al2o3cr on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @09:48AM (#10850724)
Depends on the situation - a bunch of dedicated servers means a sizable shift from "operating expenses" like AWS fees to "capital expenses" for hardware. It also means shifting expenses from monthly as-you-go to mostly upfront.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by toomuchtodo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:08PM (#10852248)
> a bunch of dedicated servers means a sizable shift from "operating expenses" like AWS fees to "capital expenses" for hardware.

Not anymore. In the US, you can now write off $500K/year in equipment costs immediately.

> It also means shifting expenses from monthly as-you-go to mostly upfront.

Dedicated server provider or lease the equipment instead of buy.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by Ded7xSEoPKYNsDd on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @11:08AM (#10851229)
Finding a provider that leases dedicated servers to you for a monthly fee isn't exactly hard.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by soccerdave on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @08:21AM (#10850323)
Right now I use 3 Softlayer virtual servers to serve up 15TB of static files a month. It costs me a whopping $168 a month. The same 15TB on AWS would cost $1325 a month. I consider saving $1157 'significant'.

Softlayer no longer includes 5TB on every virtual server and their bandwidth is equally outrageous so I'm still evaluating a plan for new servers.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by amazon_not on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:19AM (#10849663)
10TB is about $50 worth of high quality bandwidth. I'm glad you don't mind paying an extra $10k a year for that.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by nikolay on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:29AM (#10849145)
True. We pay 10% more due to the support plan. ;)
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by PaulHoule on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:22PM (#10846963)
It hasn't bothered me.

I quit Softlayer because every time I sent a change order in something awful would happen. At one point the issue tracking system broke in a way that I could not put in new tickets and got to talk to four different people until I talked to a wizard who punched a few commands into the SQL monitor and told me he saw something "amusing".

I had a "near miss" at data loss because one of their techs botched adding another hard drive to the machine, plus I was dealing with an expensive and balky backup system so I immediately moved my data into S3 then all the servers into EC2.

Softlayer had a crack sales guy call me to try to get me back and I told him I had a day job and a night job and I don't have time to talk to minions to fix the problems they make for me. He brought up the egress cost issue and I told him flatly that "I make $1000 a month in ad revenue and I pay $30 in egress charges so I don't care."

My business situation has changed in many ways since then but I'd say that my egress charges tend to run between 5-10% of my total spend so it is not a concern for me. If there is any AWS service that I don't like the value of it is RDS and I am mostly off it since I have been using SSD-backed instances and first running local copies of MySQL and then ditched MySQL.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by unclebucknasty on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:35PM (#10848045)
Softlayer is the product of multiple provider rollups and it shows. Some of their techs are solid, but others not so much. Their processes can be pretty whacked too.

One rollup just prior to Softlayer was ThePlanet and their efforts to onramp us from their vanilla dedicated to their new managed service several years ago was a complete debacle. And our environment was super simple--only 5 boxes on a rack and a couple network devices.

But, the guy who was "leading" the effort was completely inexperienced. When we finally announced that we'd had enough, they brought in more management and senior tech guys to advise and save the deal (they were angling for an investment so wanted to book more customers before quarter's end; thus our little business mattered).

They talked us into staying and one of our conditions was that they replace the "lead". Oddly, they asked if they could leave him in place because he was "a young guy, just getting started, and the blow would set him back". Of course, I felt for the guy, but that struck me as a horrible thing to ask of a customer. Didn't want to hurt him but had to insist nonetheless.

In any case, we stayed with them for some time at close to legacy prices on fairly dated metal, primarily because we didn't have time to switch. Over that time, services became decidedly "less managed", especially after the rollup to Softlayer. Of course, by then they were also pushing their cloud. When we finally found time to switch, we moved to AWS and never looked back (except in relief).

We cut our costs by two-thirds. Better, it struck me that AWS's automated processes are an order of magnitude better than the "managed" services we were by then receiving from Softlayer.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by click170 on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:15PM (#10847953)
Can I ask when you moved off of soft layer? I ask because my employer is considering them as an option and this isn't the first time I've heard softlayer horror stories.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by johnnycarcin on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @10:47PM (#10848360)
Not the OP but we have had a hell of a time with SoftLayer and have been doing everything we can to move. If you have a large ops team (or a team that isn't busy) and you go with a well planned physical server build-out (make sure you get them in different pods) you _might_ be ok.

We have been working on a POC in AWS and it's such a breath of fresh air. Things work as advertised, the provisioning process is quick and everything can easily be done with an API call. No more waiting for support tickets. The freedom you get with your network routing in an AWS VPC is worth it to me.

At the risk of sounding too much like an AWS fanboy we are actually looking at scrapping it all and just bringing everything in-house running on our own physical boxes with some type of hypervisor on top.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by sergiosgc on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:12AM (#10850058)
> At the risk of sounding too much like an AWS fanboy we are actually looking at scrapping it all and just bringing everything in-house running on our own physical boxes with some type of hypervisor on top.

We have done just that, with Opennebula (qemu,kvm; networking built on top of openvswitch and storage from distributed iSCSI NAS appliances). It's a perfect middle ground. All the easy provisioning niceness, less than half the price of AWS.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by thrownaway2424 on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @08:54PM (#10847863)
You're getting a fundamentally different quality of network from AWS or GCE than you get from Linode or similarly-sized dedicated provider. It's a good idea to question whether you need the network services of the large cloud providers, but it's not a very good idea to compare them as if they were apples and apples.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by iofj on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:03PM (#10847899)
Aside from the fact that total egress for AWS is biggger and thus (slightly) more ddos resistant ... what exactly is the quality difference here ?

There's plenty of dedi providers that are big enough to prevent real outages though. And it doesn't protect you as a customer, it just protects you from other Amazon customers getting ddossed, but Amazon doesn't keep your website reachable if you're getting ddossed (no dedi providers do).

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by thrownaway2424 on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:14PM (#10847949)
AWS has at least 23 points of presence and Google has at least 70.

I think you are seriously underestimating the size of Amazon's or Google's networks.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by iofj on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:23PM (#10847994)
That doesn't protect you as much as you think. Ddos resiliency really depends on the amount of unused (!) available capacity, in absolute value.

And Amazon, I guarantee you, doesn't have that much unused network capacity. That would be very, very expensive at their scale.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by biot on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @11:36PM (#10848579)
Amazon AWS is 10 times bigger than the next 14 competitors combined. [0] Amazon's unused network capacity is likely far larger than any other single provider's total available capacity, possibly with the exception of Azure.

If it's expensive for Amazon to have multiple Tbps of unused capacity, imagine how expensive it is for any other provider. To match the absolute spare bandwidth of Amazon having only 1/10 extra network capacity, another cloud provider might need to have keep its network utilization at only 5%. Maintaining a network capable of serving over 20x your current utilization "just in case of DDoS" is bloody expensive.

[0] http://www.businessinsider.com/nobody-gets-fired-for-buying-...

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by vgt on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:04PM (#10853299)
Google's SDN is seriously massive. Petabit of bisectional bandwidth:

http://googlecloudplatform.blogspot.com/2015/06/A-Look-Insid...

One major difference between Google and AWS is that Google will carry your packets between data centers on its backbone by default. Google will also carry packets as close to the customer as possible, whereas AWS will dump it off as quickly as possible.

So, even between Google Cloud and AWS it's not an apples to apples comparison.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by biot on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:41PM (#10854452)
Thanks for that. I knew Google has scary, massive bandwidth but didn't realize it was shared between their internal operations and their cloud platform.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by vgt on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:03PM (#10876290)
beauty of SDN :)
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by thrownaway2424 on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @10:19PM (#10848224)
Again, I think you are _dramatically_ underestimating the size of these networks.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by cherioo on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:49PM (#10848105)
A lot of the time ddos also depends on number of locations, because typically only one customer is attacked, and typically that one customer is only in a few location.

Also, I'm not sure I buy the argument Amazon has small unused capacity in absolute value, relative maybe. They could also have 5% across 23 locations so if your application is distributed it can have even better resiliency.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by mwcampbell on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:34PM (#10847048)
For me, the worthwhile comparison isn't between cloud and dedicated, but between AWS/Google/Azure on the one hand and DigitalOcean/Linode/Vultr on the other. The former charge for all outgoing transfer by the GB, while the latter include generous amounts of transfer per month with each VM plan.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by twistedpair on Thursday January 07, 2016 @03:56PM (#10860683)
Jeff's got to make money somewhere. Remember, ingress is free and unlimited. This has made business models like DropCam viable where essentially the ISP and AWS pay for all the ingress, and DropCam only has to pay for the processing and storage.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by mattbillenstein on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:04AM (#10848901)
App on AWS, data on S3, Varnish caches on Linode, Digital Ocean, etc. Route53 for managing geo-DNS.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by fideloper on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @08:26AM (#10850348)
Not sure I get the logic of Varnish being on different providers. Are your static assets also hosted on Linode/DO, in addition to Varnish?
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by toomuchtodo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:09PM (#10852264)
Varnish caches dynamic app data. Your static assets should be in a CDN, served outside of your infrastructure.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by fideloper on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:28PM (#10853914)
So to put what I'm cofused about plainly (my fault on the confusion I'm sure :D ):

It sounds like the reason for having that outside of your primary infrastructure (or more accurately, inside a cheaper bandwidth host) are lower bandwidth costs with the trade-off of some slower requests getting sent to your origin server when the cached resource expires/is invalidated.

Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by toomuchtodo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:43PM (#10854037)
Exactly! You're architecting your infrastructure to take advantage of the most efficient cost option at each layer.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by mattbillenstein on Thursday January 07, 2016 @05:24AM (#10857132)
So mainly thinking of Varnish as the CDN -- paying a 3rd party CDN is pricey.
Re:EC2 Price Reduction (C4, M4, and R3 Instances) by simonebrunozzi on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:37PM (#10852536)
Why should they? That's how they lock you in.