News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Take the Arc Challenge by pg on Saturday February 02, 2008 @04:16PM (#108456)
Do you consider News.YC a mere prototype? It's been around for a year, never gets runtime errors, and serves about 80k pages a day without breaking a sweat. And the source is full of code like this.

I think you're confusing types of software with organizations that sponsor them.

Arc certainly wasn't designed for use in the sort of environment where programs are 10% functionality and 90% the embodiment of the random bureaucratic processes of the organization paying for them. More for the opposite end of the spectrum, in fact. That's where you need power.

That said, if you care to make your challenge a precise one, it's likely I (or someone else) would try implementing it in Arc, if only out of curiosity.

Re:Take the Arc Challenge by Annoynymous on Saturday February 02, 2008 @04:55PM (#108469)
Bureaucracy isn't the only reason to care about, or have to modify, HTML. Things like accessibility and browser compatiblity matter too, and that ground is constantly shifting. Beyond that, there aren't a whole lot of people outside the world of hackers and scientists who don't care about aesthetics. That means that the overwhelming majority of us will end up working for people who care how stuff looks, even at the prototype stage. That's not bureaucracy, it's human nature.

Every time I've let somebody else's tools write HTML for me, it's caused me grief. Either because the tool author had an agenda that was at odds with my needs (Microsoft), because of bugs in the tool (everyone), or because the problem set shifted since the tool was written as browsers and techniques changed (everyone). Likewise, I'm wary of entertwining HTML output with the rest of the program the way Arc does because it makes it too much work to change things down the line.

It would be interesting to write a templating system that separates HTML output without making Arc programs take much longer to write. I suspect that it could be done, but it's not entirely clear to me what shape it would take. If done right it would give users the option to leverage Arc's existing HTML output functions where desired. I'll have to play with it.

Re:Take the Arc Challenge by richcollins on Saturday February 02, 2008 @09:33PM (#108540)
How about releasing the source to news.yc so we can see how terse it is for a non-trivial application :)
Re:Take the Arc Challenge by pg on Saturday February 02, 2008 @09:41PM (#108541)
I will eventually, but first I have to abstract out all the news.yc-specific stuff.
Re:Take the Arc Challenge by axod on Sunday February 03, 2008 @05:02PM (#108786)
Until it supports Unicode instead of translating my unicode into random entities/replacements, it's still a prototype ;)

A great, usable prototype :)

Re:Take the Arc Challenge by dfranke on Saturday February 02, 2008 @05:37PM (#108476)
How about this: make news.yc look right in Dillo (http://www.dillo.org).
Re:Take the Arc Challenge by s3graham on Saturday February 02, 2008 @06:21PM (#108492)
It looks reasonable in "links" (could use an alt-tag or two)