Annoynymous
Every time I've let somebody else's tools write HTML for me, it's caused me grief. Either because the tool author had an agenda that was at odds with my needs (Microsoft), because of bugs in the tool (everyone), or because the problem set shifted since the tool was written as browsers and techniques changed (everyone). Likewise, I'm wary of entertwining HTML output with the rest of the program the way Arc does because it makes it too much work to change things down the line.
It would be interesting to write a templating system that separates HTML output without making Arc programs take much longer to write. I suspect that it could be done, but it's not entirely clear to me what shape it would take. If done right it would give users the option to leverage Arc's existing HTML output functions where desired. I'll have to play with it.
No. Web app prototypes do that sort of thing all the time. For production web apps, the problem ends up including such confounding factors as meeting accessibility policy, making the HTML surrounding the form elements match what a web designer came up, etc. The more web development work I do, the more wary I am of any system that writes HTML for me. Inevitably the system ends up putting too many constraints on what HTML can be output.
Witness the ASP.NET framework, which writes lots of HTML for you. Unlike Arc it was written with the best practices of the time in mind, but it's aged badly as the web has grown and changed. Doing accessible, cross-browser, standards-based work in ASP.NET today involves a certain amount of fighting the framework which offsets the initial productivity gains.
I understand that Arc is intended for exploratory work and rapid prototyping. But that's exactly why the Arc challenge is meaningless. We're being asked to compare Arc to languages that provide -- dare I say it -- a great deal more flexibility and expressive power when it comes to outputting HTML.
So here's my challenge: Take a sample Arc application and modify it to replace tables with appropriate block elements that have designer-specified IDs and classes. Use <label> elements for each input if you aren't already. Replace a few regular submit buttons with image buttons or vice versa. Reorder some elements, and throw a few more arbitrary containers in here and there. Compare that process against a conventional language and let's see where we get.
In my line of work, that kind of scut work is absolutely part of prototyping. Before I can build the real thing my prototype has to be approved by people who have a hard time looking past even minor visual inconsistencies with what they're used to. For that reason I'm very wary of any design that makes fine-grained control of HTML any harder than it has to be, and I've come to value clean view/everything else separation even in early prototypes.
I suspect that Arc is much more appealing to people who don't live with such constraints.