Personally, I think that sounds right and proper, and it's reality that's the "broken" thing.
Living in reality means accepting that there are things that are "wrong" but where there's no sensible enforcement mechanism: "externalities", when it's the commons we're screwing over, or just "social ills" (e.g. hate speech) when it's a specific target.
Living in a consensual massively-multiplayer VR space, on the other hand, the rules of the space can be changed to suit its citizens: morality can be fully enforced, such that of course everything that's possible is good—because everything that's not good is impossible.
And I do mean consensual spaces, here—the plural is important; the most important thing such spaces give us is the ability to opt in or out of them, such that you can find one that fits your particular value system. You might personally enjoy a space with relatively few rules—a VR space equivalent to a "PvP server." Or you might enjoy a space with incredibly constricted rules, allowing almost no expression within their bounds, as in the game Journey. Or—and this is the thing we can't get from regular old reality given any amount of utopian politics—you can visit both, at different times of day, or even "multi-boxing" between the two in a weird VR sense we haven't invented yet.
Really, I'm just rehashing the content of these two essays:
• http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/06/07/archipelago-and-atomic-...
• http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/05/06/the-future-is-filters/
Are there any massively-multiplayer online spaces which are completely without griefers, trolls, or immorality of any sort? Which ones? (And try not to arrive at a non-empty set by redefining all complaints conveniently as "whining.")
But you're right that the concept of making literally any kind of social more into a "law of physics" of a VR space is basically impossible with current technology. We'd need somewhat-better AI (though not order-of-magnitude better) to recognize+classify e.g. speech and body-language that "break the rules" of a place, and refuse to transmit those to others.
And for one particular exception, I don't think any VR world could (or should) allow for enforcement regarding social norms of internal states—i.e. "thoughtcrime." Even if we figured out a way—even if it was inherent to the VR equipment to read your mind to do its job—thoughts are "yours", rather than being something one of your "faces" (i.e. the part of you people know as you in that space, which could itself have multiple avatar-characters) has on its own. Which further means that you can't really establish social norms about what you do outside of that VR space, using one of your other "faces." The "meta-norm" necessary there would be that a "face" is the root of identity, and so one "face" cannot be blamed for the actions of another, even if they have the same person behind them. (This presumes that there's still person-based authentication between the user and any VR space they interact with, and that there's one exactly one persistent "face" per {user, space} pair, that cannot be discarded and recreated.)
I think Tumblr has that one covered anyhow.
How is it anything new?
> When music had to be distributed as manufactured objects, the technology brought about one set of moral standards with regards to the selling/owning/distributing of music.
Are you referring to copyright? I believe these changes happened earlier, when printed scores started to sell big numbers.
There were always contexts where people could think, "Here's what people think is proper, but what can we actually do?" However, virtual spaces of the early 21st century are particular in the degree to which social/nonverbal cues are almost nonexistent or completely gone, and where consequences are so very skewed towards an amoral stance of, "What can we get away with?"
New VR technologies may well be a reversal of these conditions.
So, it's nothing completely new at the most simplistic level. But if you look more closely, it's the unintended consequences arising out of the details that are the most interesting and significant.
Are you referring to copyright? I believe these changes happened earlier, when printed scores started to sell big numbers.
Printed scores are manufactured objects. If you go back even farther, to when you had to have your own instrument and enough talent to learn music quickly by ear, you'll find a set of moral standards around the "ownership" of music similar to the one developing from today's environment of easy digital copying.
Can you provide an illustration of what exactly do you mean here?
I enjoy computer games. I played FTL until I had all the ships and all of the achievements, so perhaps I qualify as a gamer. I volunteer at a videogame museum. I have many friends who are avid gamers. That said, I seem to keep on meeting young people have a moral system along the lines of, "If the laws of physics and the laws of the government where I reside allow it, I can do it, and it's moral."
The world isn't going to end, and it won't result in an instant Mad Max post-apocalyptic world, but technological changes do have an effect on morality. Pre 1400, insisting that people be on time to the minute, or even to 15-20 minutes would have been considered quite crazy. Birth control had a tremendous effect on what society considers moral. When music had to be distributed as manufactured objects, the technology brought about one set of moral standards with regards to the selling/owning/distributing of music. Now that all media exist as bits, we are now seeing a different set of moral standards come into being. (One of which is, "Pics or it didn't happen.")
So VR is clearly going to influence what society considers "moral" -- probably in ways we can't easily forsee. Many of alive today -- even typical members of the HN community -- are going to find some of these changes quite disturbing.