News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fun with Swift by lyinsteve on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:40AM (#10836544)
The author completely missed the point of named parameters. How am I supposed to know that the string argument of "make_window" is the title?
Re:Fun with Swift by masklinn on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:32PM (#10836937)
> The author completely missed the point of named parameters.

The author didn't miss the point of named parameters. At no point does the author even cover the point of named parameters. The author complains that:

1. they're inconsistent, all parameters but the first are named by default and named parameters are still positional (you can't reorder "named" parameters in the callsite)

2. making parameters purely positional is non-obvious and ugly

And he missed the part which takes the cake: Swift doesn't actually have named parameter, parameters 1+ are labelled (#1), and labels and names are independent, you can define this:

    func foo(a b: Int, c d: Int) { … }
which is called with a:c:, but the bindings are on b and d. You can also define this:

    func foo(a b: Int, _ d: Int) { … }
which is called as `foo(a:5, 7)` which while somewhat consistent is really garbage.
Re:Fun with Swift by mikeash on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:45PM (#10837522)
In Swift terminology, a and c are "external names" while b and d are "local names." I don't see much of a difference between a "name" and a "label" here in any case.

I don't understand why the ability to set different external and local names is so bad. External names are part of the API, local names are part of the implementation. It often makes sense to make them the same, but there are case where you want them to be different, and what's wrong with that? It's ultimately no different from loading a parameter into a local variable of a different name and then operating on that local variable. Yes, you can use this facility to make ugly APIs, but you don't have to.

Re:Fun with Swift by masklinn on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:00PM (#10838083)
> I don't understand why the ability to set different external and local names is so bad. External names are part of the API, local names are part of the implementation. It often makes sense to make them the same, but there are case where you want them to be different, and what's wrong with that? It's ultimately no different from loading a parameter into a local variable of a different name and then operating on that local variable.

Then why have it in the first place? That seems like a very odd feature to put front and center into the language (considering a very similar effect can be achieved with a few assignments as the function's prelude) and require using when just wanting positional-only parameters, or consistently labelled parameters.

Re:Fun with Swift by mikeash on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:05PM (#10838124)
Can you explain what "and require using when just wanting positional-only parameters, or consistently labelled parameters" means? I don't understand that.

As for why you have it in the first place, it's just because one is API and one is implementation, and there are sometimes good reasons to have them be different.

Re:Fun with Swift by masklinn on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:14PM (#10838191)
> Can you explain what "and require using when just wanting positional-only parameters, or consistently labelled parameters" means? I don't understand that.

As far as I can see (and the article notes), by default the first parameter of a Swift function is unlabelled, and the others are labelled. That is at callsite the first parameter can not be labelled and the others must be. Having either all-positional or all-labelled (but still positional) requires specifying external names.

> As for why you have it in the first place, it's just because one is API and one is implementation

But again and as you yourself noted that could trivially be done with local bindings inside the function in cases where it's desirable.

Re:Fun with Swift by mikeash on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:21PM (#10838255)
Yes, that's true, but note that you only need to specify the external names on the parameters that depart from the default. A function with external names on every parameter looks like:

    func whatever(a a: Int, b: Int, c: Int)
A function with no external names on any parameter looks like:

    func whatever(a: Int, _ b: Int, _ c: Int)
I'm not sure if you understood that or thought they all had to be specified if any were, but in any case that's how it looks.

As for "that could trivially be done," that applies to a lot of language features in a lot of languages. Virtually all language features are redundant in that fashion, yet they can still be useful by adding brevity and clarity.

Re:Fun with Swift by wtetzner on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:35PM (#10840943)
The question is why is the first argument special? Also, it's weird that you have to explicitly mark the label as "_" to get positional parameters.

I find Scala's handling of named arguments much saner.

Re:Fun with Swift by mikeash on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @09:50AM (#10843450)
I think it's because the first argument tends to be named by the function itself. For example:

    button.setTitle("Ham and Cheese", color: red)
Note that named parameters are still positional, they just have names too. Using _ doesn't get you positional parameters, you already had that, it just removes the name. (Exception: named parameters with default values can be reordered with other adjacent named parameters with default values. Why? I don't know.)

It is mildly annoying that you have to add an extra symbol to remove the name for parameters after the first one, but that's the language pushing its preferred style.

How does Scala handle all this?

Re:Fun with Swift by masklinn on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @01:30PM (#10844999)
> Exception: named parameters with default values can be reordered with other adjacent named parameters with default values. Why? I don't know.

That's actually nice to know.

> How does Scala handle all this?

No idea about Scala. In Python 3, there are 4 "classes" of parameters:

* "positional-and-named", the basic parameter can be passed either by name or by position, though passing parameter 1 by name parameter 2 by position won't work: when actually calling the function, the interpreter first fills positional parameters left-to-right then applies named parameters, so it'll raise an error noting that one parameter got two values[0]. Can be either required or with a default value. Parameters passed by names can be passed in any order

    def foo(a, b, c=5): pass
    foo(1, c=42, b=3)
* positional varargs ("args"), can only be passed positionally, can follow any number of positional parameters, will be collected as an array

    def foo(*args): pass
    foo(1, 2, 3, 4)
* named-only ("keyword parameters"), follows either positional varargs or a special placeholder. These were not possible in Python 2 in pure Python, they're similar to 1 but can only be passed by name, they can be either required or with a default value. Like 1 but more so, named-only parameters can be passed in any relative order

    def foo(*, a, b, c=5): pass
    foo(b=6, a=2)
* keyword varargs ("kwargs"), may follow named-only parameters and will collect any parameter passed by name which didn't match any formal parameter, will be collected as a key:value map

    def foo(**kwargs): pass
    foo(bar=5, baz=42, qux=1)
The C API also allows creating true positional parameters (completely unnamed), as far as I know that's not possible in pure Python.

[0] the reverse won't work either, at callsite Python doesn't allow named parameters to be provided before positional ones

Re:Fun with Swift by Alphasite_ on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @10:16AM (#10843602)
For Swift, a lot of the designs were due to the ability to automatically transform Objective-C apis into swift APIs. The big issue from what i can tell is in extracting the first parameters name from the method name automatically.
Re:Fun with Swift by mikeash on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @11:25AM (#10844047)
That doesn't really explain the defaults, though. Translation could override the defaults if that fit better. This already happens when translating C functions, as none of the parameters get external names.
Re:Fun with Swift by rimantas on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:46PM (#10838439)

  > Then why have it in the first place? That seems like a very
  > odd feature to put front and center into the language
Cocoa is the answer.