News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by Tomte on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:07PM (#10819971)
She's talking about some guy and his "campaign to legalize rape".

I thought she was exaggerating or maybe misunderstanding something. Sure, this guy is probably an asshole, but legalizing rape, come on!

I followed the link and... it is kind of almost entertaining. He means it. Literally. You can't stop reading that trainwreck of an argument, because it gets worse and worse.

And then you've lost all hope in mankind. I thought I knew what misogyny was about, but that is absolutely breathtaking.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by nnethercote on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:59PM (#10820203)
A big problem is that many people won't believe a woman's complaints if it falls anything short of something as blatant as this. People like that guy are the easy cases.

I read an article the other day about devastating, long-term harassment that one person suffered. She had a dream where she was physically attacked by a harasser -- stabbed with a knife. In this dream her primary feeling was one of overwhelming relief. Why? Because the harasser had done something so obviously wrong that her complaints could now not possibly be ignored. She woke up disappointed.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by unimpressive on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:03PM (#10820222)
Could you post a link?
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by lillian-lemmer on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:15PM (#10820260)
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by 5F36B5F62640 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @10:37PM (#10821028)
> I followed the link and... it is kind of almost entertaining. He means it. Literally.

He means it in the same way Jonathan Swift meant that cannibalism should be legalized and the Irish should be allowed to sell their children as food in "A Modest Proposal" [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by rrss1122 on Friday January 01, 2016 @02:32AM (#10821351)
It's what one of the comments they quoted at the end said. Terrible, terrible attempt at satire, and he should be mocked for it. But come on, no one is actually for legalizing rape.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by anu_gupta on Friday January 01, 2016 @08:51AM (#10821870)
You can apologise for that inadequate scumbag all you want, but we both know that he does mean it.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by fche on Thursday December 31, 2015 @07:05PM (#10820455)
Randi talked about several different guys. Her main beef seems to be with the unnamed FreeBSD committer.

She refers to other people ("neo-nazi friends") with whom that person communicates on twitter / etc., one of whom is rooshv, who wrote that absurd "campaign to legalize rape" article.

[deleted]
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by lillian-lemmer on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:36PM (#10820101)
> Do something positive like encourage that girl to make her contribution to FreeBSD regardless of what words are slung around.

This is the attitude I'm talking about in my other comments.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by fche on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:44PM (#10820373)
"He means it. Literally."

No, rooshv was dripping with sarcasm.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by InclinedPlane on Friday January 01, 2016 @06:08AM (#10821614)
Some things you can be sarcastic about, legalizing rape is not one of them, period.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by fche on Friday January 01, 2016 @08:40AM (#10821853)
I'm not saying it's tasteful or appropriate. But it's not "literal".
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by rhizome on Friday January 01, 2016 @08:42PM (#10824534)
Poe's Law. Do you know what's in rooshv's head?
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by fche on Friday January 01, 2016 @10:09PM (#10824779)
The original commenter claimed "He means it. Literally." I rather think my mind-reading is more plausible than his/hers.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by eugeneionesco on Saturday January 02, 2016 @05:57PM (#10828418)
How about eating babies? What do you think about that?
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by draw_down on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:13PM (#10819992)
He writes such extreme things to get a reaction (and a following of complete morons). Attention is oxygen in that business. Not that that makes it any better of course. Notice how you said it's "almost entertaining", well, that's what he's aiming for.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by geofft on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:28PM (#10820064)
OK, so if that's true, then by treating him as a legitimate member of the community and not making any sort of statement against his views, the FreeBSD project is giving him attention, and they should stop doing that. Which is exactly what Randi asked for.

It's one thing if you keep your horrible-person persona separate from your technical one (as e.g. the Strange Loop thing earlier this year), although I still think it's legitimate to say that's too much. But when someone is deliberately tying their work in a project with their views that drive out other people from that same project, it's not giving them attention to kick them out. It's giving them attention to keep them in.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by lillian-lemmer on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:32PM (#10820084)
He should have been expelled the second he was harshly transphobic to me, e.g., calling me a "tranny." I'm the trans woman Randi talks about in that article. There were many times he should have been kicked out, but in the end nobody cared enough about women's issues, or there was no real recourse for such.

But since that didn't happen, Randi is trying to bring attention to the fact that the above isn't how things work.

EDIT TO CLARIFY: the man I'm referring to is the FreeBSD contributor Randi Harper speaks of in the article, not the voosh guy.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by engi_nerd on Thursday December 31, 2015 @09:30PM (#10820878)
I have no feelings of transphobia whatsoever and it's only within the past year or so that I learned that "tranny" is offensive. This is not me saying that his comment wasn't transphobic (because how would I know? but you certainly would)

I'm merely lamenting my past ignorance.

[dead]
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by engi_nerd on Friday January 01, 2016 @12:30PM (#10822456)
Well, I never put much stock in mob thinking, so that's okay.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by meesterdude on Saturday January 02, 2016 @12:25AM (#10825194)
I don't understand how that could ever come up. How you being trans has any bearing whatsoever at all in your involvement with the community.

You don't have to like it(trans), or understand it; but you do have to accept it, and be accepting. And there's just no excuse or room for that kind of thing in a project. Maybe on 4chan and maybe on reddit, but not in an OSS project. Who the fuck acts like that? I just don't get it.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by dogma1138 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:08PM (#10820239)
I would bet you that I've been called "jew" more times than you been called a "tranny" over the internet usually followed by about 20min of heil hitler spam and other funny jokes from various IRC bots, I just shrugged it off....
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by awesomerobot on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:45PM (#10820375)
It seems weird to say "this shitty thing happens to me too" and instead of commiserating and saying "this shitty thing shouldn't happen to anyone" you essentially say "stop complaining."
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by dogma1138 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:52PM (#10820406)
"this shitty thing shouldn't happen to anyone" you are not going to abolish "harassment" (I intentionally used quotation marks I don't some one who uses slur or thinks you shouldn't exist as harassment just another idiot with an opinion...) from human cloture it's included in the price you pay for living in a free society where free speech is an actuality and not a slogan. You won't cure the world of idiots, troll, or even simply cruel people and the price you'll pay in trying is way too high for my taste.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by geofft on Thursday December 31, 2015 @07:09PM (#10820474)
I'm not entirely sure that it's to the advantage of an operating system development project to have free speech as an ideal.

At the very least, there's the empirical argument that the major operating systems are overwhelmingly developed by private corporations, and you can be sure that if a developer said "hey, this new hire is getting his white supremacist followers on Twitter to attack me," the new hire wouldn't be working on that project very much more. And we generally don't find the price of this less-than-free speech too much to pay.

Can you explain why it helps develop a better net installer or Linux emulation layer to be able to use slurs against fellow developers?

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by dogma1138 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @07:30PM (#10820551)
What this has to do with software development? A COC has nothing to do with software development it's not enforcing anything related to actually committing code and collaborating.

A COC forces you to be compliant to it every where on social media, on regular media, in person, on private forums... everywhere - this is thought police.

A COC forces you to "hide" your personal beliefs, ideas, who you vote for who you donate money to etc. on the off chance they might be considered offensive to some one.

We already had a CEO who had to resign due to a political donation, COC's will have the same effect you post something offensive on facebook? you're out, you go to a political rally that some one finds offensive? well though luck.

If COC's only covered official project channels no one would care about them, and the people that want them would not push with such vigor because they could not be used for thought policing.

On a side note I find it ironic that people who had to hide who they are for most of history and maybe for most of their lives want to force the same thing on other people just because of their personal beliefs.

And on another side note the wworse of the humanity tends to fester in dark rooms when things are out in the open you know here everyone stands and you can ridicule them for that if you want.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by lillian-lemmer on Friday January 01, 2016 @06:48PM (#10824164)
> On a side note I find it ironic that people who had to hide who they are for most of history and maybe for most of their lives want to force the same thing on other people just because of their personal beliefs.

I love how you're comparing the choice of being a person who dehumanizes and threatens vulnerable people as like... a demographic to compare to being a woman, or being trans, etc.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by rewqfdsa on Friday January 01, 2016 @10:14AM (#10822049)
This thread is the most depressing thing I've read on Hacker News in months. I completely agree with you, dogma1138. You and I appear to be only ones who don't view the world through justice-colored glasses and who understand that attempting to enforce strict ideological conformity is self-defeating.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by tptacek on Friday January 01, 2016 @11:27AM (#10822245)
You should read the news more. This is not the most depressing thing to happen in months by a long stretch. Maybe you'd have an easier time getting over simple disagreements with other people if you, you know, got some perspective.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by dogma1138 on Friday January 01, 2016 @12:08PM (#10822386)
Most people tend to stay away from such threads as they will quickly get downvoted and flagged and will either be buried like most comments on this post that or will be deleted like some of the early comments here that got stomped over. People tend to downvote comments that they do not agree with (regardless of HN rules) which leads to either self censorship (not commenting in the first place or deletion of comments that get a few down-votes) or actual censorship as comments which get downvoted to -10 get buried by the HN system.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by DanBC on Friday January 01, 2016 @12:10PM (#10822391)
> (regardless of HN rules)

Please can you show me the HN rule that tells people how to downvote? Specifically, the rule that tells people not to downvote for disagreement?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171

> I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=392347

> Downvoting has always been used to express disagreement.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=658691

> IIRC we first had this conversation about a month after launch. Downvotes have always been used to express disagreement. Or more precisely, a negative score has: users seem not to downvote something they disagree with if it already has a sufficiently negative score.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by awesomerobot on Thursday December 31, 2015 @07:34PM (#10820565)
If someone mourns for a death do you just say "well everyone dies, suck it up?" — no, because that's ridiculous. So when someone is being harassed why say "it happens to everyone so get over it"? Why go out of your way to invalidate how someone feels about something?

where free speech is an actuality and not a slogan.

Harassment isn't protected speech, and that's beyond the point because this isn't an issue of free speech at all.

the price you'll pay in trying is way too high for my taste

Someone in an organized community was being harassed, and they're upset that leadership of that community didn't seem to think it was a problem. The price being paid is that someone harassing a community member isn't part of the community anymore. That's a high price?

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by fche on Friday January 01, 2016 @05:40PM (#10823841)
"Someone in an organized community was being harassed"

Note that one of the twists & turns in this sorry saga was that the same freebsd developer submitted a documented harassment complaint against Randi. The freebsd CoC was in effect by this time, but it doesn't seem like it was helpful.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by dogma1138 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @07:51PM (#10820617)
>Protected speech

That's an american definition, all forms of speech should be protected even hate speech, when hate is being pushed to the sidelines it only festers and becomes worse, let it be in the open and let it be ridiculed.

>Someone in an organized community was being harassed

Some one claimed to be harassed (there's a very thick and really not one sided story behind all this), considering the authors day to day activities allot of the things she does are also harassment or is calling out some one all the time for their beliefs is only harassment if those beliefs are currently socially progressive?

>The price being paid is that someone harassing a community member isn't part of the community anymore. That's a high price?

Well the price in this case was that she wasn't in the community any more, mostly because of her doing I would guess but I really don't want to get into that.

Communities tend to cast out the ones that cause the most disturbance and disturbance is often not a person who aggravates some one but a person who gets aggravated allot, usually by many people and about many issues.

Most communities are self managing (and do it quite well) if you find your self out of place all the time and being constantly cast out and "harassed" even if you are in the right it might be worth the time to take a deep look at one self and understand how you can adapt better and what different actions you might be able to take to avoid that because clearly; dichotomy and my way or the high way doesn't work and even in cases when it does it won't work for long and at the end will might be your own undoing because there always will be a more progressive agenda that will just as easily hijack the current one as yours did before it.

I really miss the days when progressiveness was about open dialog, accepting others and most importantly being open to your own ideas being challenged as much as you challenge the ideas of others, today progressiveness especially in online communities boils down to some unholy checklist which gets updated every so often with the latest social fab being mandatory for maintaining membership privileges.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by lillian-lemmer on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:17PM (#10820267)
Every time you step out the door do you wonder if you'll be killed for who you are? Do you worry that you can't go to the police for who you are? Do you ever worry about fighting an entire legal and medical system to be who you are?

Etc.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by dogma1138 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:29PM (#10820323)
>When (Every time) you step out the door do you wonder if you'll be killed for who you are

Yes.

>Did (do) you worry that you can't go to the police for who you are

Yes.

Most recently in Malmo.

Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by unimpressive on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:30PM (#10820075)
Not that it's worth a whole lot, but Mr. 'legalize rape' Roosh and the person being discussed in the OP are separate persons. The latter is explicit friends with the former.
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by lillian-lemmer on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:19PM (#10820022)
Don't do this. It's implying that people should just "not be hurt by it and move on." ... That the problem is with the people reacting. Surely, I agree that giving attention to stuff often fuels the flames, but the answer isn't to place the burden on the victims. The answer is to actually DEAL with the issue and have shit HAPPEN to make people (women, trans, queer, minorities) safer!
Re:The Developer Formerly Known as FreeBSDGirl by fleitz on Friday January 01, 2016 @01:02AM (#10821220)
You can tell from identity politics in the brackets who is people and who isn't people. Why not just say what you mean?