Re:The Secrets of a High-Quality Vinyl Record (2012)
by mikestew on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:40PM
(#10819247)
It just goes to show that there will always be a subset of people in all fields, regardless of the level of technology or sophistication, that think they know better than science and math.
I'm convinced it can happen with anything, especially if it's something that judging the results is largely subjective ("sounds better to me"). Take another example that's completely unrelated: mandolins. Do they "open up" (IOW, sound better) by being played over a period of time? Many raging debates on the relevant forums, and there are even devices sold in front of which you place your instrument, and the device produces sound so that the instrument will open up without you even playing it! Old school wisdom was that you set your instrument in front of your stereo speakers and play music of the style you wish to play (wouldn't want to "open it up" with Celtic music if you're a bluegrass player!). Repeatedly do it overnight, much to the chagrin of anyone with whom you share the living space.
All of this is backed by sound science, of course. Oh, wait, no it's not. It's backed by philosophical arguments about how the skeptics can never prove that "opening up" isn't a thing. Not a single person to my knowledge has so much as recorded an instrument when new, then recorded it ten years later (and even that would be fraught when huge, uncontrollable variables). Because it's largely subjective anyway, and unlikely that any lab is going to take the time do blind tests, the debate will fill mandolin forums from now to the heat death of the universe. (Me, whether it's true or not, I think you better like the way an instrument sounds now before you buy it. And I do fall in the skeptical camp.)
One can see the phenomenon elsewhere, of course, with such things as holographic bracelets (a rehash of copper bracelets from the 70s) that are obviously complete bullshit, but are claimed to cure everything from the common cold to a soft penis. People will believe what they want to believe, and vendors will stand at the ready to profit from it.
I'm convinced it can happen with anything, especially if it's something that judging the results is largely subjective ("sounds better to me"). Take another example that's completely unrelated: mandolins. Do they "open up" (IOW, sound better) by being played over a period of time? Many raging debates on the relevant forums, and there are even devices sold in front of which you place your instrument, and the device produces sound so that the instrument will open up without you even playing it! Old school wisdom was that you set your instrument in front of your stereo speakers and play music of the style you wish to play (wouldn't want to "open it up" with Celtic music if you're a bluegrass player!). Repeatedly do it overnight, much to the chagrin of anyone with whom you share the living space.
All of this is backed by sound science, of course. Oh, wait, no it's not. It's backed by philosophical arguments about how the skeptics can never prove that "opening up" isn't a thing. Not a single person to my knowledge has so much as recorded an instrument when new, then recorded it ten years later (and even that would be fraught when huge, uncontrollable variables). Because it's largely subjective anyway, and unlikely that any lab is going to take the time do blind tests, the debate will fill mandolin forums from now to the heat death of the universe. (Me, whether it's true or not, I think you better like the way an instrument sounds now before you buy it. And I do fall in the skeptical camp.)
One can see the phenomenon elsewhere, of course, with such things as holographic bracelets (a rehash of copper bracelets from the 70s) that are obviously complete bullshit, but are claimed to cure everything from the common cold to a soft penis. People will believe what they want to believe, and vendors will stand at the ready to profit from it.