Re:Fabricator – modular website design system
by tariqr on Friday January 01, 2016 @05:48PM
(#10823875)
Great! Looks quite extensive and deeply thought-out at first glance. Respect for the discipline required to ship something like this by yourself. Keep at it :) Iterate till you win.
Some constructive criticism, if it helps: it takes a while to understand what this is. On the home page, if you can have two panes, some code on the left with your framework and output on the right to quickly get a grasp perhaps?
Re:Fabricator – modular website design system
by canyonero on Friday January 01, 2016 @09:15PM
(#10824635)
My two cents: I work for a medium-sized company that has used Fabricator to build UI component libraries for clients. In each project where Fabricator was used, the deliverable source code (CSS and JS) has been both messy and inconsistent. This is due to that fact that Fabricator does not assist or guide the developer when they develop CSS and JS for their modular design components. (See http://fbrctr.github.io/building-a-toolkit/assets.html) This diminishes any ability to reuse components/widgets/atoms etc across projects.
The tool does enforce and encourage atomic design architecture when it comes to HTML. At best, I'd describe Fabricator as a static-site/documentation generator. However, I wouldn't recommend using it Fabricator to generate documentation in the 'toolkit' way that's recommended in it the docs because it tightly couples that static site/documentation generation to UI library source. There are plenty of static site generators that work well for generating docs that I'd rather use (jekyll, hugo, etc).
I'd encourage developers considering Fabricator to proceed with caution. Although, it boasts ease of UI development based on atomic designs, the tool does not aide in code modularity or UI component re-usablity.
Re:Fabricator – modular website design system
by rrrx3 on Friday January 01, 2016 @10:04PM
(#10824762)
Interesting. Looking around at the source now, it looks like it's not optimized to imply that sort of architectural thinking. That's a bummer. I'd love to have seen it take the React style approach of co-locating all the relevant parts to a module together.
Re:Fabricator – modular website design system
by lukeaskew on Sunday January 03, 2016 @03:36PM
(#10832219)
Creator here. The lack of architectural direction is very much intentional. I'm a strong believer that those decisions will vary from project to project and developer to developer. My goal was to provide the least obtrusive set of tools as possible.
I do have some plans to create a boilerplate toolkit that includes some of the architectural patterns I use often. Hopefully that helps guide developers who are less experienced with building large modular systems.
Re:Fabricator – modular website design system
by hahamrfunnyguy on Saturday January 02, 2016 @07:17AM
(#10825970)
Nice looking design, but I had no clue what the tool was because I had clicked though too the documentation first! Also, say something about what problems pertaining to design guides this tool solves specifically somewhere front and center.
Re:Fabricator – modular website design system
by lukeaskew on Sunday January 03, 2016 @03:49PM
(#10832294)
Yikes. I haven't revisited the site copy/design since I launched it months ago. I'll see what I can do to make the messaging more clear. You're right, it takes a bit of digging to discover what Fabricator actually does.
Re:Fabricator – modular website design system
by TeMPOraL on Friday January 01, 2016 @05:07PM
(#10823705)
Because a big part of learning is reinventing the wheel. Bonus points for creating a whole new taxonomy for things that have decades-old names in the industry :).
Some constructive criticism, if it helps: it takes a while to understand what this is. On the home page, if you can have two panes, some code on the left with your framework and output on the right to quickly get a grasp perhaps?
Good luck!
The tool does enforce and encourage atomic design architecture when it comes to HTML. At best, I'd describe Fabricator as a static-site/documentation generator. However, I wouldn't recommend using it Fabricator to generate documentation in the 'toolkit' way that's recommended in it the docs because it tightly couples that static site/documentation generation to UI library source. There are plenty of static site generators that work well for generating docs that I'd rather use (jekyll, hugo, etc).
I'd encourage developers considering Fabricator to proceed with caution. Although, it boasts ease of UI development based on atomic designs, the tool does not aide in code modularity or UI component re-usablity.
I do have some plans to create a boilerplate toolkit that includes some of the architectural patterns I use often. Hopefully that helps guide developers who are less experienced with building large modular systems.
Edit: A UI toolkit-toolkit for building design systems.
http://fbrctr.github.io/getting-started/what-is-a-toolkit.ht...
Reading this I see a lot of things described by new names that we're used to know as "components", "modules" or "widgets".