- Apple avoiding paying taxes on foreign income to the USA
- Apple avoiding paying European taxes to anybody
Your argument holds weight on the former. However, it obfuscates the second, where Apple pays taxes on its European income at a rate of 0% to Ireland. That's a true outrage.
Apple doesn't write the rules. It's ridiculous to criticise them for them.
Being outraged at Apple is like being outraged at the weatherman about the weather.
Similar to basing a company in a US state without corporate income tax, and not owing income tax on sales made in other states. Though the difference is that Federal taxes in the US are much larger than state taxes, while there isn't a broad EU corporate income tax, is there?
"ASI [an Irish Apple subsidiary] buys Apple products from a Chinese manufacturer, resells them at a “substantial” markup to other Apple affiliates and retains the profits, the report said."
[1] http://www.macworld.com/article/2039299/senate-report-apple-...
Not that they're the only ones to play this game. A FMCG company I'm familiar with does something similar by having billions in raw and finished good materials owned by a Switzerland-based subsidiary for tax purposes.
The article you posted however gives no evidence that Apple is actually engaging in such practices, or I assume they would already be under criminal investigation. The closest thing in the article you cited is grandstanding by members of congress. (Who aren't even being serious, Congress could easily fine or stop Apple if they actually wanted to do anything).
"By running nearly all its non-U.S. sales through the Irish subsidiaries, Apple also avoids paying taxes on sales in other countries, including the U.K., Germany and France, the report said."
From what I can tell, this 'double Irish' arrangement does not apply to US sales.
Edit: Neither the Forbes article nor the Macworld article are discussing US sales, only worldwide sales.
The linked Forbes article is a great introduction, but unless I'm reading it wrong, it covers how Apple avoids US taxes on foreign sales, not US taxes on US sales. How exactly are they avoiding US taxes on US sales?
The US practice of taxing entities (corporations and people) on their global income based on citizenship instead of residency is just stupid, so Apple is in the legal and moral right here in my view.