News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by rdtsc on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @10:51AM (#10812498)
> In the case of the TV the service component wasn’t even mentioned at all until well after installing the bloody thing

Yap same here. Bought a TV (Vizio). Without agree-ing to their "we'll monitor everything about you" disclaimer couldn't connect it to the wifi, couldn't start any of the apps. So agreed to it. Then had set up rules in the router's firewall to block it and have to un-block it if I want to watch Netflix for example. What a pain. Supposedly I could make a more complicated rule to allow only netflix traffic and no other traffic from it...

There was no, "let me connect to Netflix" but don't auto-update anything, don't phone home, don't send metrics etc. It was all or nothing. And then of course the apps are slow, crappy, and buggy.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by parennoob on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @12:01PM (#10812963)
Wow, that makes me never want to buy a Vizio, ever. Although from what I hear, their apps are pretty bad anyway, so you'd probably be better off using an external box (Roku or AppleTV or Chromecast) for your Netflix et cetera. This assumes that said devices are not phoning back to their home, which might be a slippery assumption.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jkestner on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:21PM (#10814112)
Of course they are. But it's interesting that you and I care about who phones back home - why do we trust Roku more than Vizio? Is it that it feels "unnatural" for an existing object like a TV to change the relationship?

And of course, most people actually don't care about this.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by rdtsc on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:11PM (#10815010)
That is a good point, I have Roku as well in another room (connected to a "dumb" older TV). And yeah, I trust Roku more. And I trust Google -- I have a Gmail. Heck old work trusted Google with their internal discussion and files!

Thinking about it, I guess I made a (perhaps bad) bargain -- you can have my data if you give me something useful and working that I want back. Roku works and gives me something useful, working apps and I expected I had to do it when I bought it. Google gives me Gmail, so it can spy on me. Vizio gave me a TV, but I paid for it, and I didn't expect that it would need an invasive home phoning agreement to be usable.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by chadgeidel on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @01:28PM (#10813436)
"Phone home" is default for both Roku and AppleTV. Roku requires a username/password to enable the box. Same goes for AppleTV - you need to be signed into iTunes to even get anything to work.

At least Apple provides regular updates.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by slavik81 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @02:24PM (#10813778)
Samsung gives you a bunch of different agreements to agree to or dismiss. I chose not to agree to sending my media information to Samsung, nor voice data. The remainder of the TV's features work fine.